Menstrual Cup Dangers: Risks, Safety, And Benefits - Healthline

Có thể bạn quan tâm

HealthlineSubscribe

Sexual Health

Are Menstrual Cups Dangerous? Here’s What You Need to Know

Medically reviewed by Stacy A. Henigsman, DO — Written by Rachel Nall, MSN, CRNA — Updated on June 29, 2022

What they are
Potential risks
Cups vs. pads and tampons
Benefits vs. risks
Don’t use if
Who it’s good for
How to select the right cup
How to safely use a cup
See a doctor
FAQs
The takeaway

Person taking pink menstrual cup out of packaging. — nensuria/Getty Images

Things to consider

Menstrual cups are generally regarded as safe within the medical community.

Although there are some risks, they’re considered minimal and unlikely to occur when the cup is used as recommended. It’s also important to consider that all menstrual products carry some degree of risk.

It ultimately comes down to finding the product and method that you’re most comfortable with.

Here’s what you need to know about using menstrual cups.

What are menstrual cups?

Menstrual cups are small, flexible receptacles that are inserted into the vaginal canal to catch menstrual blood. They are an alternative to sanitary pads, period underwear, or tampons during menstruation.

Menstrual cups come in a variety of shapes and sizes and are made of different components. These include:

natural rubber
silicone
thermoplastic elastomers (TPE)

This allows the cups to be washed and reused. Some menstrual cups can last up to 10 years. However, manufacturers do sell disposable, one-time-use menstrual cups.

What are the potential risks?

You’re more likely to experience minor irritation from wearing the wrong cup size than you are to develop a severe complication like toxic shock syndrome (TSS).

Understanding how and why these complications occur can help you reduce your overall risk of adverse effects.

Irritation

Irritation can happen for a number of reasons, and, for the most part, they’re all preventable. For example, inserting the cup without proper lubrication can cause discomfort.

In many cases, applying a small amount of water-based lube to the outside of the cup can help prevent this. Be sure to read the manufacturer’s recommendations on the product packaging for further clarification.

Irritation can also occur if the cup isn’t the right size or if it isn’t cleaned properly between uses. We’ll discuss cup selection and care later in this article.

Infection

Infection is a rare complication of menstrual cup use.

If an infection does occur, it’s more likely from the transfer of bacteria on hands to the cup than from the cup itself.

For example, yeast infections and bacterial vaginosis can develop if bacteria in the vagina — and subsequently vaginal pH — becomes imbalanced.

You can reduce your risk by washing your hands thoroughly with warm water and antibacterial soap before handling the cup.

You should also wash your cup with warm water and a mild, fragrance-free, water-based soap before and after use.

One over-the-counter soap to try is Neutrogena Liquid Soap. Scent-free, oil-free cleansers made for infants are also good alternatives, such as Cetaphil Gentle Skin Cleanser or Dermeze Soap-Free Wash.

TSS

Toxic shock syndrome (TSS) is a rare but serious complication that can result from certain bacterial infections.

It occurs when Staphylococcus or Streptococcus bacteria — which naturally exist on your skin, nose, or mouth — are pushed deeper into the body.

TSS is typically associated with leaving a tampon inserted for longer than recommended or wearing a tampon with a higher-than-needed absorbency.

TSS as a result of tampon use is rare. It’s even rarer when using menstrual cups.

A 2019 review states five known reports of TSS associated with the use of a menstrual cup.

You can reduce your risk for TSS by:

washing your hands thoroughly with warm water and antibacterial soap before removing or inserting your cup
cleaning your cup as recommended by the manufacturer, usually with warm water and a mild, fragrance-free, oil-free soap, before insertion
applying a small amount of water or water-based lube (per manufacturer’s instructions) to the outside of the cup to aid insertion

How do cups compare to other menstrual products?

Safety

Menstrual cups are usually safe as long as you insert them with clean hands, remove them carefully, and clean them appropriately. If you aren’t committed to keeping them clean, however, you may wish to use a disposable product, like pads or tampons.

Cost

You pay a one-time price for a reusable cup — usually between $0.75 to $46.72 — and can use it for years with proper care. Disposable cups, tampons, and pads must be continually bought.

Sustainability

Menstrual cups that are designed for reuse cut down on the number of pads or tampons in landfills.

Ease of use

Menstrual cups aren’t as easy to use as pads but can be similar to tampons in terms of insertion. Learning to remove the menstrual cup can take time and practice, but usually gets easier with repeated use.

Holding volume

Menstrual cups can hold varying amounts of blood, but on heavy days, you may have to rinse or change them more frequently than you’re used to.

You may be able to wait up to 12 hours — the max recommended time — before you have to change your cup, whereas you may need to change a pad or tampon every 4 to 6 hours.

