What Is Criminal Immunity? - Talks On Law

Customized for you...

Non-lawyer

Lawyer

Toggle navigation TALKSONLAW

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

TALKSONLAW Sign In Talks

• Talks
• Browse Talks
• Speakers

Briefs

• Briefs
• Browse Briefs
• Propose a Topic
• Nominate a Lawyer

Blog Lawyer CLE

• CLE
• The Difference
• CLE Map
• Satisfaction Guarantee
• Financial Aid
• Legal Heroes
• Mobile App
• Download The App

Search

• Sign In

× What is criminal immunity? Share 3:27

What is immunity and when and under what circumstances is criminal immunity offered? Is it actually a "get-out-of-jail-free" card or is it more complex? Former federal prosecutor and current law professor Bennett Capers explains.

Bennett Capers is a professor at Brooklyn Law School where he focuses on evidence, criminal procedure, and criminal law.

Related Briefs

Garland v. Cargill (on Bump Stocks) Explai...

Why did the Supreme Court reverse the federal ban on bump stocks? Professor Joseph Blocher of Duke Law School provide...

Mental Illness and Gun Rights

Is it constitutional to restrict gun rights for individuals with mental illness? Professor Jody Madeira of Indiana Ma...

Restricting Guns in Cases of Domestic Viol...

Current federal and state laws permit firearms restrictions in cases involving domestic violence protection orders, b...

The Second Amendment & Originalism

Second Amendment rights have emerged from often conflicting constitutional interpretations, but none has shaped its m...

Can a State Target Fighters in a Hospital?

Could Israel target Hamas fighters inside a hospital, or is it a war crime? Under the laws of war, targeting a hospit...

Are Gun Laws Racist

Are gun laws in the United States racist? We ask Professor Darrell Miller of Duke Law School to evaluate the history ...

1st v. 2nd: What Happens When Amendments C...

One of the most difficult questions in constitutional law walks the jeopardous terrain between the First and Second A...

What Weapons Get 2nd Amendment Protection?

The Second Amendment protects the right to bear arms, but what weapons exactly are covered by this Constitutional pro...

Music Sampling Rights

Intellectual property expert Joseph Fishman, Professor at Vanderbilt University Law School, gives an overview of  int...

Do you have to comply with police orders?

  Police commands can create legally binding obligations, the moment they are given, so do we always have to obey ...

What is the shadow docket?

The "shadow docket" refers to the set of expedited cases that the Supreme Court agrees to review outside of its stand...

Digital Dollar Privacy & Power

The majority of the world's leading economies have launched central bank digital currency ("CBDC") initiatives. In pa...

When is cryptocurrency a commodity?

When is cryptocurrency regulated as a commodity rather than as a security? We ask Christopher Giancarlo, the former h...

Due Process – Can a Litigant Appoint His J...

In this interview on judicial ethics and judicial recusal, Alicia Bannon (Brennan Center for Justice) explains the ru...

When is alt data illegal?

Alternative data or alt data is now fueling investment decisions at the world's leading private investment funds. So,...

The Lemon Test explained

In the 1971 Supreme Court case Lemon v. Kurtzmann, the Court established a test to determine whether legislation viol...

Major Questions Doctrine

In the controversial Supreme Court case, West Virginia v. EPA, the high court established a new regime to limit the p...

Text, History, & Tradition Test

The Supreme Court recently declared a new standard for Second Amendment jurisprudence, "text, history, and tradition....

NYSRPA v. Bruen

Constitutional scholar and Second Amendment expert, Prof. Jake Charles talks to Joel about the landmark gun law case,...

Sensitive Places under the Second Amendment

The Second Amendment to the United States Constitution protects the right to keep and bear arms, but that right has b...

More Than Two Legal Parents?

Traditionally, parents have come in pairs, but is two the legal maximum when it comes to parental rights?  How does t...

Sperm Donor Parental Rights

Are sperm donors legal parents?  How do states treat sperm donors and egg donors differently under the law?  Yale Law...

Surrogacy – Legal Risks

Parental rights in the U.S. are traditionally linked to childbirth, so how is the law adapting to the increased use o...

H-1B Visa Alternatives

With a cap on the number of H-1B visas issued per year and applications exceeding the quota on any given year, most p...

What Is the H-1B Visa?

The H-1B visa is one of the most popular visa categories for highly skilled workers holding bachelor’s degrees or hig...

Bourbon as Defined by Law

What makes bourbon bourbon? Bourbon is a uniquely American whiskey that is federally defined and regulated. Bourbon i...

Can the Police Require a Brain Scan?

Can the government compel an individual to undergo brain-based memory detection tests? Is there a constitutional righ...

Who Owns the Moon?

While United States astronauts were the first to visit the Moon, this does not mean that the United States owns it.  ...

Can lawyers lie in negotiations?

Are lawyers permitted to lie in business negotiations on behalf of their clients? What about exaggerating, puffing, o...

Are COVID-19 Vaccine Mandates at Universit...

