Frankenstein In Stitches

skip to main | skip to sidebar

January 31, 2012

Frankenstein in Stitches

Several comments posted here, on Facebook and points between have noted how Primo Carnera’s Frankenstein makeup from 1957, revealed here last week, was very similar to that worn by Robert De Niro in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein of 1994.

True enough. Bald and stitched cranium, sutured cheeks, upper lip and chin, and a damaged left eye. Very similar indeed, but Primo and Bobby were neither the first nor last of their monstrous kind.

Lon Chaney’s Monster for TV’s Tales of Tomorrow in 1952 heralded Carnera’s version with a baldhead and face-splitting stitch work. Springing 60 years ahead, the effect was revisited and worn by Jonny Lee Miller and Benedict Cumberbatch, sharing the part, in the celebrated British National Theater version of 2011. Call it same-school monster makeup.

Somewhat related, without facial distress, chrome-dome Monsters are known to sport ‘round the head, dotted line stitching indicating radical brain surgery. The two finest examples are — going from the ridiculous to the sublime — Cal Bolder in Jesse James Meets Frankenstein’s Daughter (1966) and Freddie Jones’s heart wrenching Creature in Frankenstein Must Be Destroyed (1969).

These Frankenstein Monsters are of a family. When opting for a baldhead look, similarities are perhaps inevitable. There are only so many ways to stitch a baseball.

Related:Exclusive! The Monster: Primo CarneraExclusive! 1957 Frankenstein Makeup Session
Revealed!TV’s Lost Frankenstein of 1957Tales of Tomorrow: Frankenstein’s Notorious TV Adventure.

• 22:00  

Labels: • Frankenstein (Matinee Theater) 1957, • Frankenstein (National Theatre 2011), • Frankenstein (Tales of Tomorrow, • Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (1994)

24 comments:

Emmy said...

I'm going to have to check out some of these movies :) I don't exactly have an abundance of time to watch them right now, but I'm going to try anyway :)

February 1, 2012 at 12:30 AM David L Rattigan said...

I'd say the Carnera/De Niro similarities are more than coincidental. Diagonal right-left stitch across pate, arched stitch across eye, right eye to right ear stitch diagonal stitch across left cheek, left nostril to mid-lip stitch, lip to chin stitch, open left eye, weak/semi-shut right eye. I'm guessing the latter was more than inspired by the former.

February 1, 2012 at 5:38 AM Will Errickson said...

Ugh, the less I'm reminded of Branagh's wretched version the better.

February 1, 2012 at 9:15 AM David Lee Ingersoll said...

Despite the very obvious similarities between Carnera and De Niro's make-up designs, I'm guessing that it's just one of those amazing coincidences. If the Carnera make-up design was "lost" since 1957 it's unlikely that the De Niro make-up was based on it. I've drawn a lot of Frankenstein monsters. Part of the fun is putting crude stitches on the poor wretch. The cruder and more random they are, the better the design. But, as humans, we try for balance in our designs as well, so if a lot of stitches end up around the eye we add stitches to some other part of the face. Wanting to avoid too much obvious symmetry the stitches end up higher or lower on the opposite side of the face. (Hopefully that made sense.)There are only so many places (that make sense) to put stitches so, sooner or later, similar designs were/are inevitable. Of course, it's also possible that the make-up team somehow saw a photo of the 1957 Canera design and thought, "Hey, this version is lost! Let's bring it back!"

February 1, 2012 at 9:51 AM Anonymous said...

Were all the stills from the Canera version lost or just not well publicized? I believe Rick Baker did the De Niro makeup and he's quite knowledhable about such things (were there any photos in one of Don Glut's books?).

February 1, 2012 at 11:22 AM wich2 said...

The crazy-quilt stitches might fit an artist's design sensibility... but unless Victor had real hand coordination issues, most random ones don't make a lick of sense surgicially!-Craig

February 1, 2012 at 12:18 PM Pierre Fournier said...

Anon: Baker had nothing to do with the Branagh Frankenstein (Baker won the oscar for ED WOOD that year). The only photo of Carnera’s Monster in circulation for all these years was a small and very blurry thumbnail. The photos revealed here were found thanks to the relentless research of collector and film historian George Chastain. Of course, the film people might have had a copy of these UPI photos but, still, I believe we are looking at coincidental resemblances. I remember extensive coverage of the film in Fangoria and how the makeup people said they were going for a patchwork look. The Carnera face has random stitching, the De Niro version is meant to show whole chunks stitched together: The right cheek, right chin and half the mouth are one piece “dropped in” (note pale skin). The left eye and cheekbone is another chunk popped in, note the circular scar around it. Arms and legs were also of different mismatched sizes and color. Craig: The Karloff/Pierce Monster with its flat, fliptop lid made no sense either. Brain transplants, as once unfortunately performed on monkeys, were done through the back of the head, the whole thing inserted drawer-like, with access to the spinal chord. Mary’s Monster, of course, bore no resemblance whatsoever to any of these. Shelley describes tight skin exposing muscles and arteries beneath, and compares The Monster to a mummy, with its thin, parchment skin. The words “stitch” and “scar” do not appear in the book.

