'Who Gets What, When And How' - The Nation
Maybe your like
- nawaiwaqt group
- News Paper & TV Channel
- Magazines
Get Alerts
‘Who gets what, when and how’
Muhammad Zahid February 14, 2015 Columns Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Harold Lasswell defined politics as ‘who gets what, when and how’ and this definition of politics has encapsulated political behaviour around the world, with politicians being driven by political positions, resource distribution and out-competing their competitors. This has led to much political apathy around the world, along with the corporatization of the state, with vested interests penetrating political systems and having a large say over policy and legislation formulations. Professor Gidens from Princeton University, in his work ‘Affluence and Influence: Economic Inequality and Political Power in America,’ makes this point, with vested interests penetrating and dominating the US political system, with the views and the needs of the citizens becoming insignificant compared to that of vested interests. This overtaking of the state by vested interests, is a natural outcome of capitalism, with real power being held in the hands of the corporate sector that has the capital weight to fund political parties, the campaign of politicians and to put excessive capital behind lobbying campaigns to ensure their interests are met in formal political circles. This link between capital and politics has been a close one ever since the birth of the Western nation state and the secularization processes, with previous vested interests dominated by the Kings and religious classes being replaced by a new set of vested interests, that of capitalists that were able to create much more surplus value through economic enterprises and heightened colonialism in the 17th and 18th centuries. And this class was able to shape the nature of economic development, through determining where to invest capital, the type of goods produced and urban-rural shifts.The British capitalists in colonizing India did the exact same thing, with the colonialists enforcing a new capitalist development model that would benefit the centre and leave the periphery in a state of continuous economic shocks and crises. A clear example of this would be the series of famines which India would suffer, with millions perishing as basic foodstuffs were not being produced and at the same time stocks were being prevented from being released on to the market, as they were to be shipped to the centre for its needs. At the same time, one saw an emphasis on urban areas, ports and raw material exports that suited capitalist development of the centre. This capitalist development model did not end with the creation of Pakistan but continued, with colonial vested interests being taken over by feudal, industrial, military and bureaucratic interests that have continued with rapid urbanization; focus on low value products for exports, allowing the Pakistani market to be a dumping ground for surpluses from the capitalist centre and hindering industrialisation that would upset the capitalist balance institutionalised since the time of the British.Given this reality, with vested interests existing and dominating Pakistan, the political class has become a key component in the continuation of capital accumulation and surplus values through creating the environment for them to do so through legislation and policies. For example, the privatization policies of successive governments have transferred assets into the hands of vested interests that have been able to extract immense surplus values but at the same time inflict hardship on the people through employment cuts and price hikes. Another example are the excessive loans that are granted to vested interests for capital accumulation purposes but in many cases, the loans remain unpaid, only for the deficits to be made up by increased levels of taxation on the people. The winners are the vested interests, whereas the losers are the people that continue to suffer from one problem after another- whether that is a gas or petrol shortage. The political class has become a means for vested interests to continue to grow in their financial clout and have themselves taken on board the capitalist mantra of politics as defined by Lasswell of ‘who gets what, when and how’, with their motivations being like that of the vested interests- what do they get out of being in politics?The political class has benefited from the same system of personal gain, leading to the creation of a symbiotic relationship between the political class and vested interests, with both becoming inter-dependent on one another. The political class that depends on vested interests for bankrolling election campaigns and political party activities in return pays back the favours through legislation and policies that create ground for vested interests to thrive.This is one of the fundamental reasons why in Pakistan, problems continue to snowball as the focus is on interests that can be secured through politics and ties with vested interests. This is why politics has become a tainted word in Pakistan and so hated amongst the public as they see it being played out on TV screens on a daily basis. For example, the resignation of the Governor of Punjab, Mohammed Sarwar and him joining the PTI; is this because he actually believes the PTI has better policies, solutions and programmes to solve critical problems in Pakistan or because he believes the grass is greener on the other side, where his power and influence can be greater than living in the shadow of the Shareef family? Many would lean towards the latter reasoning for his sudden jump of ship and that would be consistent with what we have seen in Pakistani politics over the decades, where pragmatism, self interest, power, resources, influence and prestige have triumphed over ‘Naziriyah’ politics-meaning no politics, no solutions, no principles, no vision, no ideas but an avalanche of problems that keep on growing and imposing immense tension and stress on a population that has been and is drowning in a sea of misery while the political class and vested interests continue to prosper from their wealth, assets and resources.
