Avril Lavigne Replacement Conspiracy Theory - Wikipedia

Hoax claiming musician Avril Lavigne is dead

A conspiracy theory that originated in 2011 states that Canadian singer Avril Lavigne died by suicide in 2003, shortly after the release of her debut album, Let Go (2002), and was replaced by a body double named Melissa Vandella. Evidence used to support the theory include changes in Lavigne's appearance between 2003 and the present, supposed subliminal messaging in her follow-up album, Under My Skin (2004), and a photoshoot in which Lavigne has the name "Melissa" written on her hand. The theory is the subject of the BBC Sounds podcast Who Replaced Avril Lavigne?[1]

The origins of the theory can be traced back to the 2011 Brazilian blog Avril Está Morta (transl. Avril Is Dead), which led to conversations on Internet forums sharing supposed evidence of Lavigne's replacement. The theory gained more traction in May 2017, when a Twitter user posted a thread recounting the theory. Lavigne herself has denied the theory on multiple occasions.

Origins

[edit] Lavigne performing in 2002 (left) and in 2011 (right), the year that the Avril Está Morta blog formed

The origins of the replacement theory can be dated back to 2011, with a Brazilian blog named Avril Está Morta, or Avril Is Dead, although some sources say that the rumour dates back as far as 2005.[2][3] The theory alleges that the pressures of fame, combined with the death of Lavigne's grandfather, sent her into a deep depression after the release of her 2002 debut album, Let Go, and that the singer died by suicide shortly after.[4]

According to the conspiracy theory, a look-alike named "Melissa" was originally hired to distract paparazzi, protecting a reclusive Lavigne. It alleges that Lavigne befriended "Melissa", that shortly before the singer's supposed death her body double was taught how to sing and perform like the musician,[5] that after Lavigne's death her record company buried the news and replaced her with "Melissa Vandella" for a continued profit, and that "Melissa" recorded all of Lavigne's future work.[6] Much of the evidence cited in support of the conspiracy theory is the purported appearance and disappearance of various moles and other skin blemishes in pictures of Lavigne over time,[4] as well as a promotional photoshoot in which she has the name "Melissa" written on her hand.[7]

The conspiracy theory soon gained traction on Internet forums such as ATRL and Godlike Productions, where self-proclaimed "Avril Rangers" shared evidence. One ATRL post in 2012 suggested that the original Avril may actually be alive, using a picture of what appeared to be the singer buying cheese at a time when "new Avril" was supposedly battling Lyme disease.[8] In addition to the changes in her appearance, the theory alleges that the title and artwork for her second album, Under My Skin, and the lyrics of songs like "My Happy Ending", "Together", and "The Best Years of Our Lives" by Evan Taubenfeld are subliminal messaging.[9][10] The original blog further suggests that Melissa feels guilt over "participating in this farce", leading to the subliminal messaging.[11]

Rise in popularity

[edit]

The theory began to gain traction in the United States in October 2015, when BuzzFeed reporter Ryan Broderick tweeted about Avril Está Morta.[12] In a BuzzFeed post, Broderick cleared up his tweet on the matter, mentioning that the opening line of the original blog post admits that the theory is a hoax, and that "This blog was created to show how conspiracy theories can look true."[12]

The death hoax saw increased prevalence in May 2017, when a high school student posted a Twitter thread alleging that Lavigne had died and been replaced in late 2003. The thread, which was retweeted over 250,000 times, cited discrepancies in the singer's face, fashion style, and handwriting as evidence of her death and replacement.[13] The Twitter thread largely corresponds with the earlier Avril Está Morta conspiracy, except that it asserts that Under My Skin was created using pre-existing recordings of the real Lavigne.[14]

The Twitter thread inspired an Internet meme in which users would say that a celebrity or fictional character died and was replaced, showing two pictures of the figure in question and titling it "a conspiracy theory thread".[15]

Response

[edit]

