Concealability Of G48 (or 43x) Vs G19 - Glock Talk

Có thể bạn quan tâm

menu Log in Sign up

Home
Forums
Practical Tactics
Carry Issues

Glocktalk is a forum community dedicated to Glock enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about Sig Sauer pistols and rifles, optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, and more!

#1 · Feb 12, 2019 The 48 and 43x have been in the wild for a little while now. People are buying them, and presumably strapping them on. I assume some of these people own, and have carried, G19s. So how do the new guns compare as carry weapons to the 19? Is there any practical, visible concealability advantage? Carry comfort advantage? I know some people are liking the thinner grip for shooting comfort reasons, but for this thread at least, I'm asking about concealment issues. So, basically, what's the verdict? Sort by Oldest first Oldest first Newest first Most reactions 1 2 #2 · Feb 12, 2019 A thinner gun will carry more comfortably 'bout 100% of the time, even if it's only a little thinner, but I don't hear too much about a thinner grip being more comfortable to shoot. Usually, it's the other way around. It's safe to say the 48 and 43X would be more comfortable to shoot than a 43, but the 19 would be more comfortable to shoot than the 43X or 48...all in theory, of course. YgripthicknesscomfortlevelMMV. #5 · Feb 12, 2019

harold63 said: A thinner gun will carry more comfortably 'bout 100% of the time Click to expand...

That's not the case for me. I don't own a 19, but I do own a 26 which is the same thickness as the 19, except for the mag well flare on the 19 which has no bearing on comfort. I carry both my 26 and 48 in Vedder LightTuck IWB holsters, and I actually find the 26 to be slightly more comfortable, but they're very close. Now my 42 (also in a Vedder LightTuck) is more comfortable than either the 26 or the 48, but it's all about the weight rather than the size or thickness. Show more replies 0 Reply #3 · Feb 12, 2019 I have been thinking about a 43X but I’m not really seeing it as much better than a 19 other than a little weight. I think the thickness is more in the mind as far as concealability. Just weighing out the benefits of a 43X over what I have (23, 26, and Shield) and the costs of new sights, mags, and holsters. Would the 43X carry that much better? I’m not sure of that one also. The only reason I’m looking is because I have a certificate. #4 · Feb 12, 2019 If I'm carrying a gun as big as a G 19 such as the G48 I'll just carry the G19. I have never liked carrying IWB on anything as large as the 19. Since the 19 and 48 are basically the same size other than thickness it makes sense to stay with my 19 for OWB carry. I have the 43 which I carry 95% of the time IWB. I just don't see the 43x or 48 as something I want or need. I'm not a fan of the slide color or front slide serration. Yeah, that's how I see it and there are several others who like just the opposite, and that's ok too. Glock was late to the party with a small shootable 10 rd gun. 43X and 48 are a no go for me. Still a Glock fan though. I have the 17,19,19X G45, 26 and 43. My bases are covered in Glock 9mm. Good luck in your quest. #6 · Feb 12, 2019 One thing that appealed to me about Glock was capacity! Something they seem to be getting away from. Also what appealed to me was that one holster could be used for 3 different models and the fact that a 33,17,15,10 rd mag would fit into a G26! Amazing to say the least. The guns Glock is coming out with just dont fit into that part of the spectrum for me. In this case I would get the G19 over these silver models, but thats me. IMO if you looking for small, thin and capacity it wont be a Glock. Now if you are stuck in a 10 rd commie state then thats another story and the Glocks might be for you. #38 · Jan 2, 2022 Im pretty sure that’s exactly who Glock came up with these guns for. The baby subs were developed during the AWB and mag capacity followed suit. 0 Reply #8 · Feb 12, 2019 The 48 prints a bit more because of the grip height, but less than I would have expected. The width of the 26 is no issue at all for me, because I don't wear tight clothes. #9 · Feb 12, 2019 I carry a 29 In a Mtac holster, and I carry a 33 in the same thing. I dont really notice any difference in comfort between the two of them. But when I carry the 43 in a soft iwb holster it vanishes for sure. So I wouldnt mind trying the 48. #10 · Feb 13, 2019 I guess if you want to get technical the the 43X would conceal better. I feel people put to much thought in “printing” on concealing. Carry what’s comfortable. And cover it up. Most people don’t really give thought to who is or isn’t carrying. I can’t say I ever even look, nor do most people. #11 · Feb 13, 2019

TnShooter0083 said: I can’t say I ever even look, nor do most people. Click to expand...