IUDs

All menstrual hygiene products — cups included — are safe to use if you have an IUD. There aren’t many large-scale reviews that report menstrual cup use affects IUD location.

However, one review found seven reports of women who experienced IUD expulsion while using a menstrual cup. Four out of the seven women had their IUDs placed as recently as 6 weeks to 13 months, which could potentially have affected placement.

However, researchers in one older 2012 study found your risk for IUD expulsion is the same regardless of whether you use a menstrual cup.

Vaginal sex

If you have vaginal sex while wearing a tampon, the tampon may get pushed higher into the body and become stuck. The longer it’s there, the more likely it is to cause complications.

Although menstrual cups won’t get dislodged in the same way as tampons, their position may make penetration uncomfortable.

Some cups may be more comfortable than others. The Ziggy Cup, for example, was designed to accommodate vaginal sex.

Do the benefits outweigh the risks?

The general medical consensus is that menstrual cups are safe to use.

As long as you use the cup as directed, your overall risk for adverse side effects is minimal. Some people like them because they’re reusable and don’t have to be changed as often as other products.

Whether they’re right for you ultimately comes down to your individual comfort level.

If you’ve experienced recurrent vaginal infections and are concerned about increasing your risk, talk with a doctor or other healthcare professional before use.

They can answer any questions you have and may be able to recommend a specific cup or other menstrual product.

Is there anyone who shouldn’t use a menstrual cup?

Although there aren’t any official guidelines around this — most manufacturers recommend cups for all ages and sizes — cups may not be an option for everyone.

You may find it helpful to talk with a healthcare professional before use if you have:

vaginismus, which can make vaginal insertion or penetration painful
uterine fibroids, which can cause heavy periods and pelvic pain
endometriosis, which can result in painful menstruation and penetration
variations in uterine position, which can affect cup placement

Having one or more of these conditions doesn’t automatically mean that you can’t use a menstrual cup. It just means that you may experience more discomfort during use.

Your provider can discuss your individual benefits and risks and may be able to guide you on product selection.

Who are menstrual cups good for?

Menstrual cups offer several benefits to the user. These include:

People trying to save money on menstrual products. Because menstrual cups last a long time, you can save money from having to purchase tampons or pads.
Those looking to minimize menstrual odor. While there’s a learning curve for menstrual cup insertion, an estimated 90 percent of those who use menstrual cups find them easy to use and enjoy the dryness and less odor compared to other menstrual management methods. One of the major keys is to ensure a menstrual cup is well-fitting. If the cup leaks or is difficult to remove, these are signs the cup doesn’t fit well.
People trying to reduce their carbon footprint. Menstrual cups generate less trash and require fewer purchases, making them an environmentally friendly option.

These are just some of the examples of why you may find menstrual cups advantageous compared to other options.

How do you know which cup is right for you?

Menstrual cups can come in slightly varied shapes and sizes. Sometimes it’s hard to know the best one to purchase. Here are a few tips.

Size

Most manufacturers offer either a “small” or a “large” cup. Although the same language is used across manufacturers, there isn’t a standard for sizing dimensions.

Small cups are usually 35 to 43 millimeters (mm) in diameter at the rim of the cup. Large cup diameters are usually 43 to 48 mm.

Pro tip
As a general rule, select a cup based on your age and history of childbirth rather than your anticipated flow. Although the volume the cup can hold is important, you want to make sure that the cup is wide enough to stay in place.

A smaller cup may be best if you’ve never had intercourse or typically use absorbency tampons.

If you’ve had a vaginal delivery or have a weak pelvic floor, you may find that a larger cup fits best.

Sometimes, discovering the right size is a matter of trial and error.

Material

Most menstrual cups are made from silicone. However, some are made from rubber or contain rubber components. This means if you’re allergic to latex, the material could cause irritation.

You should always read the product label before use to learn more about the materials in any menstrual product.

How to use a menstrual cup

Your cup should come with instructions for care and cleaning. Here are some general guidelines:

Initial cleaning

It’s important to sterilize your menstrual cup before you insert it for the first time.

To do this:

Submerge the cup completely in a pot of boiling water for 5–10 minutes.
Empty the pot and allow the cup to return to room temperature.
Wash your hands with warm water and mild, antibacterial soap.
Wash the cup with a mild, water-based, oil-free soap and rinse thoroughly.
Dry the cup with a clean towel.

Insertion

Always wash your hands before inserting your cup.

You may also consider applying a water-based lube to the outside of the cup. This can reduce friction and make insertion easier. Make sure you check the manufacturer’s recommendations on the product packaging before using lube.

As a general rule, silicone- and oil-based lube may cause certain cups to degrade. Water and water-based lube may be safer alternatives.