February 1, 2012 at 3:18 PM Anonymous said...

Thanks, I stand corrected. MARY SHELLEY'S FRANKENSTEIN was nominated for the Best Makeup Oscar(Daniel Parker, Paul Engelen and Carol Hemming)as well.

February 1, 2012 at 5:28 PM egorschamber said...

Suddenly realizing that Benedict Cumberbatch is the same brilliant actor who's currently playing the BBC SHERLOCK made me wonder who else has performed that unlikely pair of characters over the years. Christopher Lee, of course (Sherlock AND Mycroft!) -- but who else?A stretch, but Boris Karloff *might* qualify for his retired beekeeper sleuth "Mr. Mycroft" in "Sting of Death" on TV's ELGIN HOUR in 1955, based on Gerald Heard's Holmes pastiche A TASTE FOR HONEY.A close-but-no-cigar candidate: Raymond Massey, whose monstrous, stitched-together Jonathan Brewster persona is based on a movie performance by Boris Karloff.Anybody else who did it more legitimately?

February 1, 2012 at 10:25 PM David Lee Ingersoll said...

Peter Cushing played Frankenstein and both Sherlock and Mycroft. His Frankenstein was more of a monster than most of his creations.

February 2, 2012 at 3:30 PM Anonymous said...

If you really think about it, the Frankenstein Monster lost his hair over the course of his legacy. In the original novel he had long hair. In the '31 film, his hair got shorter. In that film's sequel, it was even shorter thanks to his burns. In "Young Frankenstein" he was balding on top. Now he's usually always completely bald.

February 2, 2012 at 3:32 PM Pierre Fournier said...

Cushing and Rathbone were Frankensteins and Sherlocks. And John Cleese was Dr. Waldman.

February 2, 2012 at 4:33 PM egorschamber said...

This line of connections is interesting and valid too, but I was talking about actors who've played both Frankenstein's MONSTER and Sherlock. I should've been more specific. Cushing *might* still qualify -- isn't there at least one place in the Hammer series in which the doctor himself is brought back to life by his own lab techniques... in REVENGE, perhaps?

February 2, 2012 at 6:05 PM Pierre Fournier said...

Absolutely understood, George. I was expanding on the idea and noting Sherlock actors in Frankenstein films. And by the way, lots of Sherlocks involved in DRACULA, too!Yes, Cushing is rebuilt, so to speak, in REVENGE. He's also defrosted in FRANKENSTEIN CREATED WOMAN.

February 2, 2012 at 6:11 PM David Lee Ingersoll said...

@Egorschamber I did realize you were asking which actors played both the monster and Sherlock. I mentioned Cushing because his long run as Dr. Frankenstein is unique. In Frankenstein Created Woman he's revived after being frozen for an hour. The only other film in the series that I've seen is Curse, the first one, so I don't know if there's one in which he's actually brought back from the dead.

February 2, 2012 at 6:23 PM egorschamber said...

Didn't mean to be snarky, and hope I didn't seem so. I agree absolutely that Hammer's (and Peter Cushing's) Dr. Frankenstein was usually much more monstrous than his lab creations.I webfooted around a little bit hoping to find instances of old time radio actors or cartoon voice artists who spoke for both the Monster and Sherlock, even fleetingly. No luck so far but I'd bet the farm that at least one or two of those specialists did.

February 2, 2012 at 10:45 PM Anonymous said...

Re the Monster's hair. The 2004 Luke Goss version is pretty close to Shelley, long hair and all. The 1995 children's show WISHBONE had an short adpatation of the book. The Monster starts out bald but grows long hair as the story progresses.

February 3, 2012 at 8:42 AM David Lee Ingersoll said...

There's also a long haired Monster in Frankenstein vs. The Creature from Blood Cove.

February 3, 2012 at 9:17 AM Anonymous said...

More long hair: Charles Ogle (see above post)TORTICOLA CONTRE FRANKENKSBERG (1952)and a number of 70s creations like Bo Svenson and Michael Sarrazin.

February 3, 2012 at 12:50 PM Pierre Fournier said...

Hair? THIS is hair: http://frankensteinia.blogspot.com/2010/01/frankenstein-italian-style.html

February 3, 2012 at 1:27 PM wich2 said...

