Why Can The Acidic Strength Between H2S And HCl Be Explained On ...

Sorry, we no longer support your browser Please upgrade to Microsoft Edge, Google Chrome, or Firefox. Learn more about our browser support.

1. 1. Home
   2. Questions
   3. Tags
   4. Users
   5. Unanswered
2. Teams

   Ask questions, find answers and collaborate at work with Stack Overflow for Teams.

   Try Teams for free Explore Teams
3. Teams

4. Ask questions, find answers and collaborate at work with Stack Overflow for Teams. Explore Teams

Teams

Q&A for work

Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search.

Learn more about Teams Why can the acidic strength between H2S and HCl be explained on the basis of electronegativity but H2S and H2O can't? Ask Question Asked 5 years, 10 months ago Modified 2 years, 6 months ago Viewed 5k times 12 $\begingroup$

Consider simply aqueous solutions of $\ce{H2S}$ and $\ce{HCl}$ . It is pretty much known that $\ce{HCl}$ is stronger than $\ce{H2S}$ in water. The reason behind that first is the electronegativity of $\ce{Cl}$ is higher than $\ce{S}$, so, in a polar medium, it becomes easier for the $\ce{H-Cl}$ bond to break than the other one. More ever , $\ce{Cl^-}$ ion being smaller in size is extensively hydrated in water than $\ce{HS^-}$ ion, which also favours in the increased acidity of $\ce{HCl}$.

But now consider acidity of $\ce{H2S}$ and $\ce{H2O}$ in water. If we apply the similar reasons as before, we will ultimately conclude water is a stronger acid than $\ce{H2S}$. But actually it’s the reverse. The only fact supporting the actual phenomenon is the weaker bond energy of $\ce{H-S}$, but if we apply this to the earlier case of $\ce{HCl}$ and $\ce{H2S}$, it will again contradict the actual phenomenon.

Why is this the case ? If my reasoning is incorrect, what is the actual reasoning that will support the correct acidity in both the cases ?

• acid-base

Share Cite Improve this question Follow edited Jan 6, 2019 at 10:33 orthocresol 71.9k1212 gold badges249249 silver badges423423 bronze badges asked Jan 5, 2019 at 17:08 Soumik DasSoumik Das 5,72811 gold badge1616 silver badges3333 bronze badges $\endgroup$ 1

• $\begingroup$ You could make a similar argument for comparison between the 'HX's (X = halogens). $\endgroup$ – Eashaan Godbole Commented Jan 8, 2019 at 18:42

Add a comment |

3 Answers 3

Sorted by: Reset to default Highest score (default) Date modified (newest first) Date created (oldest first) 10 $\begingroup$

You are right that electronegativity is an important consideration but another factor that is also very important is size of the atom. Although there is a decrease in electronegativity from $\ce {O}$ to $\ce {S}$, the size of the atom which the charge is mainly centred on is now larger. This allows the charge to be distributed over a larger volume of space, decreasing inter-electronic repulsions, providing greater stabilisation of the negative charge.

However, the greater size decreases charge density, decreasing the strength of ion-dipole interactions between the anion and the surrounding water molecules. Thus, the extent of solvation decreases for the larger anion.

Electronegativity is defined as the ability of the atom to attract a bonding pair of electrons. It merely serves as a proxy for the ability of the atom to stabilise negative charge. It should not be viewed as the most important factor that influences the atom's ability to stabilise negative charge.

Also, mentioned in your answer, the strength of the bond formed with the larger atom with more diffuse orbitals decreases. A bond that is more easily cleaved would facilitate bond cleavage and thus, favour the acid with the larger atom bonded to $\ce {H}$ as the stronger acid.

Consolidating the above discussion, there are really two factors on each side of the table below. Perhaps, the distribution of charge increases very significantly and the bond energy also decreases significantly while the decrease in extent of solvation and the electronegativity exhibit a relatively less significant effect. It would be great if someone is able to quantitatively show this...

\begin{array}{|c|c|c|c|} \hline \text{Favouring acids with larger atom} & \text{Favouring acids with smaller atom} \\ \hline \ce{Distribution of charge} & \ce{Extent of solvation}\\ \hline \ce{Bond strength} & \ce{Electronegativity}\\ \hline \end{array}

Share Cite Improve this answer Follow answered Jan 6, 2019 at 1:37 Tan Yong BoonTan Yong Boon 10.7k66 gold badges4545 silver badges109109 bronze badges $\endgroup$ 2

• $\begingroup$ But you just restated my arguments only. You didn't proceed much towards the actual logic (if any) supporting both the cases . I don't see much new things in your answer. $\endgroup$ – Soumik Das Commented Jan 7, 2019 at 3:21
• $\begingroup$ I have presented an additional important factor to consider - the greater extent of charge dispersal in conjugate bases with larger atoms having more diffuse orbitals. I have also presented clearly a framework for analysis of the acidity phenomena. I agree that my answer does not provide the most convincing answer to your question but it has provided a comprehensive framework (i.e. the consolidation of the 4 factors) on which we can work on. $\endgroup$ – Tan Yong Boon Commented Jan 7, 2019 at 8:33

Add a comment | 4 $\begingroup$

It is not just electronegativity. You also have to look at how strongly the atom bonds to hydrogen. If a strong bond forms, it might convince the atom to act as a base even if it would be grumpy based on its electronegativity. If only a weak bond forms, even an atom with relatively low electronegativity might balk at being protonated.