When you’re ready to insert, you should:

Tightly fold the menstrual cup in half, holding it in one hand with the rim facing up.
Insert the cup, rim up, into your vagina like you would a tampon without an applicator. It should sit a few inches below your cervix.
Once the cup is in your vagina, rotate it. It will start to expand to create an airtight seal that stops leaks.
You may find that you have to twist it or reposition it slightly for your comfort, so adjust as needed.

Emptying

Depending on how heavy your flow is, you may be able to wear your cup for up to 12 hours.

You should always remove your cup by the 12-hour mark. This ensures regular cleaning and helps prevent a buildup of bacteria.

To remove and empty your cup:

Wash your hands with warm water and mild antibacterial soap.
Slide your index finger and thumb into your vagina.
Pinch the base of the menstrual cup and gently pull to remove it. If you pull on the stem, you could have a mess on your hands.
Once it’s out, empty the cup into the sink or toilet.
Rinse the cup under tap water, wash it thoroughly, and reinsert.
Wash your hands after you’re done.

After your period is over, sterilize your cup by putting it in boiling water for 5 to 10 minutes. This will help prevent contamination during storage.

Storage

You shouldn’t store your cup in an airtight container, because this won’t allow moisture to evaporate. Instead, any moisture present can linger and attract bacteria or fungi.

Most manufacturers recommend storing the cup in a cotton pouch or an open bag.

If you go to use your cup and find that it appears damaged or thin, has a foul-smelling odor, or is discolored, throw it out. Using the cup in this state may increase your risk of infection.

When to see a doctor or other healthcare professional

Although infection is highly unlikely, it is possible. See a healthcare professional if you begin experiencing:

unusual vaginal discharge
vaginal pain or soreness
burning during urination or intercourse
foul odor from the vagina

You should seek immediate medical attention if you experience:

a high fever
dizziness
vomiting
rash, which may resemble sunburn

Frequently asked questions

Can menstrual cups cause internal damage?

Generally speaking, menstrual cups don’t cause significant injury, pain, or discomfort. In a systematic review of 13 studies with an estimated 1,144 menstrual cup users, there were reports of only five users who experienced either severe pain or vaginal wounds.

Is it bad to wear a menstrual cup every day?

There aren’t a lot of long-term studies on wearing menstrual cups outside of your menstrual cycle. Some people may choose to wear them to try and reduce discharge.

Generally, if you follow the rules of safe menstrual cup wear, you should be able to safely wear one every day. If you have a significant amount of discharge, though, you may want to rule out an underlying medical condition, such as a yeast infection.

Are menstrual cups gynecologist-recommended?

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists lists menstrual cups as a menstrual management option but doesn’t endorse one method over another. Your decision to use a menstrual cup is your preference.

However, if you experience recurrent vaginal infections, you should talk with your doctor about if a menstrual cup is right for you.

The takeaway

When used correctly, menstrual cups can be a safe, cost- and environmentally-friendly alternative to other menstrual management methods. While using a menstrual cup may involve a learning curve, they offer benefits in comfort when properly inserted. With time and practice, you may find using a menstrual cup is your preferred option.

How we reviewed this article:

SourcesHistoryHealthline has strict sourcing guidelines and relies on peer-reviewed studies, academic research institutions, and medical journals and associations. We only use quality, credible sources to ensure content accuracy and integrity. You can learn more about how we ensure our content is accurate and current by reading our editorial policy.

Gharacheh M, et al. (2021). Acceptability and safety of the menstrual cups among Iranian women: a cross-sectional study.https://bmcwomenshealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12905-021-01259-8
Manley H, et al. (2021). Comparison between menstrual cups: first step to categorization and improved safety.https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/17455065211058553
Period products: Information about tampons, pads, and more. (2020). https://youngwomenshealth.org/2013/03/28/period-products/
Schnyer A, et al. (2019). Do menstrual cups increase risk of IUD expulsion? A survey of self-reported IUD and menstrual hygiene product use in the United States.https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13625187.2019.1643836
Seale R, et al. (2019). Unintentional IUD expulsion with concomitant menstrual cup use: a case series.https://www.contraceptionjournal.org/article/S0010-7824(19)30125-8/fulltext
The ins and outs of menstrual cups — how do they differ from tampons and pads? (2019).https://goaskalice.columbia.edu/answered-questions/ins-and-outs-menstrual-cups-how-do-they-differ-tampons-and-pads
van Eijk AM, et al. (2019). Menstrual cup use, leakage, acceptability, safety, and availability: A systematic review and meta-analysis.https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpub/article/PIIS2468-2667(19)30111-2/fulltext
Wiebe ER, et al. (2012). Does using tampons or menstrual cups increase early IUD expulsion rates?https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22464406/
Your changing body. (2022).https://www.acog.org/womens-health/faqs/your-changing-body-puberty-in-girls

Share this article