Situational Awareness Show more replies 0 Reply #12 · Feb 13, 2019 48 is more comfortable to carry IWB, for me, than a G26. The G26 isn’t really a problem to carry, it’s just that the G48 pokes me less when sitting down, twisting, etc... and makes my pants feel less tight in the waistband. #15 · Feb 13, 2019 It's all about trade-offs and what you can conceal under whatever you're wearing. I pretty much always wear the type of clothes I can conceal whatever I want. But while I can reliably conceal my G30 with two spare mags on my belt, there sure is a big difference in weight and thickness between that and the G48 or my P365. Yeah, it's only around a quarter of an inch in thickness and probably 8 or 10 ounces loaded, but it sure as heck FEELS like it's more than that. It's all about trade-offs though. Sometimes I'm absolutely willing to carry something heavier and thicker and like carrying a .45 ACP. Other times, I'm fine going a little lighter and more comfortable. I'm glad I can make that choice. #16 · Feb 13, 2019

dj45 said: It's all about trade-offs and what you can conceal under whatever you're wearing. I pretty much always wear the type of clothes I can conceal whatever I want. But while I can reliably conceal my G30 with two spare mags on my belt, there sure is a big difference in weight and thickness between that and the G48 or my P365. Yeah, it's only around a quarter of an inch in thickness and probably 8 or 10 ounces loaded, but it sure as heck FEELS like it's more than that. It's all about trade-offs though. Sometimes I'm absolutely willing to carry something heavier and thicker and like carrying a .45 ACP. Other times, I'm fine going a little lighter and more comfortable. I'm glad I can make that choice. Click to expand...

I feel the same way. My G29 is, well, you can tell it's there iwb. No debating that fact. But I love that gun, it feels GREAT IN my hand, and I am just comfortable with it. Yet, when the 33 goes in its place, I'm not noticing it as much by the of the day. When the 43 comes out, I cant even tell I have it on. 0 Reply #17 · Feb 13, 2019

Scrappy said: One thing that appealed to me about Glock was capacity! Something they seem to be getting away from. Also what appealed to me was that one holster could be used for 3 different models and the fact that a 33,17,15,10 rd mag would fit into a G26! Amazing to say the least. The guns Glock is coming out with just dont fit into that part of the spectrum for me. In this case I would get the G19 over these silver models, but thats me. IMO if you looking for small, thin and capacity it wont be a Glock. Now if you are stuck in a 10 rd commie state then thats another story and the Glocks might be for you. Click to expand...

Glock is not getting away from high capacity. All the original capacity models are still available. Regards, Happyguy

