Does Stroke Order Matter? - WordReference Forums

• Forums Rules/Help/FAQ Help/FAQ Members Current visitors Interface Language

Dictionary search: English-Spanish English-French English-Italian English-German English-Dutch English-Russian English-Portuguese English-Polish English-Romanian English-Swedish English-Czech English-Greek English-Turkish English-Chinese English-Japanese English-Korean English-Arabic Spanish-English French-English Italian-English German-English Dutch-English Russian-English Portuguese-English Polish-English Romanian-English Swedish-English Czech-English Greek-English Turkish-English Chinese-English Japanese-English Korean-English Arabic-English Spanish-French Spanish-Portuguese Spanish-Catalan French-Spanish Portuguese-Spanish English definition English synonyms English collocations English usage Italian definition Spanish definition Spanish synonyms Catalan definition Spanish conjugation French conjugation Italian conjugation English conjugation Log in Register What's new Search

Search

This forum This thread Threads Everywhere Search titles and first posts only Search titles only Note By: Search Advanced search…

• Rules/Help/FAQ Help/FAQ
• Members Current visitors
• Interface Language

Menu Log in Register Install the app Install How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

• Other Language Forums
• 中文+方言 (Chinese)

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.You should upgrade or use an alternative browser. Does stroke order matter?

• Thread starter Thread starter Scharrelkip
• Start date Start date Jan 21, 2012

S

Scharrelkip

New Member

Los Países Bajos Nederlands - Nederland Hello I found the nín character very hard to write, so I searched on google for a simple tutorial. I now know how to write it, but someone replied with that the stroke order was wrong. Does this really matter? I mean, isn't the result that matters? Thanks in advance and greetings, Scharrelkip

xiaolijie

Senior Member

UK English (UK)

I mean, isn't the result that matters? Click to expand...

Yes, the result matters; and the result is the result of good stroke order. Imagine you writing the Latin alphabet all in the wrong order. Nobody would then be able to understand what you write when you write it at normal speed (and you won't be able to understand theirs!). Chinese only accentuates this ten times or even worse. My advice for starting learners of Chinese: If you want to learn to write, don't take shortcuts. Last edited: Jan 21, 2012

ouzhantekin

Senior Member

Izmir/ 伊兹密尔 Turkish - Standard I also would like to contribute to this by saying that in my opinion, paying attention to the stroke order while writing is essential because your hands and the nerves in your hands also learns along with you, so that after practice when you write the same character next time you will feel like your hand is goin forth already without you thinking too much..

ouzhantekin

Senior Member

Izmir/ 伊兹密尔 Turkish - Standard And believe me "nin" is not really hard to write S

strad

Senior Member

Taiwan English (American) There are quite a few characters that i write using incorrect stroke order, but my written chinese is very legible so i never thought it was important to learn the correct stroke order. However, I now use the handwriting input method on my iPhone, and stroke order is VERY important for how the software recognizes what you write. I can write a very clear character using my incorrect stroke order and the software often fails to find the character I want, while my friends or relatives can scribble a barely legible cursive mess using the correct order and the software recognizes it everytime So yes, i would try to learn the correct order when learning new characters. T

terredepomme

Senior Member

Korean And keep in mind that there are tricky stroke orders as well... For example 心 and 必 have completely different stroke orders. (But you can technically write 必 in the same way as you would write 心.) But I think there are many Chinese, Japanese, and certainly much more Koreans who may not be aware of the difference, because, in our computer age, handwriting is getting rarer and rarer. Last edited: Jan 26, 2012 Z

Zhi

Senior Member

Chinese Depends on the reason why you learn Chinese. If you tell me about why you're learning Chinese, I could tell you if stroke order is important. For 99.9% Chinese people who live in China, it's completely useless to know stroke order after elementary school - They still know it though, because they all went to elementary school once, but it really is useless ever since.

SuperXW

Senior Member

Beijing/Hong Kong Mandarin

Zhi said: Depends on the reason why you learn Chinese. If you tell me about why you're learning Chinese, I could tell you if stroke order is important. For 99.9% Chinese people who live in China, it's completely useless to know stroke order after elementary school - They still know it though, because they all went to elementary school once, but it really is useless ever since. Click to expand...

