Video File Size Of H.264 Vs H.265 - Mavic Pilots

Menu

• Forums New posts Search forums
• New Featured content New posts New media New media comments New profile posts Latest activity
• Popular Most Replied Threads Most Liked Threads Most Viewed Threads Most Liked Posts
• Wiki Pages Latest activity
• Media New media New comments Search media
• Members Current visitors New profile posts Search profile posts

Log in Register What's new

Search

Everywhere Threads This forum This thread Search titles only By: Search Advanced search… Everywhere Threads This forum This thread Search titles only By: Search Advanced…

• New posts
• Search forums

Search

Everywhere Threads This forum This thread Search titles only By: Search Advanced search… Everywhere Threads This forum This thread Search titles only By: Search Advanced… Menu How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: this_feature_currently_requires_accessing_site_using_safari

DJI Mavic, Air and Mini Drones Friendly, Helpful & Knowledgeable Community Join Us Now

• Forums
• Mavic 2 Series
• Mavic 2

You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.You should upgrade or use an alternative browser. Video file size of H.264 vs H.265

• Thread starter Thread starter Robert Granata
• Start date Start date Oct 2, 2018

Robert Granata

Well-Known Member

Joined Dec 25, 2016 Messages 367 Reactions 381 Age 68 I don't pretend to know much of anything about codecs, but I read where H.265 compresses the files by about 30% more than H.264. When I look at the files right off of the sd card both the H.264 and H.265 files are approx. 3.67 gigs and about 4 minutes 50 seconds long. Shouldn't 3.67 gigs of H.265 give a longer video than 3.67 gigs of H.264 if it has better compression?

• 

Reactions: ksmusa and Former Member

Kilrah

Well-Known Member

Joined Nov 12, 2016 Messages 7,254 Reactions 4,310 Age 42 Location Switzerland 30% improvement means you can do 30% smaller file for same quality, or 30% better quality for same size (approximation obviously). It does the latter.

• 

Reactions: Roamer105, ksmusa and Former Member

Robert Granata

Well-Known Member

Joined Dec 25, 2016 Messages 367 Reactions 381 Age 68

Kilrah said: 30% improvement means you can do 30% smaller file for same quality, or 30% better quality for same size (approximation obviously). It does the latter. Click to expand...

I guess it's my untrained eye, but I don't see any difference in quality using normal color mode (only mode in both codecs) between H.264 and H.265. I would think a 30% increase in quality would be visually obvious.

• 

Reactions: Former Member

BD0G

Well-Known Member

Joined Oct 13, 2016 Messages 3,486 Reactions 3,152 Age 59 Location Near Lake Tahoe NV The codecs use compression algorithms that typically have to do alot more processing and compression on areas of the video that are not the same pixels (i.e. fast motion where all pixels are constantly changing) so I would scale up the H.265 and view an area of the video that has lots of motion and constantly changing pixels. Then do the same with the H.264 video and view the same or similar video clips. If you were just hovering or moving slowly the video will look nearly identical as there is no need to re-encode pixels that have not changed.

• 

Reactions: kilomikebravo and Former Member F

Fearless Flight

Well-Known Member

Joined Nov 6, 2016 Messages 175 Reactions 209 Age 59 What is everyone using?

Robert Granata

Well-Known Member

Joined Dec 25, 2016 Messages 367 Reactions 381 Age 68

BD0G said: The codecs use compression algorithms that typically have to do alot more processing and compression on areas of the video that are not the same pixels (i.e. fast motion where all pixels are constantly changing) so I would scale up the H.265 and view an area of the video that has lots of motion and constantly changing pixels. Then do the same with the H.264 video and view the same or similar video clips. If you were just hovering or moving slowly the video will look nearly identical as there is no need to re-encode pixels that have not changed. Click to expand...

I have no doubt that you're right, but I just tried it by flying rapidly past the same tree 90 degrees to my course (so I'm looking sideways in the direction of the tree) using both codecs and zooming the original 4k to 1080. My 61 year old eyes can't make out any difference. Should the leaves be clearer and more defined in the H.265? Because, to me, they look just as smeared in both.

