Tolkien: 'Why I Wrote The Hobbit' - BBC Culture

Skip to content

• Home
• News
• Sport
• Business
• Innovation
• Health
• Culture
• Arts
• Travel
• Earth
• Audio
• Video
• Live

HomeNewsSportBusinessInnovationHealthCultureArtsTravelEarthAudioVideoLiveWeatherNewslettersTolkien: ‘Why I wrote The Hobbit’10 October 2014ShareSaveFiona MacdonaldFeatures correspondentShareSave

In a 1968 interview, the author describes the moment he wrote The Hobbit’s first line. BBC Culture pits it against The Hobbit’s new trailer in our round up of the week’s viral hits, alongside their archive predecessors.

The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies v 1968 interview with JRR Tolkien

Evangeline Lilly, Cate Blanchett and Orlando Bloom come together as a group of elves whose beauty is matched only by the landscape of Middle Earth in the new Hobbit trailer. Unveiled at Comic-Con, the clip shows Martin Freeman’s Bilbo Baggins looking baffled, Ian McKellen’s Gandalf looking resolute and Bloom looking battle-ready: he’ll need to be, what with those five armies on the march. The final instalment of director Peter Jackson’s Tolkien franchise is out in December.

“In a hole in the ground there lived a Hobbit.” JRR Tolkien describes the moment he was inspired to write the opening line of his Middle Earth saga in this 1968 interview, with footage showing the author visiting his former Oxford college, sipping from a pint of beer and expressing his love of trees. It also serves as a trailer of sorts, as a woman outlines the plot of the 1937 book – albeit in a more rudimentary way than this week’s Hollywood extravaganza. As she says: “Well it’s a very long story and it’s rather difficult to explain it, but I suppose it all begins when Bilbo finds a magic ring … They have lots of adventures, and they make friends with a lot of very interesting and influential elves.”

Fifty Shades of Grey trailer v Still Life by Sam Taylor-Wood

“I exercise control in all things, Miss Steel.” Christian Grey shares his tips on discipline with us in the trailer for Fifty Shades of Grey, which is heavy on tycoon accessories and lingering glances. Beyonce gasps out her a capella version of Crazy in Love over images of a helicopter, a glider plane, a grand piano – and a secret fetish room – in the promotional clip for the movie directed by Sam Taylor-Johnson (Nowhere Boy). An adaptation of the best-selling novel by EL James, the film stars Jamie Dornan and Dakota Johnson and is due out in February 2015.

Long before she was getting viewers hot under the collar, Taylor-Johnson – who was known as Sam Taylor-Wood before she married Aaron Johnson – was making video art. Nominated for the Turner Prize in 1998, she filmed David Beckham sleeping for a National Portrait Gallery project and created a series called Crying Men, showing actors like Robin Williams, Sean Penn and Laurence Fishburne crying. This piece, called Still Life, shows a bowl of fruit decaying at an accelerated pace; the mould gathers like billowing clouds as the fruit begins to collapse.

{

Out of the Blue’s Shakira medley v The Music Man barbershop scene

An a capella group made up of Oxford students caught the eye of Shakira this week after they recorded a version of her hit song Hips Don’t Lie for charity. In the clip – which prompted the Colombian singer to tweet "Hey @ooboxford, we LOVE your a capella Shak medley!" – members of Out of the Blue gyrate and bounce jauntily in suits and ties against a backdrop of the university town’s dreaming spires. Although at times the ensemble appears to be jostling rather than dancing, there are set-pieces worthy of Glee: several of the group pop out of the bushes in the garden of a college, before crawling across its pristine lawn.

“Singing is just sustained talking,” quips Harold Hill (Robert Preston) in this clip from the 1962 movie The Music Man. The con man – who poses as a band leader in an Iowan town – gets a group of bickering school board members to croon the word ‘ice cream’ before breaking into a performance of Sincere as fireworks explode behind them. The singers are in fact The Buffalo Bills, considered one of the greatest barbershop quartets of all time: the film won an Academy Award for best musical score, and was selected for preservation in the US National Film Registry in 2005.