The first time Lavigne was asked about the rumours was in 2014 during an interview for the Brazilian TV show Pânico na Band, during The Avril Lavigne Tour. Lavigne was asked if she had heard about online rumours claiming she "had died and was replaced by a clone", to which she replied by saying that the first time she was hearing about it was in this interview, and later added, "Well, I'm here, and I'm here in Brazil". In a video of the interview uploaded to the official YouTube channel of the TV show, it's possible to see images of the blog page Avril Está Morta responsible for starting the rumours.[16] After the theory resurfaced globally in 2017, Lavigne addressed the rumours in a November 2017 Facebook live stream Q&A, when a fan asked whether she was dead, to which Lavigne responded, "No, I'm not dead. I'm here."[17] She went on to say that the theory was spawned because "people are just bored and need something to talk about".[17] The question was broached again in a November 2018 interview with Australia's KIIS 106.5. When asked about the theory, the singer responded, "Some people think that I'm not the real me, which is so weird! Like, why would they even think that?"[18]

Radio hosts Kyle and Jackie O said that Lavigne "never actually flat out denied" that she had been replaced, and suggested that technological difficulties during the interview were a suspicious coincidence.[18] In a 2019 interview with Entertainment Weekly, Lavigne addressed the theory directly, calling it a "dumb internet rumor" and saying that she was "flabbergasted that people bought into it".[19] Lavigne addressed the rumour once again in a 2022 interview for Galore Magazine, stating "So it's funny because everyone says I look the same, but then there's that. That doesn't make any sense. Also, how random? When people bring it up, and it's been brought up to me for like, years, that there's this conspiracy theory that I'm not me or something? I'm a clone? How did something like that get so—I don't know, it's just the weirdest rumour."[20] The creator of the blog that originated the Avril Está Morta conspiracy has apologized and changed the whole blog post to state that Avril has not died yet, and that the blog was a way of showing how conspiracy theories may seem true.[21]

In 2013, a separate death hoax alleged that Lavigne died in a snowboarding accident at the Whistler Blackcomb ski resort.[22]

See also

[edit]

• Paul is dead, a similar conspiracy theory involving Paul McCartney
• Melania Trump replacement conspiracy theory

References

[edit]

1. ^ Heritage, Stuart (February 28, 2024). "Is Avril Lavigne really dead? The rollicking podcast taking on the internet's wildest rumour". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved March 22, 2024.
2. ^ Rohwedder, Kristie (February 11, 2019). "Avril Lavigne Can't Believe *That* Death Hoax Is Still A Thing Either". Bustle. Archived from the original on March 29, 2019. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
3. ^ Cresci, Elena (May 16, 2017). "Why fans think Avril Lavigne died and was replaced by a clone named Melissa". The Guardian. Archived from the original on July 15, 2022. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
4. ^ a b Song, Sandra (October 1, 2015). "A Conspiracy Theory Says Avril Lavigne Is Dead And Has Been Replaced By A Doppelganger". Paper. Archived from the original on October 28, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
5. ^ Purdom, Clayton (May 15, 2017). "The world is now convinced that Avril Lavigne is dead". The A.V. Club. Archived from the original on November 15, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
6. ^ Rafferty, Scott (May 15, 2017). "The Avril Lavigne Death Hoax That Won't Die". Rolling Stone. Archived from the original on January 24, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
7. ^ Bassil, Ryan (October 1, 2015). "Investigating the Conspiracy That Says Avril Lavigne Was Killed off and Replaced with an Actress". Noisey by Vice. Archived from the original on February 7, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
8. ^ Feinberg, Ashley (October 2, 2015). "Did Avril Lavigne Die in 2003?: An Internet Conspiracy, Explained". Gawker. Archived from the original on November 14, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
9. ^ "Is Avril Lavigne Really Dead? Assessing The Endless Rumours About Her 'Imposter'". NMEP. May 15, 2017. Archived from the original on February 9, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
10. ^ "Is Avril Lavigne Really Dead? Assessing the Endless Rumours About Her 'Imposter'". NME. May 15, 2017. Archived from the original on February 9, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
11. ^ Gilbride, Tricia (May 15, 2017). "The Avril Lavigne conspiracy theory that hasn't died yet, just like Avril Lavigne". Mashable. Archived from the original on December 24, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
12. ^ a b Broderick, Ryan (October 2, 2015). "Here's How I Accidentally Made An Old Avril Lavigne Death Hoax Go Viral". BuzzFeed. Archived from the original on January 29, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
13. ^ Estatie, Lamia (May 15, 2017). "The Avril Lavigne conspiracy theory returns". BBC News. Archived from the original on January 3, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
14. ^ Dickman, Maggie (May 15, 2017). "This Avril Lavigne conspiracy theory has returned, and the internet is freaking out". Alternative Press. Archived from the original on February 6, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
15. ^ Shamsian, Jacob (May 17, 2017). "The internet is having a field day with a crazy conspiracy theory that Avril Lavigne died and was replaced with someone else". Business Insider. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
16. ^ "Avril Lavigne Dança Beijinho No Ombro". YouTube. January 30, 2015. Archived from the original on September 20, 2022. Retrieved September 20, 2022.
17. ^ a b Michallon, Clemence (November 2, 2018). "Avril Lavigne responds to conspiracy theory that she died years ago and was replaced by lookalike". The Independent. Archived from the original on November 21, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
18. ^ a b "Avril Lavigne confronts conspiracy theory that she's a clone". Alternative Press. November 1, 2018. Archived from the original on February 12, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
19. ^ Kaplan, Ilana (February 11, 2019). "Avril Lavigne on Head Above Water, near-death experiences, and that crazy conspiracy theory". Entertainment Weekly. Archived from the original on January 22, 2021. Retrieved March 9, 2021.
20. ^ "Avril Lavigne Is Still The Motherf*cking (Pop-Punk) Princess". Galore Magazine. January 17, 2022. Archived from the original on February 18, 2022. Retrieved September 2, 2022.
21. ^ Crews, Tyler (April 2, 2018). "Who is Avril Lavigne? Or Should We Say Melissa?". Washington Square News. Archived from the original on August 6, 2022. Retrieved August 6, 2022.
22. ^ Francis, Nathan (December 25, 2017). "Avril Lavigne Dead? Bizarre Conspiracy Theory About Singer's Suicide Goes Viral". Inquisitr. Archived from the original on November 8, 2020. Retrieved March 9, 2021.