With most schools planning a full return to campus in fall 2021 and COVID-19 cases on the rise again in pockets of th...

Crisis Management — the First 48hrs

When a crisis erupts, the first 24 to 48 hours are critical for a company. The steps taken in those first hours may s...

Returning to the Office — Employer Legal L...

Offices are reopening their doors after a year plus of interruptions, closures, and remote work during the COVID-19 p...

Can you record the police?

Under the Constitution, when can the police prevent the use of cameras in public? While the Supreme Court has not yet...

How do NFT royalties work?

One of the unique features of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) is the ability to distribute royalties from resales. When th...

When can police use deadly force?

Under the Constitution, when may police officers use deadly force? As Professor Rachel Harmon explains, generally, po...

Standard Essential Patents

Standards are necessary for wide adoption of technologies and to ensure interoperability. Mobile phones, for example,...

Offshore Wind Rights

The Biden administration has committed to building and expanding American clean energy infrastructure including offsh...

What is CFIUS?

The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) is an interagency committee that assesses the potent...

Can Hospital Workers Be Fired for Refusing...

The first batch of COVID-19 vaccinations are already being administered to healthcare workers in hospitals and long-t...

Ohio v. Amex

In 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court handed down a decision in Ohio v. Amex that sent ripples through the antitrust world....

The Failing Firm Defense

With an influx of distressed companies as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, the “failing firm” defense has been attr...

Returning to Work in a Pandemic

For Companies and Private Funds In the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, many companies and private funds shift...

SPACs – Trends and Structure after Tontine

In the summer of 2020, Tontine, the largest ever special purpose acquisition company (SPAC), debuted on the NY Stock ...

Termination for Bankruptcy Myth

Contracts often call for a termination right in cases of bankruptcy, but are such provisions enforceable? Rachel Alba...

What Is Bankruptcy Mothballing?

The COVID-19 virus and government shut-downs have triggered a historic wave of bankruptcies in the United States.  Fa...

Can the Police Lie to You?

When can the police deceive, and when do law enforcement lies go too far? Alex Spiro explores under what circumstance...

Can universities ban hate speech on campus?

Can public universities ban racist, sexist, or otherwise offensive speech?  Lee Rowland of the ACLU explains how the ...

Can you be fired for speech outside the of...

Can a private employer fire you for speech outside of work? Does the First Amendment offer protections to employees a...

Free speech: what constitutes "incitement?"

What constitutes "incitement" under the First Amendment? When is speech so violent and dangerous that it can be prohi...

Next Previous

What is criminal immunity? Brief Transcript

So what is immunity? Before I answer that question, allow me to introduce myself. My name is Bennett Capers. I’m a professor at Brooklyn Law School where I teach courses relating to criminal procedure and evidence and criminal law, and I’m also a former federal prosecutor. I was an assistant U.S. Attorney of the Southern District of New York. And there, the issue of immunity came up quite often.

So what is immunity? Really, immunity is what we use to say a "get out of jail free" card. It literally means that you might never be prosecuted. But technically, there are two types of immunity in the federal system. There’s something called use immunity, and there's something called transactional immunity.

So use immunity simply means that if a defendant comes in testifies or does whatever in exchange for immunity, the government won't use anything the defendant says to prosecute that defendant later on. So if a defendant has use immunity and says, “Oh, by the way I killed somebody,” because of use immunity, the government can’t actually use his statement to later prosecute him. But if the government finds independent evidence separate and apart from what the defendant says that points at his guilt, the government can use that information. So that’s why it's more limited.

Transactional immunity completely covers a defendant. So transactional immunity is basically a blanket immunity. The government is saying, “You will not be prosecuted for the following crimes no matter what. Even if we learn independent evidence, we still will not prosecute.” So that's what defendants prefer.

So how does one go about getting either use immunity or transactional immunity? In the federal system, it's actually given out very rarely. I don’t think prosecutors like giving it out, for good reason. There are other ways of getting information from defendants. If the defendant can make the pitch to the prosecutor, of course, the defendant is speaking through his lawyer, and usually what would be set up is a meeting where the defendant would be present, the defense lawyer, the prosecutor. And there would be a “Queen for a day” agreement basically during which the defendant would lay everything out on the table, say everything he has to say, say why his information is so valuable, and basically make the pitch to the prosecutor for why in exchange for his valuable information, he should be given immunity. One thing I should say about immunity is in the federal system, the government holds all the power, all the cards. This is one of the few areas where a federal judge is actually powerless. A judge cannot order a prosecutor to give a witness immunity. It's actually something the prosecutor decides. And in the federal system, it actually goes beyond simply the prosecutors offices; its actually a decision that goes through Washington.

So that’s a little nutshell about immunity in the federal system. My name is Bennett Capers, and thank you for watching TalksOnLaw.

× SIGN UP LOG IN

SIGN UP

Please make sure your email and password are correct. * First name Last name * Email * Password * Password confirmation I agree to the Terms and Conditions

Login

Please make sure your email and password are correct. * Email * Password Log in with Facebook Forgot your password?