Best Soy Sauce Substitutes: 7 Alternatives And A DIY Recipe - Greatist

Maybe your like

Greatist

NUTRITION

We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s our process

What’s the Best Soy Sauce Substitute? 7 Alternatives That Taste Soy Good

Medically reviewed by Kathy W. Warwick, RDN, CDCES, Nutrition — Written by Leandra Beabout — Updated on September 12, 2024

What is soy sauce?
Soy sauce substitutes
DIY substitute recipe

Looking for a substitute for soy sauce? Whether you’re avoiding gluten, cutting down on sodium, or just out of soy sauce, we’ve got you covered. Discover 7 alternatives that deliver the salty, savory flavor you crave.

Looking for a stellar soy sauce substitute? Whether you’re avoiding yet another grocery store run (yeah, we see you) or looking for an alternative that’s gluten-free or low sodium, you have some options.

We’ve rounded up seven solid soy sauce replacements that still offer that salty, savory flavor your sushi and stir-fry can’t live without.

What exactly is soy sauce?

Soy sauce — also known as shoju — is a brown liquid that’s made from fermented soybeans and packs a salty, umami flavor.

Originally from China, the condiment has been used in East Asian and Southeast Asian cuisines for thousands of years. And it makes a mean marinade for grilling. 🔥

There are dozens of soy sauces on the market, but they pretty much all consist of these 5 ingredients:

soybeans
wheat
salt
water
bacteria strains (It’s fermented, remember?)

But while it is delicious, soy sauce poses a problem for folks with soy or wheat sensitivities.

Folks watching their sodium intake might also want to steer clear of this pantry staple — 1 tablespoon of regular soy sauce has almost 40 percent of the recommended Daily Value (DV) for sodium. Lower sodium versions are available but still have about 22 percent of the DV per tablespoon.

Best soy sauce substitutes

Avoiding soy, wheat, or extra sodium doesn’t mean you need to ditch every recipe that calls for soy sauce. Here are some dope alternatives.

1. Tamari

Share on Pinterest

Tamari, also called shoyu, is a fermented Japanese soy product. The difference between this and soy sauce is simple: Tamari is made without wheat. That’s a #win for the gluten-free crowd.

Tamari is probably the most straightforward soy sauce swap. It contains comparable ingredients that are processed similarly. That means it’s *still* pretty dang salty, though. The lack of wheat translates to heftier umami flavor too.

Use tamari like you’d use any soy sauce. But if you’re severely sensitive to gluten, check your labels. Some tamari is made in facilities that also process wheat.

How to sub: Swap tamari for soy sauce at a 1:1 ratio.

Buy tamari sauce at Amazon

2. Coconut aminos

Share on Pinterest

Coconut aminos is a dark brown, slightly sweet and salty sauce made from fermented coconut plant sap.

This condiment is a major player in the soy sauce substitute arena. And it’s a great option for folks with multiple food sensitivities.

Coconut aminos is:

soy-free
wheat-free
gluten-free
vegan
lower in sodium than soy sauce

Swap coconut aminos for the soy sauce in salad dressings, dipping sauces, and marinades.

How to sub: Swap coconut aminos for soy sauce at a 1:1 ratio.

Buy coconut aminos at Amazon

3. Fish sauce

Share on Pinterest

Like soy sauce, fish sauce gets VIP status in Southeast Asian dishes. Also like soy sauce, it’s fermented and offers that umami flavor.

So, what’s the diff? Fish sauce is made from fermented fish aminos instead of fermented soybean. That makes it taste hella bright and briny.

Fish sauce makes a strong soy sauce alternative for folks who enjoy fishy flavor and don’t mind a hefty dose of sodium. But not all fish sauces are gluten-free, so check your nutrition labels. You’ll also want to skip this one if you’re vegetarian or vegan — the name says it all.

How to sub: Swap fish sauce for soy sauce at a 1:1 ratio.

Buy fish sauce at Amazon

4. Worcestershire sauce

Share on Pinterest

Worcestershire sauce is made from a fermented blend of ingredients like sugar, anchovies, salt, spices, and vinegar. Originating from England, it has a different flavor profile that’s a little less umami and a little more tang. If that’s your jam, Worcestershire sauce might become your new fave broth and marinade ingredient.

Worcestershire sauce doesn’t have as much salt as soy sauce — a win for folks who are watching their sodium levels. But it also means you might need to play around with salt and spice measurements.

Because Worcestershire has more sugar than some other options, it may not be the best choice for those who are counting carbs.

Also, with anchovies in the mix, it’s not usually vegan-friendly — but some vegan versions are available.

