Swimming's Most Interesting Comeback Stories

Swimming’s Most Interesting Comeback Stories Photo Courtesy: Rob Schumacher-USA TODAY Sports Left Sidebar by Jason Tillotson 22 January 2018, 03:00pm

By Jason Tillotson, Swimming World College Intern. 

Swimming probably has the most high-level comebacks out of any sport and we all know very well the incredible comeback stories of Michael Phelps, Katie Hoff, Brendan Hansen and now Dana Vollmer, though few people may know or remember the lesser told tales of comebacks in swimming.

These three comeback stories are not necessarily the most successful, but they are interesting in the sense that the circumstances surrounding each of these swimmers’ comebacks were full of challenges, setbacks and adversity. Despite their treacherous paths, each of these swimmers climbed back and tasted success.

Here’s a closer look at some of the swimming world’s most intriguing comeback stories.

Photo Courtesy: Adidas

Ian Thorpe

The most decorated Australian Olympian made a comeback to the sport in January of 2011, in hopes to make the 2012 Australian Olympic Team. Despite his unsuccessful comeback, Thorpe still posted impressive times in the 100 and 200 freestyles at the 2012 Aussie Olympic Trials. Thorpe was able to post sub-50 and sub-1:50 times in the 100-meter and 200-meter freestyle, which, with only 13 months of training and racing after six years of no training or racing, is rather impressive.

Despite Thorpe’s solid times, he failed to qualify for the 2012 Olympic Games in London and, due to shoulder injuries, was forced to retire as the condition of the Thorpedo’s shoulders began to worsen. Thorpe’s comeback isn’t necessarily remarkable due to his performance, but rather to how he turned his life around after his initial retirement in 2006.

Thorpe struggled with mental health issues which was met with longtime scrutiny and questioning of his sexuality. Thorpe admittedly struggled with alcohol abuse and financial problems which created an uphill battle for Thorpe as he entered his comeback years. This is what makes Thorpe’s comeback so astounding, the fact that he was able bounce back from this low point in his life, speaks louder for the success of his comeback than his performance in the pool.

Photo Courtesy: Cindi Dayton

Davis Tarwater

Davis Tarwater was a mainstay on the U.S. National Team as a top-notch butterflier since the early 2000’s. Tarwater was a multi-time Big-10 Conference Champion, NCAA Champion and an Olympic gold medalist. Despite his consistency on the international stage, Tarwater was notorious for just missing a spot on the U.S. Olympic Team in 2004 and 2008 by the hands of Michael Phelps.

Tarwater would see success the following year though, winning a gold medal in the 4×200-meter freestyle relay at the 2009 LC World Championships in Rome. Tarwater then retired and began studying at Oxford with no intensions of returning to the sport. In 2010, however, then SwimMAC Carolina head coach David Marsh, was contacted by Tarwater about a comeback. Tarwater began training with Marsh for the 2012 U.S. Olympic Team Trials, in hopes to make his first Olympic squad. Tarwater moved to Charlotte to train with Marsh, all while managing a 40-hour work week.

Tarwater would go on to place seventh in the 200 free, fifth in the 100 fly and fourth in the 200 fly, just missing a spot on the Olympic roster. What makes Tarwater’s comeback so intriguing is his seemingly disappointing performance at the 2012 trials was met with somewhat of a gift from Phelps, who later decided to drop the 200 free from his schedule at the London games.

This moved Tarwater into a relay position in the 4×200 free relay.

Tarwater would go on to win a gold medal in the event at the London games, which capped off his successful career and comeback.

Photo Courtesy: Erich Schlegel-USA TODAY Sports

Missy Franklin

Placing Missy Franklin on this list was a difficult choice to make since her comeback is still in the works and, perhaps, still up in the air. What makes Franklin’s comeback interesting is how dynamic it has been. Some may say Franklin never actually left the sport, but she did go through a long period of no training or racing

After a phenomenal age group and high school career, which led into her recording breaking summers in 2011 in Shanghai and 2012 in London. Those two meets solidified her as one of the greatest backstrokers in history, who still had her best years in front of her.

Franklin would go on to win multiple World Championship gold medals until the summer of 2014 where Franklin suffered a severe back injury, which, along with both of her shoulders, kept her from training for an admittedly unsuccessful performance in Rio, where she failed to medal in her signature backstroke events.

After a brief stint with the men’s team at the University of California-Berkeley with head coach Dave Durden, Franklin had surgery on both her shoulders. Recently, Franklin has recovered from both surgeries and made the move to Athens, Georgia to train with legendary coach Jack Baurle. Franklin’s comeback is still in progress and we likely won’t see her race at peak levels for awhile, but she is a world record holder who clearly still has the spark for the sport.

All commentaries are the opinion of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of Swimming World Magazine nor its staff.

Subscribe Login Notify of new follow-up comments new replies to my comments Label Name* Email*

Welcome to our community. We invite you to join our discussion. Our community guidelines are simple: be respectful and constructive, keep on topic, and support your fellow commenters. Commenting signifies that you agree to our Terms of Use

Label Name* Email*

Welcome to our community. We invite you to join our discussion. Our community guidelines are simple: be respectful and constructive, keep on topic, and support your fellow commenters. Commenting signifies that you agree to our Terms of Use

13 Comments Oldest Newest Most Voted Inline Feedbacks View all comments Tim Lecrone 8 years ago

Pablo Morales?

