Why Did Pat McAfee Retire? - Indianapolis Colts

Skip to main content Advertising Why Did Pat McAfee Retire?

Intro: Making some media rounds on Thursday, Pat McAfee explained why he decided to abruptly retire at the age of 29, with two years remaining on his contract.

Feb 02, 2017 at 10:36 AM

Kevin Bowen

Colts.com Writer

• Copied!

INDIANAPOLIS – When Jim Irsay walked out of the Indiana Farm Bureau Football Center pavilion early Monday evening, he had just introduced a new general manager to his fan base.

What Irsay, and his fan base, didn't know was some other major news was on the verge of being revealed.

Arguably the most popular player on the Colts was about to tell his boss that he was retiring from the NFL at the age of 29.

Inside of Irsay's office on Monday night, Pat McAfee delivered the news face-to-face.

"We sat down for an hour and 45 minutes in his office," McAfee said on the Dan Patrick Show about informing Irsay that he was retiring with two years remaining on his contract. "For the first 15 minutes, (Irsay) was a little confused and was trying to lure me back. But once he saw my excitement and my incredible gratitude to him…all he did was support me. He's excited for me.

"He said he'll walk into my office if he feels the need that I need to be punting again. It was a funny conversation, a great conversation. To have his backing and support really meant a lot to me."

Along with Irsay, who gave McAfee some articles to potentially help him in his next job, the two-time Pro Bowl punter also met with Chuck Pagano late in the 2016 season to let the head coach know of what had been stirring in his mind for a couple of seasons.

McAfee joining budding sports media site Barstool Sports, as the Chief Operating Officer of the Indianapolis headquarters, was something that really started to gain momentum back in mid-November.

The creative and comedic sides of McAfee have been something we've seen more and more in recent years.

With the physical toll adding to his right knee, McAfee decided the time was now to fully pursue something he's always longed for.

"Staring down my third knee surgery in four years, with more knee surgeries certain for the future, (injuries were) definitely a part of (my decision)," McAfee said of abruptly retiring. "My knees have really taken a beating. For the last half of the season, I couldn't really walk much on days that I kicked. I would stay in bed and ice my knees. I felt like a 90-year-old man. Going into work I was like, 'There has to be more to work than kicking balls.'

"When Barstool Sports approached me about the potential of joining their family whenever I'm done with football, I told them, 'I might be done sooner than most think.'"

Talks with Barstool picked up from there, highlighted by McAfee's announcement early Thursday morning.

Official retirement papers still need to be signed by McAfee. The former All-Pro admits he was googling Thursday morning 'how to actually retire from the NFL.'

McAfee will continue to call Indianapolis home, working out of a downtown studio while producing all sorts of content, i.e. blogs, podcasts, videos, for Barstool. McAfee will have a radio show on SIRIUS starting in the coming weeks. He will also have a show on the Barstool social channels, airing at 5:00 p.m. EST.

The elephant in the room for McAfee is why would such a successful punter walk away from guaranteed millions?

"For me, I didn't want to focus on kicking balls anymore," McAfee says.

"I wanted to focus on a different direction and hopefully make the world a happier place. I want to turn my obsessive like focus for football, and for kicking a ball, and turn it into something I think will affect a lot more people."* *

Chuck Pagano on Pat McAfee: pic.twitter.com/gpNTIW5jaa

— Kevin Bowen (@KBowen1070) February 2, 2017

• The analysis from those producing content on Colts.com does not necessarily represent the thoughts of the Indianapolis Colts organization. Any conjecture, analysis or opinions formed by Colts.com content creators is not based on inside knowledge gained from team officials, players or staff.*

This article has been reproduced in a new format and may be missing content or contain faulty links. Please use the Contact Us link in our site footer to report an issue.

Related Content

news

Colts awarded 2 7th-round compensatory picks in 2026 NFL Draft

The Colts now have seven selections in the 2026 NFL Draft. 

news

Alec Pierce has always been a 'priority' for the Colts. This is one big reason why. 

