The Texas Big Freeze: How A Changing Climate Pushed The State's ...

Home » When Was The Freeze In Texas » The Texas Big Freeze: How A Changing Climate Pushed The State's ...

Maybe your like

Skip to main content Utility Dive CONTINUE TO SITE ➞ Don't miss tomorrow's electric utility industry news

Let Utility Dive's free newsletter keep you informed, straight from your inbox.

Daily Dive M-F Storage Weekly Every Tuesday Load Management Weekly Every Wednesday

In partnership with

Renewable Energy Weekly Every Thursday

In partnership with

By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at anytime. Search search close search
  • Generation
  • T&D
  • Grid Reliability
  • Electrification
  • Load Management
  • Renewables
  • Storage
  • DER
  • Regs
  • Corp News
An article from site logo Opinion The Texas Big Freeze: How a changing climate pushed the state's power grid to the brink Published June 2, 2021 By Dan Esposito and Eric Gimon
  • Share this article Share
    • Copy link Copy link
    • Email this page Email
    • Post to LinkedIn LinkedIn
    • Post on X X/Twitter
    • Share on Facebook Facebook
    • Print this page Print
  • Set preferred source Add us on Google
Pike Electric service trucks line up after a snow storm on February 16, 2021 in Fort Worth, Texas.
Getty Images

The following is a contributed article by Dan Esposito, senior policy analyst at Energy Innovation, and Eric Gimon, senior fellow at Energy Innovation.

Editor's Note: This is the first of a three-part op-ed series in Utility Dive based on Energy Innovation's research examining 1) what drove the extended Texas outages, 2) the degree to which energy markets failed, and 3) how different entities can improve U.S. energy market and power infrastructure resiliency against extreme events while decarbonizing the grid to mitigate future climate risk.

When February's polar vortex brought historically rare freezing temperatures to Texas, the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) initiated rotating outages to prevent the power grid's collapse, leaving millions of Texans without electricity for days. The ensuing crisis (deemed the "Big Freeze") led to residential heating shortages, burst pipes, water treatment plant failures, and an estimated 700 deaths — all of which disproportionately affected low-income communities of color.

The incident was covered as an isolated event, but climate change threatens grid stability across the United States. Recognizing this, new research from Energy Innovation identifies the root causes of Big Freeze-driven power outages to offer lessons for policymakers in and beyond Texas. While climate change mitigation efforts are critical, they must be paired with smart resiliency measures to protect against increasingly common climate-related disasters — such as deploying demand-side measures like weatherizing homes, taking a more holistic approach to risk management, and planning for "managed failure" of the grid.

In the tragedy's wake, disingenuous commentary blocked productive public discourse, and several parties capitalized on power sector complexities to redirect blame or leverage national attention to further their agendas. For example, Texas Governor Greg Abbott, R, attacked wind and solar, falsely blaming them for the power outages. While the state's energy market has made it a renewable energy leader, natural gas still provides more than half of its electricity. Evidence shows natural gas was chiefly responsible for the power supply shortage and that a high renewable energy system could have performed better.

Climate-related disasters will become increasingly common, even as the world decarbonizes, making extended outages like those in Texas possible anywhere:

  • In 2017, Hurricane Maria severely damaged Puerto Rico's power grid, with a quarter of the island's residents still in the dark five months later.
  • In California, utilities shut off power for millions of residents in recent years to prevent live transmission lines from blowing into dry foliage and sparking wildfires, and wildfires themselves pose additional risk to energy infrastructure.
  • In 2020, Tropical Storm Isaias downed trees, cutting power to 1.4 million New Jersey customers.
  • Connecticut officials recently estimated that a Category 3 hurricane could leave its residents without power for months.
Permission granted by Energy Innovation  

Sober diagnosis of the Big Freeze is essential to help lawmakers and regulators across the U.S. prepare for inevitable future system shocks and protect their states' residents from physical and financial harm.

The challenge of high-impact, common-mode events

ERCOT is tasked with ensuring just enough supply of electricity to meet demand at any given moment, as too large an imbalance can trigger a system-wide blackout. It has successfully performed this function at low cost during ordinary and extreme conditions — in fact, Texas residents paid below the U.S. average for power over the last decade, with ERCOT keeping the lights on through periodic heat waves.

However, the Big Freeze falls well beyond "ordinary" and typical "extreme" conditions into a third category: high-impact, common-mode events. In these events, a "common mode" causes failure across many seemingly independent system components, compounding the impact of any one piece failing.

