Should You Rely On Your Cat To Catch Mice? - Greenleaf Pest Control

Throughout time, cats have been taken into homes, as well as barns and even retail stores, for their hunting deftness, and specifically for their mouse-killing abilities. (After all, cat vs. mouse is probably the most popular predator-prey pairing, immortalized in idioms and cartoons from all over the world.) Tiny in size and lacking flight abilities, which limits the possibility of counterattack or escape, mice are present in a cat’s diet simply because they are easy prey.

The same goes for house flies, moths, cockroaches, grasshoppers, spiders, and anything else that happens to wander inside your house. Cats love to chase (and sometimes kill) pretty much anything that creeps, crawls, or scurries before their eyes. They are born with natural hunting instincts, and many homeowners rely on them to chase and catch vermin on their property. However, allowing them to put their natural instincts to use may not only be ineffective at stopping a rodent infestation, but can actually introduce more pests into your home.

Your Cat May Kill the Occasional Mouse, but It Won’t Stop an Infestation

Although a lot of farmers would swear that their barn cat is an efficient mouse exterminator, the idea of a modern-day house cat decimating armies of mice is probably more wishful thinking than reality. A standard domesticated cat living inside the house with plenty of food available has little incentive to kill a mouse, let alone vicious adult rats that might fight back.

First of all, not all cats are natural mouse killers. Centuries of domestication have reduced the prey drive and hunting skills of many cats, and those who are still at it do it for entertainment or as a sign of affection for their owner.

When they do go hunting, many cats don’t eat their prey, and sometimes they don’t even kill it. Common behaviour in indoor-outdoor cats that don’t have the opportunity to catch live prey is to torture and play with their catch, trying to prolong the ‘event’ as much as possible.

Most agree that breed, sex, age, temperament, and upbringing also matter in establishing if a cat is suited for mouse-killing. For instance, the popular Maine Coon, initially bred for killing rodents, has currently lost its reputation as a mouse-killer, and breeds such as Birman, Persian, or Ragdoll are considered mellow and laidback. Females are said to be better hunters than males, possibly because they have the instinct to teach their kittens how to hunt, and older cats are preferred to younger ones who are still honing their skills.

Even if your cat is active and seems interested in hunting, that doesn’t automatically mean your house is vermin-free. Rodents prefer nesting in undisturbed locations, and when they come into your house, they will head for wall cavities, ceiling voids, areas behind appliances, or in unoccupied areas such as attics and basements, where cats have little or no access at all.

Given rodents’ capacity to breed incessantly (one female mouse can produce up to 15 litters per year), the occasional mouse your cat catches will hardly make a dent in the rodent population.

Your Cat May Be Inviting More Pests into Your Home

Indoor cats (who may or may not spend time outdoors) are an excellent host for fleas, ticks, and parasites, despite their rigorous hygiene regimen. The soft, warm fur of cats and dogs provides the perfect environment for these blood-sucking pests, who can then easily hop onto people and spread in all living areas of the house.

Bed bugs, especially, can become a serious problem if they gain access to your house. While they are not particularly fond of furry animals (they have a hard time moving through fur), they will not refuse to hitch a ride on your cat or dog and even have a meal or two off their blood until they detect a human host nearby. And once they find it, it’s almost impossible to convince them to move house.

However annoying and gruesome, live pests plaguing your cat are not your only concern. Fleas and ticks often spread disease by feeding on and nesting on pests. Fleas are known carriers of cat scratch disease, plague, tapeworm, or flea allergy dermatitis, while ticks transmit the notorious Lyme disease, as well as ehrlichiosis, anaplasmosis, and tularemia. Sometimes, the parasites causing these diseases may not pose a risk to your pet’s health, but they will endanger the health of humans, especially children.

Cats who hunt are susceptible to even more bacteria and parasites, which can result in life-altering consequences for their owners. Those who kill or feed on small prey such as birds and rodents can pick up Toxoplasma gondii (the parasite responsible for toxoplasmosis), avian flu, Salmonella, hantavirus, leptospirosis, and others. Cats may contract these diseases themselves or transmit them to their owners through a bite, lick, or scratch.

