Captain Marvel Fans Have A Pretty Solid Theory About Nick Fury's Eye

SearchSearchClose
  • Subscribe
  • My Bookmarks
  • Entertainment
  • Style
  • Food
  • Drinks
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • News & Politics
  • Archive
  • Newsletter
  • About Us
  • Follow
  • Other Editions
Skip to Contentsign inSubscribeSearchSearchLogosign inSubscribeSearchCloseLogo
  • Privacy NoticeTerms Of Use
xtiktokyoutubefacebookinstagrampinterestsign inSubscribe
  • More
Forehead, Nose, Human, Fictional character, Movie,
Marvel

Since we first saw him in the post-credit scene of 2008's Iron Man, the Nick Fury we've known has had one eye. And for more than a decade the story of how he lost that eye has remained a mystery. Captain Marvel changed all of that. In the latest Marvel outing, Carol Danvers crash lands on Earth, where she teams up with a young, two-eyed '90s-era Nick Fury to get involved in the intergalactic Skrull-Kree war.

Related Stories
  • Samuel L. Jackson Operates Like He Owns the Place
  • The 'Captain Marvel' Soundtrack Is a '90s Dream
  • 'Captain Marvel' Re-Writes its Own History

At the end of it all, when the battle is over, we finally learn how Nick Fury lost his eye. He's playing with the very good kitty Goose, when the cat/Flerken scratches the eye right out of his head. Even though Fury is presented with an assortment of replacement eyes, he chooses to wear an eye patch instead. Why would he do this with all of the technology in the Marvel Cinematic Universe? It's certainly not a fashion choice, right?

One Reddit user posed an interesting theory that Fury chose to not use a prosthetic eye because he wants to defend himself from Skrull duplication:

My theory is that Nick chose to keep his disfigured eye and cover it throughout his SHIELD career in order to protect himself and SHIELD if he was ever simmed. In the MCU, Talos states he has to see something to sim it to the point of a DNA match, and since Fury's eye isn't genetic, its actual appearance is available only to him and the backup security parameters he placed in SHIELD. Fury had been trying to protect Earth from Alien invasion long before The Avengers, it only make sense that'd he'd take steps against the two alien species he already knew of, Kree and Skrulls, especially in the way of preventing theft of his own identity like Talos did to his boss.

It's a pretty believable theory—one that turns a potential Nick Fury weakness into a strength, which is a play on a classic superhero trope. But, again, it's also worth noting that the eye patch does make him look pretty damn cool.

Watch Next Play IconForehead, Nose, Human, Fictional character, Movie, Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Marvel New Releases 2025: Marvel Studios & Disney Projects

celebrity sightings in glasgow august 3, 2025

Tom Holland ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ Interview

spiderman

Why Spider-Man’s New Movie Costume Is a Big Deal

superman

Are Superhero Movies Actually Good Again?

pedro pascal in 'the fantastic four first steps'

‘The Fantastic Four’ Post-Credits Scene, Explained

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below2024 san diego international comic con day 3 panels

Every Marvel Studios Project Announced So Far

pedro pascal as reed richards/mister fantastic in 20th century studios/marvel studios' the fantastic four: first steps. photo courtesy of marvel studios. © 2025 20th century studios / © and ™ 2025 marvel

‘The Fantastic Four’ Is Breezy and Beautiful

vanessa kirby as sue storm/invisible woman in 20th century studios/marvel studios' the fantastic four: first steps. photo courtesy of 20th century studios/marvel studios. © 2025 20th century studios / © and ™ 2025 marvel.

Marvel Cinematic Universe Movies, Ranked

mephisto (sacha baron cohen) in marvel television's ironheart, exclusively on disney+. photo courtesy of marvel. © 2025 marvel. all rights reserved.

Does Anyone Care That the MCU Introduced Mephisto?

alexei shostakov/red guardian (david harbour) in marvel studios' thunderbolts*. photo by chuck zlotnick. © 2025 marvel.

Does ‘Thunderbolts’ Have a Post-Credits Scene?

lewis pullman

Lewis Pullman on 'Thunderbolts*,' Style, and More

yelena belova (florence pugh) in marvel studios' thunderbolts*. photo courtesy of marvel studios. © 2025 marvel.

Why Marvel’s ‘Thunderbolts*’ Is Actually Very Good

the imdb official portrait studio at d23 2022

Julius Onah on ‘Captain America: Brave New World’

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Tag » How Did Fury Lose His Eye