Cold weather was the common mode in the Big Freeze, causing power plants, natural gas production wells, and other critical energy infrastructure to freeze and cease operations. The cold also drove electric demand to near-record levels, as electricity meets about 60% of heating demand in Texas, often through inefficient systems.

Permission granted by Brian Bartholomew (@BPBartholomew on Twitter)  

The need to balance supply and demand led ERCOT to employ planned outages, though these too were mishandled. Poor planning left some communities with uninterrupted power while others suffered in the dark for days. This compounded hardships faced by Black and Hispanic communities in particular, who have fared worse through the COVID-19 pandemic and whose neighborhoods disproportionately consist of older and less efficient homes. An ERCOT program compensating industrial facilities to reduce power consumption also backfired, as many participants ordered offline were critical to the state's natural gas infrastructure.

Failures throughout the natural gas infrastructure system starved the grid of power

A shortfall of available natural gas power generation was the Big Freeze's main culprit. Texas natural gas production fell by 45% due to frozen wells, frozen pipes, and a lack of electricity to manage other gas infrastructure components, leaving some generators without fuel to burn. Other power plants had access to gas but weren't designed to operate in such cold conditions.

These gas power generation shortfalls could have been avoided simply through sufficient winterization, but winterization has been (and currently remains) optional under Texas regulations. Given the perceived low risk of an event like the Big Freeze, market participants in ERCOT's highly competitive environment have opted to forego such measures.

Huge swaths of the sprawling natural gas system may need winterization retrofitting to address this problem going forward, as gas-fired power plants need access to the fuel to operate. With more than 120,000 gas producing wells, nearly half a million miles of pipeline, and nearly 70 GW of gas-fired power plants, retrofit costs could quickly balloon. The price tag may be more tolerable if only a small subset of the system or new gas infrastructure must be winterized, but such estimates ignore stranded asset costs of moving away from gas — and in any case, those funds would likely see a higher return if put toward demand-side measures.

Permission granted by Energy Innovation  

On the other hand, wind farms can be winterized for as cheap as 5% of installed prices, cost-effectively preventing frozen turbines. With no fuel production and transportation network necessary for wind farms to operate, the costs stop here. As wind development must boom over the next decade to meet U.S. decarbonization goals, winterization during construction could limit subsequent retrofit costs.

Despite false rhetoric, a technical analysis from Vibrant Clean Energy suggests wind "actually provided support over the winter storm," with solar producing better than expected. Preliminary models also show that a Texas grid supplied predominantly by wind, solar, and energy storage would perform better than the existing gas-led system — particularly if the state built new transmission connections with neighboring regions to share resources as weather systems move across the continent.

Inefficient buildings and poor communication contributed to high electricity demand

ERCOT was also faced with 14% higher demand than its worst-case estimate of extreme winter conditions. The residential sector was responsible for most of this demand spike, as residential loads may have increased up to 250% during the Big Freeze due to four factors:

  • Building codes in Texas were historically inadequate, especially prior to 2001, resulting in most of Texas' housing stock leaking warm air and straining for more.
  • Incentives to weatherize homes have had only limited impact; for example, state and federal weatherization programs improved only 0.1% of Texas from 2010-2016.
  • Residential electricity rates are generally flat, removing any financial incentive to use less energy during high-demand conditions.
  • Regulators and market operators have no coordinated plan to communicate with homeowners to lower their energy use.

Texans therefore had no awareness of the looming crisis, no reason to keep thermostats low in cold weather, and homes that needed to continually cycle hot air to replace that which seeped outside. Meanwhile, demand-side measures to promote targeted energy conservation and home weatherization could have paid for themselves many times over during the Big Freeze.

Scrambling to prevent a blackout, ERCOT moved forward with its only remaining option — controlled outages that artificially reduce demand to match available supply.

Durable solutions must look beyond fossil fuels

A brute force approach to planning for high-impact, common-mode events would mandate the construction of 10 new winterized natural gas-fired power plants with fuel storage on site. While it may work in theory, the plan is anticompetitive, very expensive, and devoid of supplemental societal benefits like reduced emissions and energy bills from weatherizing buildings.

Instead, the plan would harm communities forced to sponsor the new plants through added pollution and further entrench natural gas infrastructure when the U.S. must rapidly transition away from fossil fuels — something we can and must do without building any new gas-fired power plants in order to meet America's target of reducing greenhouse gas emissions 50-52% by 2030. As you can't dig your way out of a hole, you can't make burning more fossil fuels central to addressing climate change-driven crises.