BD0G

Well-Known Member

Joined Oct 13, 2016 Messages 3,486 Reactions 3,152 Age 59 Location Near Lake Tahoe NV Good Question! I dont have a good answer. Since the file sizes are smaller using the H.265 codec then there is information that is not being included in the file that H.264 encoding would include. OR the information is being captured , but the codec does a more efficient job at understanding what to discard and not affect the video clarity and definition. "Conceived to boost video streaming, High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC), or H.265, is a video compression standard designed to substantially improve coding efficiency when compared to its precedent, the Advanced Video Coding (AVC), orH.264.Jun 8, 2016 "

Robert Granata

Well-Known Member

Joined Dec 25, 2016 Messages 367 Reactions 381 Age 68

BD0G said: Good Question! I dont have a good answer. Since the file sizes are smaller using the H.265 codec then there is information that is not being included in the file that H.264 encoding would include. OR the information is being captured , but the codec does a more efficient job at understanding what to discard and not affect the video clarity and definition. "Conceived to boost video streaming, High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC), or H.265, is a video compression standard designed to substantially improve coding efficiency when compared to its precedent, the Advanced Video Coding (AVC), orH.264.Jun 8, 2016 " Click to expand...

That's what I don't understand. How could it boost video streaming when the files are (basically) the exact the same size?

• 

Reactions: digiteye

SteelFlyer

Well-Known Member

Joined Jan 17, 2017 Messages 339 Reactions 205 Age 62 Comparing codecs is tricky business because it depends a lot on what is being filmed, how uniform it is, how much motion, etc.. You will tend to see a greater difference when the image is very complicated and there is a good deal of motion. Static shots or ones with very uniform objects will show much less difference. There are some very good YouTube videos showing differences in H.264 and HEVC (H.265) encoding. Toggle signature Certified Part 107 Pilot Charlotte, NC

Robert Granata

Well-Known Member

Joined Dec 25, 2016 Messages 367 Reactions 381 Age 68

SteelFlyer said: Comparing codecs is tricky business because it depends a lot on what is being filmed, how uniform it is, how much motion, etc.. You will tend to see a greater difference when the image is very complicated and there is a good deal of motion. Static shots or ones with very uniform objects will show much less difference. There are some very good YouTube videos showing differences in H.264 and HEVC (H.265) encoding. Click to expand...

I did the tree with lots of leaves flyby to test just that. I can't see any difference in quality or clarity between the H.264 and H.265. Does anyone see a difference in quality between the two codecs, in Normal mode, on the Mavic 2 series? Can you look at a video recorded in Normal on the Mavic 2 and say "Oh, that's definitely H.265, because look at the..."?

Roamer105

Well-Known Member

Joined Dec 24, 2016 Messages 461 Reactions 321 Location Dammeron Valley, UT 84783

Robert Granata said: I guess it's my untrained eye, but I don't see any difference in quality using normal color mode (only mode in both codecs) between H.264 and H.265. I would think a 30% increase in quality would be visually obvious. Click to expand...

Got it right: untrained eye. You can see a difference in certain very challenging (for the encoder) situations. But for the most part they are subtle enough. Don’t forget that if you encode in 10-bits... the 30% improvement is consumed by that already. Toggle signature Air 2S + SC Pro + Flat Shark HDO2 Sold: Air2s, MR500, M2P, RE Goggles, MP and P3P

• 

Reactions: kilomikebravo P

Pisushax

New Member

Joined Jan 18, 2021 Messages 1 Reactions 0 Age 30 Location Tabriz You know where is the problem where you cant find the difference.?? Bitrates Since your camera set to a constant amount of bitrate no matter what codec it uses the final file size are the same and becouse the bitrate is so high there is no visual difference between h264 and h265 In your case your camera set to record at about 100mbps which yields about 3.67 gigabyte of files in 290 seconds so basically your video is rarly compresed What a codec does is compressing a video when it has plenty of room to do what ever it wants there will be no compression so no difference between them if you want to see real difference lower bitrate to about 10mbps so your files would be about 400 megabytes then you will definitely see visual difference between h265 and h264 assuming you are recoding in 4k S

