R11 Or R13, Or Does It Matter? | Forums Home

Log in Register

• Home
• Recent Activity
• Forums New posts Search forums Members Registered members Current visitors
• Wiki Pages Latest activity
• Media New media New comments Search media
• Resources Latest reviews Search resources
• FAQ
• Ratings

Log in Register What's new

Search

Everywhere Threads This forum This thread Search titles only Note By: Search Advanced search… Everywhere Threads This forum This thread Search titles only By: Search Advanced… Menu Install the app Install How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

R11 or R13, or does it matter?

• Thread starter Thread starter saichele
• Start date Start date Jul 26, 2006

• Active since 1995, Hearth.com is THE place on the internet for free information and advice about wood stoves, pellet stoves and other energy saving equipment. We strive to provide opinions, articles, discussions and history related to Hearth Products and in a more general sense, energy issues. We promote the EFFICIENT, RESPONSIBLE, CLEAN and SAFE use of all fuels, whether renewable or fossil.

• Forums
• Main Hearth Forums
• The Green Room

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.You should upgrade or use an alternative browser. Status Not open for further replies. S

saichele

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Nov 18, 2005 545 so I went to my local bigbox to buy insulation, and I can get r11 or r13 fiberglass for 2x4 framing. Need about 400 sq ft (doing all 4 walls). The r11 is 23c/sq. ft, the r13 is 33c. So a diff. of $40. Both unfaced, both 15.5 in wide (for 16" framing). It's an older house, and we're stepping up from r0. Someone give me an argument why the extra r2 (not even that, since it;s non-linear) is worth 50% more. Steve Toggle signature Englander 30-NC 1972 MGB Roadster 2000 VW Golf TDI - 205K and still 50 mpg S

saichele

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Nov 18, 2005 545 Short, concise, and weighs the pros and cons of each approach. Good response. Steve Toggle signature Englander 30-NC 1972 MGB Roadster 2000 VW Golf TDI - 205K and still 50 mpg

Michael6268

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Nov 19, 2005 784 Grafton NH/Upper Valley What part of the country do you live in? What type of room is it going in? If you are in a cold (or hot) climate you should go with at least the R-13. They make a R-15 for 2x4 framing too, but it is a little pricey. Should pay for itself down the road though.... Toggle signature Hitzer 50-93 coal stove E

elkimmeg

Guest

$40 and getting tax credits? If one compares R11 and R13 R11 looks chinzy. It looks more like 2.5 " thick The reason it is cheaper. R11 today will not satisfy any energy code. I am supprised it is even for sale. But you made a valid point R11 beats R-0. Its your call and wallet

wg_bent

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Nov 19, 2005 2,248 Poughkeepsie, NY Well, I've got a basement project going where I already have R10 foam and I'll add the r13 in the studs. The room will nice an comfortable when done! Toggle signature Work towards world peace...Heat with renewable fuels. Osburn 1800 Insert Slàinte Mhath S

saichele

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Nov 18, 2005 545 So this wasn;t exactly going as I had intended... I found the appropriate reference information, including a couple handy equations at a website (http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/thermo/heatloss.html#c1) and that I can expect 7200 base65 heating degree days in my location. A couple minutes in Excel revealed that in it's current shape, my 10x15 room with 2- 8 sq.ft.windows, no wall insulation and R50 inthe attic would take a whopping 22.5 million BTUs to maintain 65 all winter. Put R11 in the walls, and it drops to 7.3mill, R13 takes it to 6.7mill BTUs/yr. From Hearthnet, I can tell 1 MBTU's of electric is $32, 1 MBTU gas is $17, and 1MBTU pellet/corn (the eventual solution) is $12. The difference I'm interested in is 0.6 MBTU, so $19.20/yr electric, 10.20/yr gas, and 7.20 pellet/corn. Over a 5 yr horizon, the first year much of the heat inthat room will come from electric, the remaining 4 probably from pellet/corn. So 19+(4*7) = $47 Which means the difference between the R11 and R13 probably is worthwhile, and that the difference of 16 MBTU annually makes the cost of the remodel pretty trivial as well - savings of $500 in that first year of electric heat. More like $200 once we switch to pellet/corn. Steve Toggle signature Englander 30-NC 1972 MGB Roadster 2000 VW Golf TDI - 205K and still 50 mpg