Punjab CM Maryam Nawaz launches Phase III of Green Tractor Program
Share on Facebook Share on TwitterMuhammad Zahid
The writer is an assistant professor of political science at LUMS. Follow him on Twitter
Columns
US and Iran
US and Iran
February 21, 2026A National Army
A National Army
February 21, 2026The Miracle
The Miracle
February 21, 2026Indian State Terrorism Confirmed
Indian State Terrorism Confirmed
February 20, 2026The Failed Angels
The Failed Angels
February 20, 2026Silencing the Subalterns
Silencing the Subalterns
February 20, 2026Top Stories
Trump hikes global tariff to 15pc after SC ruling
Trump hikes global tariff to 15pc after SC ruling
February 22, 2026SC stays trial of PM Shehbaz defamation suit against Imran
SC stays trial of PM Shehbaz defamation suit against Imran
February 21, 2026Trump says considering limited strike on Iran
Trump says considering limited strike on Iran
February 21, 202616 dead after building collapses in Karachi following blast
16 dead after building collapses in Karachi following blast
February 20, 2026Pakistan, US sign MoU to redevelop Roosevelt Hotel
Pakistan, US sign MoU to redevelop Roosevelt Hotel
February 20, 2026Naqvi downplays propaganda over Imran’s health as jail report lands ...
Naqvi downplays propaganda over Imran’s health as jail report lands in court
February 18, 2026Latest
Punjab CM Maryam Nawaz launches Phase III of Green Tractor Program
3:46 PM | February 22, 2026Somalia in talks to buy up to 24 JF-17 Block III jets from Pakistan
3:43 PM | February 22, 2026Pakistan sugar imports surge 7,900% amid NAB corruption probe
2:17 PM | February 22, 2026FC Balochistan offers 24/7 medical care at Quetta hospital
12:47 PM | February 22, 2026Punjab Safe Cities Authority launches online complaint tracking system
12:44 PM | February 22, 2026Editor's Picks
-
February Fractures
-
Extremist ideologies driving Indian army, institutions: DG ISPR
-
'No talk of President Zardari resigning or COAS seeking Presidency': Naqvi rejects rumours
-
Pilgrims perform final Hajj ritual as Eidul Azha begins amid tight security and heat measures
-
Hajj 2025 sermon: Imam-e-Kaaba prays for Palestine, urges unity and compassion
Columns
US and Iran
US and Iran
by Rear Admiral (retd) Faisal Shah February 21, 2026A National Army
A National Army
by Masud Ahmad Khan February 21, 2026The Miracle
The Miracle
by Najm us Saqib February 21, 2026Indian State Terrorism Confirmed
Indian State Terrorism Confirmed
by Malik Muhammad Ashraf February 20, 2026The Failed Angels
The Failed Angels
by Tanveer Ashraf February 20, 2026ePaper
Blogs
The Mandate for National Unity
The Mandate for National Unity
by Tanweer Ahmed February 08, 2026Green Pakistan initiative: Transformation of ...
Green Pakistan initiative: Transformation of agriculture, ...
by Dr. Sadia Khattak January 30, 2026Pakistan Needs a Shared Boardroom
Pakistan Needs a Shared Boardroom
by Tanweer Ahmed January 18, 2026Advancing Trade Governance and Financial ...
Advancing Trade Governance and Financial Integrity Through ...
by Umair Wahab December 26, 2025Pakistan at the crossroads of a changing ...
Pakistan at the crossroads of a changing world
by Lt Gen Rizwan Akhtar (Retired) December 04, 2025Cartoons
Cartoon
February 21, 2026Editorials
Guarded Giving
February 21, 2026Escalation As Strategy
February 21, 2026Balancing Expectations
February 21, 2026Before the Storm
February 20, 2026Educating the Future
February 20, 2026Letters
A New Normal
February 21, 2026US Failure on Iran
February 21, 2026Easy Alcohol Access
February 21, 2026Islamabad Mourns
February 21, 2026Fixing KP Education
February 21, 2026ePaper - Nawaiwaqt
Newsletter Subscription
Latest HighlightsFollow Us
Contact Us
NIPCO House, 4 - Shaharah e Fatima Jinnah,
Lahore, Pakistan
Tel: +92 42 36367580 | Fax : +92 42 36367005
- Advertise With Us
- Contact Us
- About Us
- Privacy Policy
- Copyrights
- AI Use Policy
Nawaiwaqt Group | Copyright © 2026
News CMS by 
Nawaiwaqt Group | Copyright © 2026
Tag » Who Gets What When And How
-
Politics: Who Gets What, When, How | Work By Lasswell - Britannica
-
Politics: Who Gets What, When, How. By Harold D. Lasswell. (New ...
-
Who Gets What, When, How - Through Which Electoral System?
-
Politics Who Gets What, When And How: Lasswell, Harold D.
-
Politics: Who Gets What, When, How Paperback – October 15, 2011
-
POLITICS: WHO GETS WHAT, AND HOW? - Sage Publications
-
Politics: Who Gets What, When, How EBook By Harold D. Lasswell
-
Politics: Who Gets What, When, How - Foreign Affairs
-
Harold D. Lasswell, Politics: Who Gets What, When, How, Cleveland ...
-
Who Described Politics As 'who Gets What, When, And How'?
-
Politics; Who Gets What, When, How