0 Reply Bob Tyler 8 years ago Reply to Tim Lecrone

Agreed

0 Reply Lane Four 8 years ago Reply to Tim Lecrone

Absolutely! One of the greatest returns in history!

0 Reply Tim Lecrone 8 years ago Reply to Tim Lecrone

Still chokes me up to watch his 100 fly for his mom in ’92.

0 Reply Leander 8 years ago Reply to Tim Lecrone

Pablo’s was the first one that came to mind for me. A couple other successful comebacks would be Dara Torres (twice) and Tom Dolan, who had a somewhat disappointing Olympics in Atlanta and then swam much better in Australia (after leaving Michigan a year early to turn pro, he was expected to do better at the Atlanta Olympics).

But, of course, the article is entitled interesting comebacks, not successful ones.

0 Reply Wendy Morrison 8 years ago

Can’t wait to see her at the pool!

0 Reply Michael Maloney 8 years ago Reply to Wendy Morrison

yes to bad she will be signing autographs right next to Ryan L..and not swimming….unf they are both done….

0 Reply ROBERT J BURNS 8 years ago

Jeff Farrell?

0 Reply Tom Co 8 years ago

Megan Jendrick had a pretty good story too I thought. The debacle with the super suit era and her then-sponsor threatening to sue if any of them wore a good suit. Broken leg at the navy seal training camp. Motherhood. My daughter loved her!

0 Reply Steve Lane 8 years ago

I hope she makes it back. My girls met her during her freshman year at Cal. What a Class Act!

0 Reply Miranda Emaus 8 years ago

Kalina Grace Emaus

0 Reply Chris Sheppard 8 years ago

Uhhhhh….Anthony Ervin???

0 Reply YY 8 years ago

How can a swimmer who suffered a severe back injury, along with both of her shoulders issues can swim 1:39.10 at 200y free. The time that is beyond the reach of Olympic gold medalist at 100m free and Olympic gold medalist at 200 free. Who is cultivating this myth of unlucky injured star. She was on the top long enough for at least five years and her time is just up to think about retirement.

0 Reply

Poll

Reaction Time Comments

• MDS on Arizona State Adds 2027 Verbal Pledge From Landon Hall
• MDS on 35 Things Swimmers Sometimes Take for Granted
• Bill Price on The Hidden Cost of House vs. NCAA: Is America’s Olympic Engine at Risk?
• glenn wilson on The Hidden Cost of House vs. NCAA: Is America’s Olympic Engine at Risk?
• John Lohn - Editor-in-Chief on Under-the-Radar Female Performance of the Year: Tess Howley Lit Up 200 Butterfly at World University Games

• 2020 Holiday Gift Guide by Swimming World
• 2022 Holiday Gift Guide by Swimming World
• 2022 Prep School Directory by Swimming World
• 2022 Swim Camp Directory by Swimming World
• American Swimming Records: Long Course Meters
• American Swimming Records: Short Course Meters
• American Swimming Records: Short Course Yards
• Aquatic Directory: Spectrum Aquatics
• Be a Guest on Swim & Tell Podcast | Swimming World
• Cart
• Checkout
  • Checkout → Review Order
  • Shipping Addresses
  • Shipping Addresses
  • Shipping Addresses
  • Shipping Addresses
  • Shipping Addresses
• Contact Us At Swimming World
• Donation Confirmation
• Donation Failed
• Donor Dashboard
• Every Child A Swimmer
• FREE 90 Days
• Get Recruited
• Hacienda Fund Donation
• Holiday Gift Guide 2025
• ISHOF – Swimming World Early Bird Renewals
• ISHOF – Swimming World Magazine Renewals
• ISHOF One in a Thousand Club
• Live Streaming TV & On-Demand: Eurovision Sports Exclusively on Swimming World
• Login or Join
• Maxime Grousset Rattles 100 Free Rankings With 47.62 Blast In Rennes; Three In Three For Leon Marchand
• My Downloads
• My Swimming World Account
  • Shipping Addresses
  • Shipping Addresses
  • Shipping Addresses
  • Shipping Addresses
• My Swimming World Account – Redirect To New Login Page
• NAIA Swimming Records
• NCAA Division II Swimming Records
• NCAA Division III Swimming Records
• NCAA Men’s Division I Swimming Records
• NCAA Women’s Division I Swimming Records
• NJCAA Swimming Records
• Olympic Swimming Records
• On-Demand Coaching Advice for Swimmers from David Marsh
• On-Demand Coaching Advice for Swimmers from David Marsh
• Post a Job
• Prep School Directory
• Shop
• Swim & Tell
• Swimming Jobs
• Swimming Resource Guide
• Swimming World 2025 Advertising / Media Kit
• Swimming World Archive
• Swimming World Award Honorees
• Swimming World Partners And ISHOF Sponsors
• Swimming World Swim Camp Directory (All Listings)
• Swimming World’s Record Book
• Terms
• The Who’s Who Aquatic Directory For The Industry
• USA High School National Records
• World Junior Records in Swimming: Long Course Meters
• World Swimming Records: Long Course Meters
• World Swimming Records: Short Course Meters
• zz(SW Carousel)
• zz(SW Category Double)
• zz(SW Category Single)
• zz(SW Category Triple)
• zz(SW Posts w Ads)
• zz(SW Recent Comments)
• zz(SW Recent Posts)
• zz(SW Search)
• zz(SW Slider)
• zz(SW Weekly Poll)

wpDiscuz130Would love your thoughts, please comment.x()x| ReplyInsert Loading Comments... Write a Comment... Email Name Website