Pierce's ability to win on vertical, downfield routes provides a skillset that's becoming harder and harder to find in today's modern NFL. 

news

Colts WR Alec Pierce announces new contract with Colts

Pierce, originally selected by the Colts in the second round of the 2022 NFL Draft, has become one of the league's top downfield receivers.

news

Former Colts C Ryan Kelly announces retirement from NFL

Kelly played for the Colts from 2016-2024.

news

Colts win multiple 2026 BART List awards

The Colts were recognized as one of the three best pro departments in the league.

news

After strong rookie year, Colts see even more for Tyler Warren in 2026

General manager Chris Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen spoke at the 2026 NFL Combine about Warren's success in his rookie year and his potential in 2026.

news

Why NFL analysts aren't worried about Colts' lack of first-round draft pick: 'It's Sauce Gardner'

While the Colts didn't see a lot of Sauce Gardner in 2025, they, along with national analysts, are optimistic about what the All-Pro cornerback will bring in 2026.

news

The Colts currently have 5 picks in the 2026 NFL Draft. Here's how GM Chris Ballard plans to get more

The Colts are projected to have at least seven picks in this year's draft.

news

Colts GM Chris Ballard, HC Shane Steichen provide updates on Charvarius Ward Sr. 

General manager Chris Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen spoke to the media on Tuesday at the NFL Combine about Ward's outlook for 2026 after the cornerback said he would be reevaluating his future in football after sustaining multiple concussions in 2025.

news

Colts announce 2026 coaching staff

Here is what the Colts' 2026 coaching staff will look like this upcoming year.

news

TUNE IN: General manager Chris Ballard and head coach Shane Steichen at NFL Scouting Combine Tuesday, February 24

Watch live on Colts.com, Colts mobile app, Colts Facebook page, @Colts on X and Colts Youtube channel.

news

NFL Network's Daniel Jeremiah on strengths of 2026 NFL Draft class, possible options for Colts

Jeremiah, the lead NFL Draft analyst for NFL Network, spoke about the 2026 NFL Draft prior to the NFL Combine.

Want more Colts content from the official source? Add Colts.com to your list of source preferences on Google today!

Advertising Big left arrow icon Big right arrow icon Close icon Copy Url Three dots icon Down arrow icon Email icon Email icon Exit Fullscreen icon External link icon Facebook logo Football icon Facebook logo Instagram logo Snapchat logo YouTube logo TikTok logo Spotify logo LinkedIn logo Grid icon Key icon Left arrow icon Link icon Location icon Mail icon Menu icon Open icon Phone icon Play icon Radio icon Rewind icon Right arrow icon Search icon Select icon Selected icon TV icon Up arrow icon User icon Audio icon Add to calendar iconNFC icon AFC icon NFL icon Carousel IconList ViewWebsite InstagramTwitterFacebookSnapchatShop IconProfile Overlay AvatarAddAirplayArrow LeftArrow RightArrow UpArrow DownAudioBack 5sBack 10sBack 30sCalendarChartCheckDownLeftRightUpChromecast OffChromecast OnCloseClosed CaptionsBench OffBench OnBroad OffBroad OnVertical OffVertical OnCommentDockDoneDownloadDraftFantasyFilterForward 5sForward 10sForward 30sFull Screen OffFull Screen OnGamepassGamesInsightsKeyLeaveLiveCombineDraftFantasyMenu GamesMenu NetworkMenu NewsMenu PlayoffsMenu Pro BowlMenu ShopMenu StandingsMenu StatsMenu Super BowlMenu TeamsMenu TicketsMenuMore HorizontalMore VerticalMy LocationNetworkNewsPauseplayMultiple PlayersSingle PlayerPlaylistPlayoffsPro BowlPurgeRefreshRemoveSearchSettingsShare AndroidShare Copy URLShare EmailShare FacebookShare InstagramShare iOSShare SnapchatShare TwitterSkip NextSkip PreviousStandingsStarStatsSwapTeamsTicketsVideoVisibility OffVisibility OnVolume HiVolume LowVolume MediumVolume MuteWarningWebsite Caret downCaret upAtNewsPlayAudioGalleryPromo Chevron right The browser you are using is no longer supported on this site. It is highly recommended that you use the latest versions of a supported browser in order to receive an optimal viewing experience. The following browsers are supported: Chrome, Edge (v80 and later), Firefox and Safari. Got it!