The stroke orders would be burnt into your subconscious once finishing your elementary school, so you can write the characters "normally". Imaging how a writer with no knowledge of stroke orders writes. The connections among his strokes would be so strange that makes harder for others to read. He cannot write fast, nor understand others' handwriting 连笔字. C

claireyeung

New Member

chinese, cantonese We were once tortured by stroke orders in primary school-all the exercises and tests. But once you get through all this, it will make it much easier for you to learn more characters and more complicated ones, because a good command of stroke orders will help you understand the structure of chinese characters better and then remember them more easily. Chinese characters are hieroglyphics, so writing chinese is kind of like drawing. And there is always a certain order in drawing, isn't there? Plus, correct stroke orders will be of great importance if you want to study calligraphy such as 楷书、行书. D

Dragonseed

Senior Member

Taiwan France - French There are just a few simple rules that actually allow you to know in which order the strokes come for almost any character. Top to bottom, left to right, central part then the sides for symmetrical constructs, and which of the horizontal or vertical comes first depending on whether they cross each other or not, etc. This page (http://zhongwen.com/shufa/index.html) is one of many giving you the rules and how to articulate some apparent "contradictions". With these, and few examples to practice, you should almost never need help to know how to write Chinese characters... I agree there are a few puzzling ones (I am quite sure I got 必 wrong. I'll have to go and check this one), but this is way simpler than spelling in many other languages! Practice a little, and you'll forget that this was ever a problem for you!

YangMuye

Senior Member

元素精霊界〈アストラル・ゼロ〉 精霊語, Chinese

Dragonseed said: This page (http://zhongwen.com/shufa/index.html) is one of many giving you the rules and how to articulate some apparent "contradictions". ...... I agree there are a few puzzling ones (I am quite sure I got 必 wrong. I'll have to go and check this one), but this is way simpler than spelling in many other languages! Click to expand...

Do you mean checking this one? http://lost-theory.org/ocrat/chargif/search.py?string=必 It's seems really awkward to me. I suggest you write in this order: “丿,乚,`(top),ヽ(left),ヽ(right)” or “`(top), 丿, 乚,ヽ(left),ヽ(right)”. (The last two dots should point to the center.) But 心 is usually “ヽ(left), 乚, ヽヽ(right)”( I'm not sure) And if you really want to write Character well, don't imitate 宋体. Try 楷书 or 行书. Last edited: Feb 1, 2012 L

Lugubert

Senior Member

Falkenberg, Sweden Swedish If I've understood handwriting correctly, the more cursive types are heavily dependent on stroke order. So if you want to learn to decipher even not too extreme handwriting, you'd better learn stroke order. The Wenlin software doesn't like wrong order in its handwriting recognition, but PlecoDict is quite permissive.

SuperXW

Senior Member

Beijing/Hong Kong Mandarin

Scharrelkip said: Hello I found the nín character very hard to write, so I searched on google for a simple tutorial. I now know how to write it, but someone replied with that the stroke order was wrong. Does this really matter? I mean, isn't the result that matters? Thanks in advance and greetings, Scharrelkip Click to expand...

When learning how to write a Chinese character like nin2, you'd better have learnt the very basic ones before, not just mimic the character showing on your computer. You need to learn 人, 尔, 心 respectively with their correct stroke orders and positions and meanings first. 人 is the image of a person. 尔 means “you”. 心 is the icon of a heart, etc. Only then you can really understand how 您 is constructed, and the way to write it properly. V

viajero_canjeado

Senior Member

Georgia English - Southeastern USA Call me crazy, but I've got a solid understanding of stroke order and still have a tough time reading locals' 草寫的字。。Probably haven't practiced calligraphy enough.

SuperXW

Senior Member

Beijing/Hong Kong Mandarin

viajero_canjeado said: Call me crazy, but I've got a solid understanding of stroke order and still have a tough time reading locals' 草寫的字。。Probably haven't practiced calligraphy enough. Click to expand...

Some people do write in "running style" or "grass style"... It is beautiful but indeed hard for most people to recognize, unless you are from the few ones who had learn it. -.- I just had such a problem recognizing some applicant's name on a form, and I consider it's his own fault. -.- You must log in or register to reply here. Share: Bluesky LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Share Link

• Other Language Forums
• 中文+方言 (Chinese)

Back Top Bottom