v t e Avril Lavigne
Awards and nominations Discography Promotional tours Songs
Studio albums	Let Go Under My Skin The Best Damn Thing Goodbye Lullaby Avril Lavigne Head Above Water Love Sux
Live albums	My World
Compilations	Greatest Hits
Video albums	Avril Lavigne: My World Bonez Tour 2005: Live at Budokan The Best Damn Tour: Live in Toronto
Singles	"Complicated" "Sk8er Boi" "I'm with You" "Losing Grip" "Mobile" "Don't Tell Me" "My Happy Ending" "Nobody's Home" "He Wasn't" "Fall to Pieces" "Keep Holding On" "Girlfriend" "When You're Gone" "Hot" "The Best Damn Thing" "Alice" "What the Hell" "Smile" "Wish You Were Here" "Here's to Never Growing Up" "Rock n Roll" "Let Me Go" "Hello Kitty" "Give You What You Like" "Fly" "Head Above Water" "Tell Me It's Over" "Dumb Blonde" "I Fell in Love with the Devil" "We Are Warriors" "Bite Me" "Love It When You Hate Me" "I'm a Mess" "Fake as Hell" "Young & Dumb"
Featured singles	"Wavin' Flag" "Lean on Me" "Flames" "Can You Die from a Broken Heart" "77"
Promotional singles	"Basket Case" "Knockin' on Heaven's Door" "I Always Get What I Want" "Take Me Away" "O Holy Night" "I Will Be" "Push" "Bad Reputation" "How You Remind Me" "Baby, It's Cold Outside" "Bois Lie"
Other songs	"Bad Girl" "Get Over Me" "Breakaway"
Concert tours	Try to Shut Me Up Tour The Best Damn Tour The Avril Lavigne Tour Head Above Water Tour Love Sux Tour Greatest Hits Tour
Related articles	Replacement conspiracy theory Steve Ferlazzo Matt Brann Jesse Colburn Mark Spicoluk Closet Monster Evan Taubenfeld Charles Moniz Devin Bronson Jim McGorman
Category