Rhone

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Nov 21, 2005 827 I'm bummed I haven't been around for a few months or so this stuff is right up my alley! I have all sorts of this stuff. Your savings/year are going to be different than quoted, your numbers appear to be very conservative. The $32/MBTU's electric, it costs me $57.89/MBTU's right now where I live. Pellet prices are all over the place depending where you live, where I live today pellets are $250/ton from what a friend just told me, that's $18.38/MBTU. My program includes heating & cooling degree days so you can tell how much electricity you'll save keeping it cool in summer as well. Choosing to go with R13 instead of R11 for someone in a 7200 heating and 450 cooling, and 400 sq ft will save you 966,713 BTU's/year in heating and 60,420 btu's/year cooling. That translates into Electricity at $0.19757/kw: $55.96 heating + $3.50 cooling = $59.46/year Oil at $2.69/gal and 75% efficiency: $24.77 heating + $3.50 cooling = $28.26/year savings Pellets at $250/ton & 85% efficiency: $17.77 heating + $3.50 cooling = $21.27/year savings Wood at $185/cord & 70% efficiency: $9.46 heating + $3.50 cooling = $12.96/year savings So, the R13 is the wiser choice but you already figured that out! It should pay for itself within 2 years except for wood, there's a federal tax credit for insulating the envelope of your house of 20%, I think it's still active and 20% if you live in the USA so going to R13 over R11 after the credits are factored the difference is actually $32 in the end instead of $40. Also, one can't account for the savings of wear & tear on equipment that doesn't have to work as hard because you have more insulation. Interesting about going to R50 in the attic. It would take me 17 years to recoup the price increase of going to R50 instead of R38 in my attic. That's a lot less than when I ran it a few years ago, it told me it would take 29 years so I opted to stop at R38. Since you have the info in Excel, for some fun calculate the total square feet of your windows and their R-Value. Most likely, if they're windows & storms, or double-pane they're around R2. If new high-efficiency replacement windows with Low-E and Argon they're around R3. Then, determine the effect of adding a plastic film over them for winter which increases their R-Value by about R1. Amazing isn't it? Watch that the tape doesn't ruin your trim/finish. Next, run it for adding R 2.5 insulating blinds instead. S

saichele

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Nov 18, 2005 545 Hey Rhone - Nice to see you back. You're paying the "joy of New England" premium. (I think I remember you were from NE). Anyway, Electricity is $0.102 here, wood about $135, and gas $1.04/ccf. Pellets are 205/ton (for now). I catually did the windows, and they're bad. After insulating I'll lose more through 16 sf of glass than through 184 sf of wall. The R50 was also about ease and timing - we had the machine, and the trailer full of cellulose, and a babysitter. So I blew about 65 bags into the attic because that was what I could get home. We were coming up from nothing, and frankly I don't want to do it again. Shouldn;t have too. Next we can start the old convective/radiant debate. Steve Toggle signature Englander 30-NC 1972 MGB Roadster 2000 VW Golf TDI - 205K and still 50 mpg

Sandor

Minister of Fire

Hearth Supporter Dec 9, 2005 917 Deltaville,VA Nice to see you analyze again Rhone. Rather than beat the numbers to death, I choose to go full bore whenever you cannot go back and do it again easily. So, I would order R15 and go that way. God only know what a therm will cost in another 10 years; whether its electric, gas, oil or wood. Toggle signature WoodStock Soapstone - Keystone VC Resolute Acclaim - Old Style! Deltaville, Virginia Status Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

C Questions on Running a Jotul F3 After First Month

• CutterComp
• Nov 26, 2021
• Jotul

Replies 10 Views 5K Jotul Feb 5, 2022 Tar12

• Locked

First timer

• Stdyhand
• Aug 26, 2015
• The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces

Replies 6 Views 1K The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces Aug 27, 2015 begreen B

• Locked

Stove recommendations - 1100 sq ft in Vermont

• BeeTee
• Sep 23, 2011
• The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces

Replies 16 Views 2K The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces Sep 27, 2011 kingquad K C

• Locked

New stove user - need some advice on config in the new house

• Chris Miller
• Apr 1, 2011
• The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces

Replies 11 Views 1K The Hearth Room - Wood Stoves and Fireplaces Apr 4, 2011 begreen

• Locked

The "value of insulation"

• Frozen Canuck
• Dec 10, 2010
• The Boiler Room - Wood Boilers and Furnaces

Replies 21 Views 3K The Boiler Room - Wood Boilers and Furnaces Jan 18, 2011 Como Share: Facebook Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email Share Link

• Forums
• Main Hearth Forums
• The Green Room

Top Bottom

• Merry Christmas, Happy New Year!....and Happy Holidays!

• We value your privacy

  We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.

  See further information and configure your preferences

  Accept all cookies Reject optional cookies
  • Essential cookies
  These cookies are required to enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may not reject these.
  • Optional cookies
  We deliver enhanced functionality for your browsing experience by setting these cookies. If you reject them, enhanced functionality will be unavailable.
  • Third-party cookies
  Cookies set by third parties may be required to power functionality in conjunction with various service providers for security, analytics, performance or advertising purposes.
  • Detailed cookie usage
  • Privacy policy
  Save cookie preferences