As a rule, hydrogen forms stronger bonds with itself and with nonmetals in the second row ($\ce{C}$ through $\ce{F}$) than with just about anything else. It's due to favorable covalent overlap; take account of orbital sizes and nodes. Respecting this difference, treat $\ce{H,C,N,O,F}$ as one group and heavier nonmetals as another, and just compare electronegativities within each "class".

Share Cite Improve this answer Follow answered Jan 5, 2019 at 23:39 Oscar LanziOscar Lanzi 62.4k44 gold badges9696 silver badges186186 bronze badges $\endgroup$ Add a comment | 0 $\begingroup$

Acidity/ Basicity is a bulk property - it also depends on the medium where a substance acts as an acid or a base. For example, ammonia, a weak base in aqueous medium, can be a rather strong base in another medium.

Similarly, pure 100% dry $\ce{H2S}$ is theoretically a stronger acid than perfectly dry gaseous $\ce{HCl}$ due to a smaller bond dissociation energy and weaker dipole interaction. But, when it comes to aqueous medium, many factors are taken into account to decide the strength of acidity. To behave as a stronger acid, constituent ions need to be hydrated very well to facilitate the dissociation of $\ce{H+}$ ion or proton.

In case of $\ce{H2S}$, it is not so polar, (electronegativity difference between $\ce{H}$ and $\ce{S}$ is only about $0.4$ just like the case of $\ce{CH4}$), it doesn't dissolve very well in water. Also the dissolved $\ce{H2S}$ feebly dissociates to give proton or $\ce{H+}$ ion since the $\ce{HS-}$ is not well hydrated due to its bigger size. On the other hand, $\ce{HCl}$ dissolves (due to a bigger electronegativity difference, about 1.4) and is solvated very well, since $\ce{Cl-}$ ion is smaller in size when compared to $\ce{HS-}$ or $\ce{S^2-}$.

Hence, $\ce{HCl}$ is a stronger acid than $\ce{H2S}$ due to the environment in which it is present and also note that the electronegativity difference plays a minor role here.

Share Cite Improve this answer Follow edited May 13, 2022 at 14:34 answered Jun 19, 2021 at 5:48 SudhagarSudhagar 14166 bronze badges $\endgroup$ 2

• 1 $\begingroup$ +1 I've seen your contributions and they look good to me. Just a few tips in writing an answer. 1, Use paragraphs, it makes the whole thing look a lot neater. Two new lines breaks the word wall into paragraphs. 2. Use $\ce{}$ when formatting chemical compounds. It makes them look a lot prettier. $\endgroup$ – Safdar Faisal Commented Jun 19, 2021 at 12:13
• $\begingroup$ Why is solubility a factor in pKas...? The equation for Ka only involves aqueous species, i.e. molecules that have already dissolved. The question of solubility is quite separate. The case of $\ce{H2CO3}$, or $\ce{CO2}$, is similar: the "pKa of $\ce{H2CO3}$" already assumes that the molecule is formed from $\ce{CO2 + H2O}$, and it's only the "pKa of $\ce{CO2(aq)}$" where solubility / reactivity comes into play. The common confusion in this case only arises because $\ce{H2CO3}$ basically doesn't exist; but such arguments cannot be applied to $\ce{H2S}$. $\endgroup$ – orthocresol Commented Jun 19, 2021 at 14:48

Add a comment | Highly active question. Earn 10 reputation (not counting the association bonus) in order to answer this question. The reputation requirement helps protect this question from spam and non-answer activity.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged

• acid-base

or ask your own question.

• Featured on Meta
• More network sites to see advertising test
• We’re (finally!) going to the cloud!
• Advertising Test Beginning Nov 13 2024

Linked

-2 Why is HCl a stronger acid than H2S on the basis of electronegativity, but HF is a weaker acid than HCl?

Related

2 Lewis base strength and the hydrogen proton 6 Stability of Sulfides - backbonding? 0 link between acidity and [H3O+] 3 Reversibility of an acid's reaction with water depending on its strength 1 Why do we use different arguments for determining the strength of hydracids and solubility of ionic compounds? 3 Is there also a leveling effect for weak acids in water? 3 Is there a notion of generalized acidity for lithium ions? 4 Why is hydrated beryllium ion acidic? 4 Acidity of H4P2O7 and H3PO4

Hot Network Questions

• Is every automorphism of a cone diagonalisable?
• Group action on affine variety induces faithful action on tangent space
• Do referees get to see each other's reports?
• Did renaissance actors learn their parts by heart?
• Uk exhibition pass query impact
• Can a storage device completely erase itself while performing the erase?
• What is a second oversize Hi-Lok fastener?
• Is there a theorem in metaphysics that basically says, "Biting the bullet will be inevitable in any metaphysical theory?"
• Missile Impact Velocity
• Advantages of information criteria over cross-validation
• Quantitative definition of information without set cardinality or probability?
• Moments of a random variable related to uniform distribution on sphere
• Selecting point demanding on distance and date with QGIS Expression
• Why does my laundry supply hose extension coupler leak?
• Is it possible to get bitcoin address from Jan 2010 that still has balance and never send out transactions?
• Where in the Gospels does Jesus explain what 'The Truth' is?
• How do different observers decide if they are looking at the same thing?
• What is the ontological difference between platonism and non platonism?
• How to avoid wasting reader investment with a thematically disappointing ending?
• Is there an elegant general method for solving linear multiplicative system of equations in modulo 2? Here is an interesting example problem.
• Why「记」for shop names?
• What is the Calvinist/Reformed solution to the Problem of Hell?
• Short story about a man living In an apartment who's curious about his neighbor who turns out to be a monster or demon
• Brushing pastries with jam

more hot questions Question feed Subscribe to RSS Question feed

To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader.