Peyton Manning's Dominance Of The NFL MVP Award Was Incredible

Skip to main contentSB NationSB Nation logoAn Indianapolis Colts CommunityStampede BlueDecember 19, 2025Stampede BlueNotificationsNotifications

• Sections
  • News
  • Schedule
  • Rumors
  • Injuries
  • Roster
  • Depth Chart
• By/For Fans
  • The Feed
  • Community Guidelines
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
• Today's Trivia
• Betting
  • FanDuel NFL Odds
  • FanDuel Super Bowl Odds
  • Indianapolis Colts Odds
  • NFL Picks and Predictions
• Newsletters

Navigation Drawer

• Login / Sign Up

closeCloseSearch

• SectionsExpand
  • News
  • Schedule
  • Rumors
  • Injuries
  • Roster
  • Depth Chart
• By/For FansExpand
  • The Feed
  • Community Guidelines
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
• Today's Trivia
• BettingExpand
  • FanDuel NFL Odds
  • FanDuel Super Bowl Odds
  • Indianapolis Colts Odds
  • NFL Picks and Predictions
• Newsletters
• All communities

• Facebook
• Twitter
• Youtube
• RSS

Stampede BluePeyton Manning’s dominance of the NFL MVP award was incredibleNotificationsNotifications

• General

Peyton Manning’s dominance of the NFL MVP award was incredibleby Josh WilsonMay 10, 2016, 10:21 PM UTC

• Facebook
• Link

Photo by Andy Lyons/Getty Images

Earlier today, Golden State Warriors guard Stephen Curry was named the first unanimous MVP in NBA history as he won the award for the second straight season (collecting all 131 first place votes while doing so). He is also the eleventh player in NBA history to win back-to-back MVP awards.

As for Cleveland Cavaliers forward LeBron James, he earned his ninth top-three finish in his career in MVP voting, the second-most in NBA history behind Michael Jordan’s ten.

With all of the talk about the NBA MVP voting going on and with some significant historical perspective added, it got me thinking about the NFL MVP award and how much recently-retired quarterback Peyton Manning dominated in his career.

Let’s consider his MVP legacy for a moment.

• Manning holds the NFL record for most MVP awards in a career with five, two more than anyone else (Jim Brown, Johnny Unitas, and Brett Favre all won three each).
• Manning actually was never a unanimous selection for MVP - the only player to earn that honor was Patriots quarterback Tom Brady in 2010 - but Manning had a couple of instances where he came pretty close. In fact, there have been four seasons in which a player has received all but one vote or better, and they all belong to either Manning or Brady. Brady of course received every vote in 2010 and received all but one in 2007, while Manning received all but one in both 2004 and 2013 (because some idiot wanted to make it about himself in the MVP voting rather than the right recipient). In three of those four seasons, the all-time touchdown pass record was broken (in other words, if you want to be a near-unanimous MVP, just break the touchdown record).
• Manning finished in the top three in MVP voting in nine different seasons. During a 15-year stretch (1999-2013), he finished in the top three in voting nine times. That is made even more remarkable when you factor in one year missed due to injury (2011) and two years in which Tom Brady either received every vote or all but one (meaning that there was another future Hall of Fame quarterback going against Manning during the period). While I don’t have the numbers of where Manning’s top three finishes rank all-time, I’d have to imagine it’s near the top. Take, for example, Tom Brady, who has six career top three finishes - he’d need to finish in the top three of the MVP voting in his age 39, 40, and 41 seasons just to tie Manning’s mark. So while I’m not sure where Manning ranks historically, it’s clear how impressive that number is.
• Manning was a back-to-back winner of the MVP award twice during his career (2003-2004, 2008-2009), the only player in NFL history to do so. In fact, only five times has a player ever won an MVP award back-to-back: Jim Brown in 1957-58, Joe Montana in 1989-90, Brett Favre in 1995-97 (the only time someone has won three consecutive), and then Peyton Manning in 2003-04 and in 2008-09.

We all know that Peyton Manning had a remarkable career in which he established himself among the very best in NFL history and became an NFL legend, not just a Colts legend. We all know that Manning will go down as the best to ever play in Indianapolis and will make the Hall of Fame. But it seems like Manning’s five MVP awards are often just mentioned and then moved on from, perhaps because that number has become so commonly known. Regardless, Manning’s dominance of the MVP award for over a decade is absolutely incredible, and it’s something worth noting as we hear about the NBA MVP award being given out.

See More:

• General

Advertiser Content From

This is the title for the native ad

More in General

Dec 4Week 14 Poll: Will the Colts bounce back this week?Nov 25Week 13 Poll: Are the Colts trending up this week?Nov 19Starting today, comments and Feed posts on Stampede Blue will have activity notificationsNov 13Vote: are the Colts on the rise?Oct 30Colts Reacts Survey Week 9Sep 25Colts Reacts Survey Week 4GeneralDec 4GeneralDec 4Week 14 Poll: Will the Colts bounce back this week?

Are you confident the Colts are headed in the right direction?

By Kyle TheleGeneralNov 25GeneralNov 25Week 13 Poll: Are the Colts trending up this week?

Are you confident the Colts are headed in the right direction?

By Kyle TheleGeneralNov 19GeneralNov 19Starting today, comments and Feed posts on Stampede Blue will have activity notificationsBy SB Nation NFLGeneralNov 13GeneralNov 13Vote: are the Colts on the rise?

Are you confident the Colts are headed in the right direction?

By Kyle TheleGeneralOct 30GeneralOct 30Colts Reacts Survey Week 9

Are you confident the Colts are headed in the right direction?

By Luke SchultheisGeneralSep 25GeneralSep 25Colts Reacts Survey Week 4

Are you confident the Colts are headed in the right direction?

By Kyle TheleAdvertiser Content From

This is the title for the native ad

The Latest

Two hours agoIndianapolis Colts Thursday Injury Report: QB Richardson Makes His ReturnDec 18Colts initiate 21-day practice window for QB Anthony Richardson, but there’s a new medical updateDec 18Indianapolis Colts discussion: How confident are you in this team’s future?Dec 18Pair of NFL insiders weigh in on Philip Rivers performance from league buzzDec 17The Colts could make things very interesting down the stretchDec 17Colts add three offensive linemen to practice squad to reinforce unit’s depleted depth