#25 · Feb 13, 2019 I take the 43x as Glocks quick, and maybe a bit panicked reply to the SIG P365. We'll see if they come out with a short and slim 10 rounder down the line. 0 Reply #18 · Feb 13, 2019 I don’t get this printing I carried a G19 and now I have a 43x and it is much easier to carry compared to my G19 now do they print probably and really who cares I carry what is more comfortable and if you look at me someone would say he looks like a guy that would carry a gun anyway so you know Iam armed don’t do anything to me or my family and if you want to point at me and say I have a gun so be it that’s what concelled permits are for.. #19 · Feb 13, 2019 Yep, I agree. At least in my state for the moment, it's legal to open carry. So even if someone were to spot my gun, which hasn't happened yet that I know of, the open carry law combined with my permit has me covered. Of course I acknowledge that keeping it concealed is very important. That whole painting a target on your back if people know you're armed, thing. In general though, people these days really just need to mind their own damn business. Show more replies 0 Reply #21 · Feb 13, 2019 Based on the laws of physics, I’m guessing they conceal and print the same but are more comfortable to carry. #22 · Feb 13, 2019 Been carrying and concealing a 19 since '89...see no need to change now #23 · Feb 13, 2019 If it works for you, that's all that matters. 2 Replies #26 · Feb 13, 2019 I have a G19, 26, 27, 17L and now a G48, have carried a 9mm Shield the most and have most everything else PPQ, P01, P07, etc, etc. I'm 6'2" and 175lbs and just cannot make IWB comfortable with anything. I stopped carrying the 19, 26, 27 because they felt too fat using my favorite comp-tac paddle holsters. Because comp-tac does not yet make a paddle holster for the 48 I bought RCS Perun for the 48 and it just melts into me. This Perun/48 combination perfectly follow my body contour and bring the center of gravity way inboard. The combination is easy to sit/drive with and the tip/bottom of the holster is hidden by my vests, jackets and un-tucked shirts/T-shirts. #27 · Feb 13, 2019 In my opinion Glock didn’t set out only to make a series of Glocks that were anymore concealable then the G19, G26 series, sure a “Thinner” Glock should Conceal a d carry better then their larger brothers. My thinking is that with all these states restricting mag caparity to 10 rounds and more to follow Glock hedged thier bet in keeping these folks in the Glock camp. But do you really believe that with Glock’s excellent engineering and production capabilities it’s limiting its self only to 9mm? Da ! S&W produced a 45ACP Shield keeping its deminsions very close to the 9mm and 40. How about a 10 Round Glock in the 43x and 48 series ? I’ve no doubt Glock can do it to “Perfection”. #29 · Sep 23, 2020 My G48 with15 round magazines is concealed carry Nirvana. I still find myself carrying my G30S most of the time though. As much as I like my G19, it is rarely carried anymore. Regards, Happyguy

#30 · Sep 23, 2020 The 19 and the 23 were always too thick and chunky for both comfort and concealability. The 43x is much better but I wish they them without the dumbass forward slide serrations. The forward slide serrations should be optional so those who like them can have them but those that don't, have a choice. I'd also like to see them make the same gun (43x) in 40 caliber but that will never happen unless they make one with a heavier thicker slide or just get rid of the ambi safety and bring back the third pin. I don't like the G48 and much prefer the G43x. #31 · Sep 24, 2020 Replace it with a 43 slide. 0 Reply #32 · Oct 11, 2020 I have EDC a Glock 19 off and on for 20+ years. I bought a 48 in February this year. The 48 is distinctly thinner and slightly lighter (even using 15 round Shield Arms mags in the 48.) Thinner is always better for IWB. Printing for me is more a matter of how your dress around the gun. I have carried a Glock 34 IWB many miles without any problems concealing it. For most relatively new to concealed carry or those who carry rarely, being very self-conscious of the presence of the gun is understandable. The idea of printing is part of that self-consciousness. For those who carry daily and have for a long time, we literally forget we are wearing the gun. Dress around the gun. Be confident that the weapon is properly concealed by your clothing/holster choices. Acknowledge that 95% of the people around you are wrapped up in their own little worlds and totally oblivious to those around them. YMMV. #33 · Oct 11, 2020 When I set outside reading a book, my G43X in an IWB. When I go somewhere my G45 is carried. The G45 is my favorite Glock(never leave home w/o it). #34 · Oct 11, 2020 Don’t over think this. Unless you’re a gun guy 99% of the population are to busy going on with their lives. When I first started carrying I thought everyone new I was carrying. In Arkansas no one cares. #35 · Dec 29, 2021 I think that the thinner the gun, the easier it is for ME to conceal. I did a test with my 19 and 43x. The way I carried it was IWB and also with a belly holster. With either of those methods, it is 43x hands down the winner. It was about the slimness and weight. When I carried OWB, the 43x won again. While the 19 was tolerable OWB, the 43x was slim and the lesser weight made a huge difference. I can't believe I used to pocket carry a 19. The 43x has me spoiled. I can imagine, based on this test, I can still carry a 48 more comfortably and more concealed than a 19. #36 · Dec 29, 2021 My post # 33 is dated and I now carry my 43X everywhere. It is so lite and small that it is a pleasure to carry. I must admit that I also always carry two spare mags. All my mags. are OEM 10 rounders. #37 · Jan 1, 2022 My G19 is more comfortable to shoot, but my G48 is MUCH more comfortable to carry IWB. #39 · Jan 4, 2022 I've CCW'd a G19 since the early 2000's, and I shoot it very well. I've taken several shooting classes with it. But I've always had a minor issue with the girth of the grip. About five years ago I got a G43. I shoot the G43 more accurately than I do the G19. I haven't identified the reason why, I just shoot the G43 better. After Shield Arms released its 15 round magazine for the G43X/G48, I started wondering how I'd shoot a G48 compared to my G19. So I bought one. I discovered that I also shoot it more accurately than my G19. So... I bought some Shield Arms 15 rd magazines and steel magazine catch. Unfortunately the Shield Arms magazines aren't as reliable as the 10 rd Glock OEM magazines. I suspect the problem is probably due to an out-of-spec breechface on the G48's slide, which causes an intermittent failure to feed with Shield Arms magazines but not Glock OEM magazines. I removed the steel magazine catch and replaced it with the plastic Glock OEM magazine catch and I've been CCW'ing the G48 in lieu of my Glock 19. I've carried it in several different modes and holsters. For AIWB carry, the G48 is more comfortable for me than the girthier G19. I've been experimenting with different AIWB holsters and I found the JM Custom Kydex Wing Claw 2.5, with the wide hole pattern and pull the dot loops, is the most comfortable when used with the Mastermind Tactics Appendix Carry adjustable pillow pad. I've found the G48 conceals better, AIWB, than the G19, due to its slightly slimmer girth. (I haven't yet found an AIWB holster that's comfortable with G19 for long periods of sitting. I've tried Tenicor, Keepers, and JM Custom Kydex and they all deliver about the same amount of eventual discomfort.) I've also carried both the G19 and G48 in IWB and OWB holsters. I've noticed the G48 conceals slightly better than the G19 when I carry IWB at 3:30-4:00 o'clock. I have a JM Custom Kydex IWB 3 holster for each pistol, both with a 20-degree cant. I haven't noticed any difference in concealment when CCW'ing the G48 in a JM Custom Kydex OWB 2 holster. #40 · Jan 4, 2022 I carried a G19 Gen 3 for years, it was my sole EDC. I tried several other handguns as far as conceal carry but the G19 always seemed to have the advantage. I carried IWB about 4'O clock position and was happy to continue doing so till I picked up a Glock 43X recently. I definitely like it for the slimmer profile, it carries much easier as far as not printing, it actually disappears quite nicely with my JM4 holster. I put night sights, and a Handleit grip on it, and I use the SA Gen 2 15-round mags which have ran flawlessly so far through it. After many years, I'm starting to like carrying the G43X just due to it's lighter, slimmer, and I'm determined to get better with it. I'm not as proficient with it as I am my G19, but I'm hoping to be eventually. It's a good trade off for the small frame weapon. In short, I've become a fan of the 43X after refusing to carry anything other than a G19 for 15 years now. 1 2 This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread. Insert Quotes Quotes Post Reply

21.2M posts
187.9K members
Since 1999

A forum community dedicated to Glock firearm owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, troubleshooting, accessories, classifieds, and more! Show Less Full Forum Listing Explore Our Forums General Glocking General Firearms Forum Sold/Expired Cop Talk GSSF