SCAMBO-1

New Member

Joined Apr 27, 2019 Messages 2 Reactions 0 Lots of video editing software companies are avoiding supporting h.265 due to the excessive licensing fee being charged for the privilege of being able to build it into their software, sad situation for sure as h.265 is quite good in my experience

vjpapa

Active Member

Joined Jan 14, 2021 Messages 40 Reactions 57 Location San Antonio, Texas

PSNR(peak signal-to-noise ratio) in some captures can be larger in H.264, thus producing a slightly more detailed image. So it appears that H.265 will out perform H.264 in most captures but not always. ​

Post reply

Similar threads

L h.264 vs h.265... CHOPPY VIDEO

• Luckyguy9
• Oct 26, 2023
• Mini 4 Pro
2

Replies 35 Views 8K Mini 4 Pro Apr 4, 2024 mobilehomer TriplTek 8 Pro - Poor video performance

• DmitryGlinka
• Jun 2, 2023
• General Discussions
2

Replies 29 Views 3K General Discussions Mar 13, 2024 masterangler B H.264 versus H.265 mini 3 pro

• bersecti
• Feb 14, 2023
• General Discussions
2 3

Replies 42 Views 8K General Discussions Mar 16, 2023 aerovikings A Shooting, Editing, and Producing in H.264 or H.265 Codec?

• Wavepilot Aerial
• Apr 30, 2022
• Editing & Techniques

Replies 8 Views 6K Editing & Techniques Jul 6, 2022 chris-bin C DVR and the Dlog colour glitches

• AeroJ
• Jun 9, 2024
• Editing & Techniques

Replies 10 Views 1K Editing & Techniques Jul 2, 2024 AeroJ Share: LinkedIn

DJI Drone Deals

1. NEO 2. Mini 4k 3. Mini 4 Pro 4. Air 3 5. Avata 2 6. Mavic 3 Pro 7. Mavic 3 Classic

New Threads

• Drone Search for Dog Help - San Diego Area
  • Started by boomtown2024
  • Today at 9:44 PM
  • Replies: 0
  San Diego Area
• Looking for Help with Search for a Lost Pup with a Drone (Carmel Valley San Diego)
  • Started by boomtown2024
  • Today at 9:15 PM
  • Replies: 3
  Pilot Check In
• Mini 4 Pro Camera won’t point down when landing
  • Started by Buzzed
  • Today at 6:03 PM
  • Replies: 1
  General Discussions
• Air 3sDolphin Megapod
  • Started by downeym
  • Today at 5:30 PM
  • Replies: 3
  Photo and Video Showcase
• Looking for an RPA forum that's all encompassing
  • Started by DarR-T
  • Today at 5:20 PM
  • Replies: 0
  General Discussions

Members online

• TerryOregon
• CadrePilot
• noosa2010
• AlanL
• TonyPHX
• Hercsta79
• Bad Santa
• Ghost27
• Recoveryone
• timinator
• Richard R

Total: 450 (members: 12, guests: 438)

Forum statistics

Threads 135,140 Messages 1,602,909 Members 163,630 Latest member Ghost27

• Forums
• Mavic 2 Series
• Mavic 2

• We value your privacy

  We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.

  See further information and configure your preferences

  Accept all cookies Reject optional cookies
  • Essential cookies
  These cookies are required to enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. You may not reject these.
  • Optional cookies
  We deliver enhanced functionality for your browsing experience by setting these cookies. If you reject them, enhanced functionality will be unavailable.
  • Third-party cookies
  Cookies set by third parties may be required to power functionality in conjunction with various service providers for security, analytics, performance or advertising purposes.
  • Detailed cookie usage
  • Privacy policy
  Save cookie preferences

Want to Remove this Ad? Simply login or create a free account