Understanding the policy decisions and market failures that exacerbated the Big Freeze is imperative for designing solutions, which we'll discuss in this series' second article. Policymakers can then implement sustainable, holistic solutions that rise to the complexity and interrelatedness of such events, like improving building codes, creating a resilience fund, and upgrading the distribution grid to allow for more surgical rotating outages — which we'll discuss in the third article.

  • Post to LinkedIn
  • Share on Facebook
  • Post to X
  • Print this page
  • Email this page
Filed Under: Grid Security & Reliability, Regulation & Policy

Utility Dive news delivered to your inbox

Get the free daily newsletter read by industry experts

Email:
  • Select Newsletter: Daily Dive M-F
  • Select Newsletter: Storage Weekly Every Tuesday
  • Select Newsletter: Load Management Weekly Every Wednesday
  • Select Newsletter: Renewable Energy Weekly Every Thursday
  • Select user consent: By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at anytime.
Sign up A valid email address is required. Please select at least one newsletter. Daily Dive newsletter example

Editors' picks

  • An aerial view of a power plant.
    Image attribution tooltip Brandon Bell via Getty Images Image attribution tooltip

    Groups sue FERC over MISO, SPP fast-track interconnection programs

    The groups contend the Midcontinent Independent System Operator and Southwest Power Pool’s processes give undue advantage to fast-tracked projects and will lead to higher residential ratepayer costs.

    By Ethan Howland • Nov. 19, 2025
  • Power line crews come out to help people who are experiencing difficulty with their power in Savannah, Georgia.
    Image attribution tooltip Megan Varner via Getty Images Image attribution tooltip

    Georgia Power’s large load pipeline shrinks by 6 GW

    Georgia Public Service Commission staff testimony noted data centers are “underperforming expectations” due to lower materialization rates, project cancellations and delays.

    By Diana DiGangi • Nov. 24, 2025

Keep up with the story. Subscribe to the Utility Dive free daily newsletter

Email:
  • Select Newsletter: Daily Dive M-F
  • Select Newsletter: Storage Weekly Every Tuesday
  • Select Newsletter: Load Management Weekly Every Wednesday
  • Select Newsletter: Renewable Energy Weekly Every Thursday
  • Select user consent: By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at anytime.
Sign up A valid email address is required. Please select at least one newsletter. A worker repairs a power line ge-vernova Craig Station, a 1,285-megawatt, three-unit, coal fired power plant in Moffat County, Colorado. The power plant's units were constructed by Colorado Ute Electric Association. An American flag and a flag bearing the seal of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (which features an eagle holding a shield with elements of a skyline on it) flank a large upright square panel bearing the same CISA seal. On the wall to the right of the panel and the flags, a row of digital clocks shows the time in the four major U.S. time zones. Two men install solar panels on a roof. A large entrance sign that reads "Gate A, NIST, National Institute of Standards and Technology, U.S. Department of Commerce" is mounted on a rock base and surrounded by grass and trees. In the background to the left of the sign, there is a commercial building. Buildings burn in the distance. A woman speaks into a microphone.

Get the free newsletter

Subscribe to Utility Dive for top news, trends & analysis

Email:
  • Select Newsletter: Daily Dive M-F
  • Select Newsletter: Storage Weekly Every Tuesday
  • Select Newsletter: Load Management Weekly Every Wednesday
  • Select Newsletter: Renewable Energy Weekly Every Thursday
  • Select user consent: By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at anytime.
Sign up A valid email address is required. Please select at least one newsletter.

Most Popular

  1. An aerial view of houses near large industrial buildings. Data centers were 40% of PJM capacity costs in last auction: market monitor
  2. An aerial view of several buildings in a wide open plain. ERCOT’s large load queue jumped almost 300% last year
  3. Craig Station, a 1,285-megawatt, three-unit, coal fired power plant in Moffat County, Colorado. The power plant's units were constructed by Colorado Ute Electric Association. DOE orders 446-MW Colorado coal unit to keep running
  4. A natural gas plant is seen lit up and emitting steam at sunset. Vistra to buy Cogentrix Energy’s 5.5 GW of gas plants in $4B deal

Library resources

  • studioID resource icon Playbook How to build a secure, future-ready utility grid Custom content for Semtech
  • studioID resource icon Playbook Mega Project Framework: Programmatic Strategies for a New Energy Era Custom content for POWER Engineers and WSP
  • studioID resource icon Infographic How to Turn Compliance Into a Competitive Advantage Custom content for Veriforce
View all