How to sub: If you’re OK with tartness, swap Worcestershire sauce for soy sauce at a 1:1 ratio. If you prefer less tang, use a little less Worcestershire and add a sprinkle of salt for good measure.

Buy Worcestershire sauce at Amazon

5. Liquid aminos

Share on Pinterest

Liquid aminos is a dark, salty sauce made from unfermented soybeans — so it’s *not* soy-free. But it is vegan, gluten-free, and alcohol-free.

Because it’s made will soybeans, it offers a pretty comparable swap in recipes, but it has a slightly milder, sweeter taste than soy sauce. It also contains more sodium.

How to sub: Swap liquid aminos for soy sauce at a 1:1 ratio.

Buy liquid aminos at Amazon

6. Miso

Share on Pinterest

Miso is a fermented paste made from soybeans, grain, koji (a mold), and salt — so it’s not always gluten-free.

You’ll notice that miso’s flavor is milder than those of most soy sauces. But the more significant difference between these two products is texture.

TBH, replacing a liquid with a paste isn’t always easy. Your success will depend on the recipe. Still, miso can be a solid soy sauce substitute that also adds some protein to recipes.

How to sub: Swap miso with soy sauce at a 1:2 ratio (more miso to match the flavor) *or* thin the miso paste with liquid aminos and use the liquid as a 1:1 swap.

Buy miso at Amazon

7. Oyster sauce

Share on Pinterest

Stir salt, sugar, and a thickening agent into caramelized oyster extract and voila! You have oyster sauce.

This dark, syrupy sauce adds a similarly complex flavor to Asian and Southeast Asian dishes with less sodium than soy sauce. But the flavor is a bit more sweet and salty than umami (and, unlike with fish sauce, you don’t have to worry about a strong fish flavor).

Just check your labels if you’re trying to swap oyster sauce for soy sauce because of a food sensitivity. Some oyster sauces contain soy and gluten.

And, as with the other seafood-based sauces, you’ll want to go with a different option if you’re vegetarian or vegan.

How to sub: You can swap oyster sauce with soy sauce at a 1:1 ratio, but don’t expect an exact flavor match.

Buy oyster sauce at Amazon

What about a soy sauce substitute recipe?

Wanna whip up your very own soy sauce swap? We trawled the supermarket for ingredients with umami oomph, compared a slew of soy sauce substitution concoctions, and created a soy sauce alternative of our own.

Here’s what you need to create about 1 cup of faux soy sauce.

Ingredients

1 cup beef broth or vegetable broth (low sodium if you prefer)
2–3 dried shiitake mushrooms
2 tablespoons apple cider vinegar
1 tablespoon dark molasses
1/4 teaspoon salt
Pinch of ground black pepper

Instructions

Bring broth to a boil in a saucepan on the stovetop.
Dump mushrooms into boiling broth, cover tightly, then remove from heat.
Allow mushrooms to soak for 20 minutes, then remove them with a slotted spoon and set them aside to use in another recipe.
Add all remaining ingredients to the mushroom-infused broth and place back on the heat.
Simmer mixture for 10 minutes.
Remove from heat, let cool, and then store in an airtight container.

Takeaway

Soy sauce is a common ingredient in Asian and Southeast Asian dishes. It infuses food with a complex salty, umami flavor created by fermenting soybeans and wheat.

Folks with dietary restrictions can use alternative liquids like tamari, fish sauce, and more. But it’s essential to consider sodium content, flavor profile, and liquid consistency to find the best swap for your recipe.

4 sourcescollapsed

Diez-Simon C, et al. (2020). Chemical and sensory characteristics of soy sauce: A review.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7581291/
Mushrooms & umami. (n.d.).https://www.mushroomcouncil.org/all-about-mushrooms/umami/
Sodium in your diet. (2022).https://www.fda.gov/food/nutrition-education-resources-materials/sodium-your-diet
U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. (2019). FoodData Central.https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/index.html

FEEDBACK:

Medically reviewed by Kathy W. Warwick, RDN, CDCES, Nutrition — Written by Leandra Beabout — Updated on September 12, 2024

Wellness

Health Conditions

Food

Recipes

Fitness

Workouts

Product Reviews

Series

How-To

The Greatist Community

About Greatist

NUTRITION

What exactly is soy sauce?

Best soy sauce substitutes

1. Tamari

2. Coconut aminos

3. Fish sauce

4. Worcestershire sauce

5. Liquid aminos

6. Miso

7. Oyster sauce

What about a soy sauce substitute recipe?

Ingredients

Instructions

Takeaway

Read this next

Contact