v t e Conspiracy theories
List of conspiracy theories
Overview Core topics Antiscience Cabals deep state éminence grise power behind the throne Conspiracy Civil Criminal Political Crisis actors Deception Dystopia Espionage Global catastrophe scenarios Hidden message Pseudohistory Pseudoscience Secrecy Secret societies Urban legends and myths Psychology Attitude polarization Cognitive dissonance Communal reinforcement Confirmation bias Denialism Locus of control Manipulation Mass psychogenic illness moral panics Paranoia Psychological projection
Astronomy and outer space 2012 phenomenon Nibiru cataclysm Ancient astronauts Expanding Earth Apollo Moon landings Flat Earth Hollow Earth Hollow Moon Reptilians UFOs(Alleged aliens) Alien abduction Area 51 Black Knight satellite Cryptoterrestrial / Extraterrestrial / Interdimensional hypothesis Dulce Base Estimate of the Situation (1948) Lake Michigan Triangle MJ-12 Men in black Nazi UFOs Die Glocke Project Serpo Hoaxes Dundy County (1884) Maury Island (1947) Roswell (1947) Twin Falls (1947) Aztec, New Mexico (1949) Southern England (1967) Ilkley Moor (1987) Gulf Breeze (1987–88) Alien autopsy (1995) Morristown (2009)
Deaths and disappearances Assassination / suicide theories Zachary Taylor (1850) Ludwig II of Bavaria (1886) Louis Le Prince (1890) Lord Kitchener (1916) Tom Thomson (1917) Władysław Sikorski (1943) Benito Mussolini (1945) Adolf Hitler (1945) Subhas Chandra Bose (1945) Johnny Stompanato (1958) Marilyn Monroe (1962) John F. Kennedy (1963) Lee Harvey Oswald (1963) Lal Bahadur Shastri (1966) Harold Holt (1967) Martin Luther King Jr. (1968) Robert F. Kennedy (1968) Salvador Allende (1973) Aldo Moro (1978) Renny Ottolina (1978) Pope John Paul I (1978) Airey Neave (1979) Olof Palme (1986) Zia-ul-Haq (1988) GEC-Marconi scientists (1980s–90s) Turgut Özal (1993) Vince Foster (1993) Kurt Cobain (1994) Yitzhak Rabin (1995) Diana, Princess of Wales (1997) Vatican murders (1998) Nepalese royal family (2001) Yasser Arafat (2004) Benazir Bhutto (2007) Osama bin Laden (2011) Hugo Chávez (2013) Seth Rich (2016) Alejandro Castro (2018) Jeffrey Epstein (2019) Chan Yin-lam (2019) Sushant Singh Rajput (2020) John McAfee (2021) Accidents / disasters Mary Celeste (1872) RMS Titanic (1912) Great Kantō earthquake (1923) Lynmouth Flood (1952) Dyatlov Pass (1959) Lost Cosmonauts (1950s–60s) JAT Flight 367 (1972) United Air Lines Flight 553 (1972) Itavia Flight 870 (1980) South African Airways Flight 295 (1987) Khamar-Daban (1993) MS Estonia (1994) TWA Flight 800 (1996) EgyptAir Flight 990 (1999) Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 (2014) Other cases Joan of Arc (1431) Roanoke Colony (1585) Yemenite children (1948–54) Elvis Presley (1977) Jonestown (1978) Body double hoax Paul McCartney Avril Lavigne Vladimir Putin Melania Trump
Energy, environment Agenda 21 Climate change denial false theories Free energy suppression Red mercury United States California drought manipulation HAARP 2024 Atlantic hurricanes Camp Fire disinformation
False flag allegations USS Maine (1898) RMS Lusitania (1915) Reichstag fire (1933) Pearl Harbor (1941) USS Liberty (1967) Lufthansa Flight 615 (1972) Widerøe Flight 933 (1982) KAL Flight 007 (1983) Mozambican presidential jet (1986) Pan Am Flight 103 (1988) Oklahoma City bombing (1995) 9/11 attacks (2001) advance knowledge WTC collapse Madrid train bombing (2004) London bombings (2005) Smolensk air disaster (2010) Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 (2014) Denial of the 7 October attacks (2023)
Gender and sexuality Alpha/beta males Anti-LGBTQ Anti-gender movement Chemicals Drag panic Gay agenda Gay bomb Gay Nazis myth HIV/AIDS stigma United States Homintern Lavender Scare Recruitment Grooming Litter box hoax Transvestigation Finger pinching Gamergate Ideology in incel communities Larries / Gaylors Satanic panic Soy and masculinity