Company Announcements

View all | Post a press release

What We're Reading

  • Wall Street Journal The Fight Over Making Data Centers Power Down to Avoid Blackouts offsite link
  • Texas Tribune Panhandle magnate moves to take over region’s electricity offsite link
  • Reuters American Electric Power signs $2.65 billion deal for fuel cells offsite link
View all

Events

View all | Promote an event

Industry Intel

  • Integrating Geospatial Data and Analytics Into Your Cloud Strategy: A Game Changer For Utilities Webinar - on demand • Provided by Korem
  • Reducing Grid Strain With Automated Energy Management for EV Charging Webinar - on demand • Provided by Amply

Utility Dive news delivered to your inbox

Get the free daily newsletter read by industry experts

Email:
  • Select Newsletter: Daily Dive M-F
  • Select Newsletter: Storage Weekly Every Tuesday
  • Select Newsletter: Load Management Weekly Every Wednesday
  • Select Newsletter: Renewable Energy Weekly Every Thursday
  • Select user consent: By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at anytime.
Sign up A valid email address is required. Please select at least one newsletter. Daily Dive newsletter example

Company Announcements

View all | Post a press release Unicorn Modernises European Energy Market with New AIB Hub From Unicorn January 05, 2026 Unicorn logo Tech startup Utilen closes seed funding round to address power infrastructure coordination gaps From Utilen January 07, 2026 Utilen logo From Gas to Grid: How 120V Induction Stoves Are Cooking Up a New Electrification Tradition From CalNEXT December 19, 2025 CalNEXT logo Editors' picks
  • An aerial view of a power plant.
    Image attribution tooltip Brandon Bell via Getty Images Image attribution tooltip

    Groups sue FERC over MISO, SPP fast-track interconnection programs

    The groups contend the Midcontinent Independent System Operator and Southwest Power Pool’s processes give undue advantage to fast-tracked projects and will lead to higher residential ratepayer costs.

    By Ethan Howland • Nov. 19, 2025
  • Power line crews come out to help people who are experiencing difficulty with their power in Savannah, Georgia.
    Image attribution tooltip Megan Varner via Getty Images Image attribution tooltip

    Georgia Power’s large load pipeline shrinks by 6 GW

    Georgia Public Service Commission staff testimony noted data centers are “underperforming expectations” due to lower materialization rates, project cancellations and delays.

    By Diana DiGangi • Nov. 24, 2025
Latest in Grid Security & Reliability
  • A worker repairs a power line Utilities under pressure: 6 power sector trends to watch in 2026 By Meris Lutz, Robert Walton, Ethan Howland and Diana DiGangi
  • ge-vernova How VPPs can help data centers connect to the grid faster By Jesse Cohen, Mark Dyson and Lauren Shwisberg
  • Craig Station, a 1,285-megawatt, three-unit, coal fired power plant in Moffat County, Colorado. The power plant's units were constructed by Colorado Ute Electric Association. DOE orders 446-MW Colorado coal unit to keep running By Ethan Howland
  • An American flag and a flag bearing the seal of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (which features an eagle holding a shield with elements of a skyline on it) flank a large upright square panel bearing the same CISA seal. On the wall to the right of the panel and the flags, a row of digital clocks shows the time in the four major U.S. time zones. CISA loses key employee behind early ransomware warnings By Eric Geller
Industry Dive is an Informa TechTarget business. © 2026 TechTarget, Inc. or its subsidiaries. All rights reserved. | View our other publications | Privacy policy | Terms of use | Take down policy. Cookie Preferences / Do Not Sell This website is owned and operated by Informa TechTarget, part of a global network that informs, influences and connects the world's technology buyers and sellers. All copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. TechTarget, Inc.'s registered office is 275 Grove St. Newton, MA 02466. close menu Search search
  • Home
  • Topics down arrow
    • Generation
    • T&D
    • Grid Reliability
    • Electrification
    • Load Management
    • Renewables
    • Storage
    • DER
    • Regs
    • Corp News
  • Deep Dive
  • Opinion
  • Library
  • Events
  • Press Releases

Get Utility Dive in your inbox

The free newsletter covering the top industry headlines

Email:
  • Select Newsletter: Daily Dive M-F
  • Select Newsletter: Storage Weekly Every Tuesday
  • Select Newsletter: Load Management Weekly Every Wednesday
  • Select Newsletter: Renewable Energy Weekly Every Thursday
  • Select user consent: By signing up to receive our newsletter, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at anytime.
Sign up A valid email address is required. Please select at least one newsletter.

Tag » When Was The Freeze In Texas