Sadie doesn’t want her baby brother to grow up v 1924 Peter Pan film

A tantrum of existential angst has become a viral hit this week, as five-year-old Sadie bemoans the passing of the years. “I don’t want him to grow up!” she screams about her younger brother, who sits smiling by her side. “And I don’t want to die when I’m a hundred!” she sobs, choking on her tears. This isn’t the first time the girl from Arizona has been emotional over ageing: her father Ryan Miller told Time: “She’s cried about not wanting to get older herself in the past, but this was the first time she was upset about her brother”. The clip ends with Sadie crying out “I want him to stay little!” before becoming hysterical over the relentless march of time.

Reassuring words from ‘the boy who wouldn’t grow up’ in this clip from a 1924 silent film. “You just think lovely, wonderful thoughts and they lift you up in the air,” says Peter Pan, played by Betty Bronson, as he teaches the Darling children how to fly. Herbert Brenon’s Peter Pan was the first film adaptation of JM Barrie’s play, and stuck closely to the stage version. Most copies of the film were destroyed over the years, but in 1990 it was restored and given a new score.

If you would like to comment on this story or anything else you have seen on BBC Culture, head over to our Facebook page or message us on Twitter.

HollywoodWatch

What's it like to meet your own avatar?

Musician KT Tunstall meets her avatar as Tech Now explores music’s virtual future.

Tech Now

A simple stargazing ritual to reset stress

Dark-sky retreats are on the rise, offering nights under dazzling skies to boost calm, clarity, and wonder.

Science & Health

Trump expects huge investment in Venezuela

Former Venezuelan minister says firms will not invest without democratic legitimacy.

Opening Bell

How Tom Hiddleston's dad became his biggest cheerleader

Initially sceptical of his career, the actor recalls his father’s reaction to one of his early roles.

Film & TV

Wall Street weighs impact of Venezuela turmoil

Brian Szytel says he expects a correction in equity valuations in the year ahead.

Opening Bell

Olsen and Teller talk British phrases they don't understand

The two actors talk to Radio 1's Ali Plumb about the complexities of the British vernacular.

Film & TV

Global financial caution over recent US capture

Global financial caution over US strike and capture of Venezuela’s President Nicolás Maduro.

Opening Bell

How pop-up ads took over the internet

BBC journalist Ammie Sekhon explores the unexpected history of the pop-up ad.

Tech Now

Cecilia Bartoli: See the magic of Opera's 'last diva'

Renowned for her astounding range, the Italian mezzo-soprano's singing is a source of joy for adoring Opera fans.

Arts in Motion

Strong consumer spending helps boost US growth

Expert says the newly released third-quarter figures are a useful indicator of the resilience of the US economy.

Opening Bell

BBC Talking Movies top 10 films of 2025

Talking Movies presenter Tom Brook looks back at 2025 to pick the top 10 films of the year.

Film & TV

US markets start the week higher after period of volatility

US markets start the week higher on renewed AI enthusiasm after a period of volatility.

Opening Bell

Köttbullar: The secret behind the iconic Swedish meatballs

Ikea’s meatballs turn 40. We asked Swedes how Köttbullar became a global phenomenon.

Culture & Experiences

Tech stocks to drive growth next year

Martin Baccardax, senior writer at Barron's, says tech stocks are likely to continue to drive markets in 2026.

Opening Bell

The AI toys taking over Christmas shopping lists

Tech Now investigates the latest AI toys on the market and how safe they are for children.

Tech Now

Lower than expected inflation boosts Wall Street shares

Shares on Wall Street have opened strongly and James Demmert explains what this means for consumers.

Opening Bell

The forgotten underground river that shaped Paris

Buried beneath Paris since 1912, the ghost river Bièvre shaped the French capital in unexpected ways.

The SpeciaList

Wall Street on track for third year of double-digit gains

Greg Halter, from the Carnegie Investment Counsel, says the markets have seen a third consecutive year of gains.

Opening Bell

George Clooney and Adam Sandler's recommended movies

The actors share their personal favourites and talk about why the films hold up today.

Film & TV

Watch playful hyena cubs cause mayhem

A group of hyena cubs play with the other animals drawn to the fallen fruit of the sausage trees near their den.

Wildlife