Proven Alternative Mouse Control Options

Mice are opportunistic, adaptable, and excellent at staying hidden. Effective control requires a layered approach that removes access, eliminates attractants, and reduces existing populations in a targeted, consistent way. The following options are proven, practical, and far more reliable than hoping Fluffy will be able to prevent and/or catch all mice trying to nest in your home.

Seal Entry Points and Cut Off Access

Mice can squeeze through openings as small as a dime, which means even well-maintained homes often have unnoticed entry points. Start with a careful inspection of the foundation, exterior walls, roofline, and utility penetrations.

Common problem areas include:

• Gaps around pipes, vents, and cable lines
• Cracks in foundation walls or siding seams
• Spaces beneath doors or damaged weatherstripping
• Garage doors that do not seal flush to the floor

Use durable materials like steel wool, metal mesh, or hardware cloth for small openings, and seal larger gaps with concrete patch or rodent-resistant sealant. This step alone can dramatically reduce activity by preventing new mice from entering while you address the ones already inside.

Reduce Clutter and Eliminate Nesting Sites

Mice prefer quiet, undisturbed areas where they can nest and move unseen. Cluttered basements, packed garages, and overfilled storage rooms provide ideal shelter. Cardboard boxes, paper stacks, and unused furniture are especially attractive.

Focus on:

• Replacing cardboard with sealed plastic bins
• Keeping storage items elevated off the floor
• Clearing dense clutter along walls and corners
• Regularly cleaning rarely used spaces

Outdoors, trim back vegetation near the foundation and remove woodpiles or debris stored against the house. Reducing shelter forces mice into the open, where control measures are far more effective.

Remove Food Sources and Improve Sanitation

Even small amounts of accessible food can sustain a mouse population. Dry goods, pet food, bird seed, and crumbs under appliances all contribute to ongoing activity.

Best practices include:

• Storing food in airtight, chew-resistant containers
• Cleaning spills and crumbs promptly
• Taking garbage out regularly and using tight-fitting lids
• Avoiding overnight pet food bowls

Sanitation does not eliminate mice on its own, but it significantly weakens infestations and improves the effectiveness of traps and professional treatments.

Use Traps Strategically and Consistently

Traps remain one of the most reliable tools for active mouse control when used correctly. Snap traps, when placed properly, provide quick results. Humane traps can also be effective, but require daily monitoring and appropriate release locations.

Key placement tips:

• Position traps along walls where mice travel
• Place traps perpendicular to the wall, trigger side facing inward
• Use multiple traps rather than relying on one or two
• Check and reset traps daily

Random placement often leads to frustration. Strategic positioning based on mouse behaviour makes a measurable difference.

Know When to Call a Professional

Persistent activity, repeated sightings, or evidence of nesting usually indicate a larger issue than DIY methods can handle. Professional pest control services bring experience, tools, and exclusion strategies that go beyond traps alone.

GreenLeaf Pest Control professionals will:

• Identify hidden entry points and nesting areas
• Implement comprehensive exclusion plans
• Use the latest, proven pest control products that are safest for humans and pets
• Monitor and adjust treatments over time

For households dealing with recurring mouse problems, professional intervention often saves time, stress, and long-term repair costs.

Unlike a cat, these strategies address both current activity and future prevention. When done thoroughly, they turn your home from a welcoming habitat into a difficult place for mice to survive, let alone settle in.

In Conclusion

Cats may be famed for their mouse-catching capabilities, but if you have a full-blown infestation in your house, a cat will be of little use to you. They may be helpful in preventing a mouse from entering the house in the first place, but if the infestation has already occurred, you should rely on effective control options. Reach out to us and find out how you can eliminate rodent populations without risking the health of your family and pets.

Related

ShareTweetPinShareBuffer