Health 5G misinformation Anti-vaccination Autism MMR Thiomersal In chiropractic Misinformation Aspartame Big Pharma Chemtrails COVID-19 Ivermectin Lab leak Vaccines Turbo cancer In Canada / Philippines / United States Ebola Electronic harassment Germ theory denialism GMOs HIV/AIDS denialism Origins theories Oral polio AIDS hypothesis Lepers' plot Medbeds SARS (2003) Water fluoridation Pont-Saint-Esprit mass poisoning
Race, religion, ethnicity Bhagwa Love Trap CERN ritual hoax COVID-19 and xenophobia Freemasons French Revolution [fr] Gas chambers for Poles in Warsaw (1940s) Prisoners of war Germans (post-WWII) Priory of Sion Product labeling Halal Kosher Tartarian Empire War against Islam White genocide Antisemitic Andinia Plan Blood libel Cohen Plan Doctors' plot During the Black Death Epsilon Team George Soros Holocaust denial Trivialization International Jewish conspiracy Committee of 300 Cultural Bolshevism / Jewish Bolshevism Żydokomuna Judeo-Masonic plot The Protocols of the Elders of Zion World War II Z.O.G. Judeopolonia Killing of Jesus Kalergi Plan New World Order Rothschilds Stab-in-the-back myth Christian Bible conspiracy theory Christian persecution complex Christ myth theory Caesar’s Messiah Jesus bloodline Anti-Christian Anti-Catholic Vatican John Paul Giuseppe Siri Popish Plot Jesuits Islamophobic Counter-jihad Bihar human sacrifice Eurabia Great Replacement Love jihad Proposed "Islamo-leftism" inquiry Trojan Horse scandal Genocide denial /Denial of mass killings Armenian Assyrian Bangladesh Bosnian Cambodian Gaza Pallywood The Holocaust Holodomor Nanjing Rwandan Serbs during WWII
Regional Asia India Cow vigilante violence Pakistan Jinnahpur Philippines Tallano gold South Korea Finger-pinching Thailand Finland Plot Americas(outside the United States) Argentina Andinia Plan Canada Avro Arrow cancellation Trudeau-Castro conspiracy Leuchter report Peru Casa Matusita Venezuela Daktari Ranch affair Golpe Azul Middle East / North Africa In the Arab world 10 agorot Cairo fire Kissinger Plan in Lebanon Israel-related animal theories Iran Western-backed Iranian Revolution Israel Pallywood Russia Alaska payment Dulles' Plan Golden billion Petrograd Military Organization Rasputin Ukraine bioweapons Turkey 2016 coup attempt Ergenekon Operation Sledgehammer Gezi Park protests Sèvres syndrome Üst akıl Other European Euromyth Georgia Global War Party Germany Vril Society Ireland German Plot Lithuania Statesmen Roman Republic First Catilinarian conspiracy Spain Mano Negra affair Sweden Lilla Saltsjöbadsavtalet UK Clockwork Orange plot Elm Guest House Harold Wilson Voting pencil United States 4 AM club Barack Obama Citizenship Religion Parentage "Obamagate" / Spygate Biden–Ukraine Black helicopters CIA and JFK CIA assistance to bin Laden Clinton body count Cultural Marxism Election denial movement FBI secret society FEMA camps Georgia Guidestones Jade Helm 15 Montauk Project Philadelphia Experiment Pizzagate The Plan Project Azorian QAnon Pastel Incidents Saddam–al-Qaeda Sandy Hook (2012) Springfield pet-eating hoax Trump–Ukraine "Vast right-wing conspiracy" Vietnam War POW/MIA issue / Stab-in-the-back myth 2020 election Italygate "Pence Card" Maricopa County ballot audit Stop the Steal
Other Dead Internet theory NESARA/GESARA New Coke Phantom time / New chronology Shadow government claims Bilderberg Illuminati New World Order synarchism Shakespearean authorship Pseudolaw Admiralty law Freeman on the land movement Redemption movement Sovereign citizens Strawman theory Tax protesters Satirical Acre Bielefeld Birds Aren't Real Li's field Ted Cruz–Zodiac Killer meme Epstein didn't kill himself
See also Argument from ignorance Conspiracy Encyclopedia Conspiracy fiction Conspirituality Dogma pseudoskepticism Falsifiability Fringe science Historical negationism Online youth radicalization Paranormal Prejudice Hate speech Radicalization Science by press conference Superstition