>...hoping to find instances of old time radio actors or cartoon voice artists who spoke for both the Monster and Sherlock ... I'd bet the farm that at least one or two of those specialists did<I honestly don't know anyone in the Classic Network Radio Era who pulled that double, egor - but would you consider a Modern Audio Drama actor (who's worked a great deal with the Vets)?:http://www.prx.org/accounts/45521-wich2/pieces-Craig

February 5, 2012 at 11:28 AM -jjmm- said...

http://www.flickr.com/photos/derricksphotos/265717993/

July 31, 2012 at 11:48 PM Taylor Aufderhar said...

I started using Dermalmd Scar Removal two months post thyroidectomy. I’ve been using it twice a day most days since. I’m now six months out (using the cream for about 4 months) and my scar has really improved! It is very flat, faded in color and very soft. I’ve noticed a significant difference in texture and appearance. You only need a tiny bit each time, I still have most of the container still. Really recommend.

August 16, 2022 at 3:30 AM 3dbet said...

3dbet thailand เว็บตรง มุ่งมั่นในการให้บริการที่มีคุณภาพและปลอดภัย pg ด้วยระบบที่มีความมั่นคงสูง การเข้ารหัสข้อมูลที่มั่นคง และระบบฝาก-ถอนที่สะดวกสบายด้วยทีมสนับสนุนที่พร้อมให้ความช่วยเหลือและแก้ไขปัญหา

March 4, 2024 at 5:30 AM

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Visit our Companion Blog!

Blog Archive

Blog Archive December 2019 (1) January 2018 (1) October 2017 (1) March 2017 (1) December 2016 (1) November 2016 (1) October 2016 (1) June 2016 (2) April 2016 (1) December 2015 (1) November 2015 (4) October 2015 (8) September 2015 (2) August 2015 (5) July 2015 (1) May 2015 (3) April 2015 (1) March 2015 (2) February 2015 (1) January 2015 (1) December 2014 (4) November 2014 (8) October 2014 (3) September 2014 (4) August 2014 (5) July 2014 (2) June 2014 (4) May 2014 (4) April 2014 (5) March 2014 (5) February 2014 (4) January 2014 (2) December 2013 (1) November 2013 (2) October 2013 (9) September 2013 (5) August 2013 (7) July 2013 (6) June 2013 (7) May 2013 (9) April 2013 (6) March 2013 (7) February 2013 (4) January 2013 (4) December 2012 (8) November 2012 (9) October 2012 (9) September 2012 (6) August 2012 (8) July 2012 (8) June 2012 (4) May 2012 (11) April 2012 (8) March 2012 (12) February 2012 (9) January 2012 (13) December 2011 (9) November 2011 (10) October 2011 (15) September 2011 (8) August 2011 (10) July 2011 (9) June 2011 (9) May 2011 (12) April 2011 (10) March 2011 (13) February 2011 (9) January 2011 (6) December 2010 (19) November 2010 (10) October 2010 (16) September 2010 (9) August 2010 (13) July 2010 (7) June 2010 (6) May 2010 (10) April 2010 (16) March 2010 (14) February 2010 (10) January 2010 (7) December 2009 (8) November 2009 (15) October 2009 (14) September 2009 (9) August 2009 (9) July 2009 (10) June 2009 (12) May 2009 (10) April 2009 (15) March 2009 (20) February 2009 (13) January 2009 (12) December 2008 (10) November 2008 (13) October 2008 (16) September 2008 (20) August 2008 (18) July 2008 (14) June 2008 (9) May 2008 (12) April 2008 (12) March 2008 (14) February 2008 (16) January 2008 (18) December 2007 (16) November 2007 (17) October 2007 (24) September 2007 (24) August 2007 (18)

Labels: Films

• CARRY ON SCREAMING (1966) (3)
• DOUBLE DOOR (1934) (1)
• FRANKENSTEIN CANNOT BE STOPPED (2014) (1)
• FRANKENSTEIN MD (2014) (1)
• FRANKENSTEIN TRESTLE. THE (1899) (1)
• FRANKENSTEIN'S AUNT (1987) (1)
• FRANKENWEENIE (2012) (2)
• HOLLYWOOD CAPERS (1935) (1)
• I WAS A TEENAGE MONSTER (THE MONKEES) (1)
• MYSTERY OF THE HAUNTED HOUSE (THE HARDY BOYS/NANCY DREW MYSTERIES) (1)
• Penny Dreadful (2014) (4)
• SHERLOCK HOLMES VS FRANKENSTEIN (2)
• THE GREAT PIGGY BANK ROBBERY (1946) (1)
• THE SKELETON IN THE CUPBOARD SAVE (1943) (1)
• VICTOR FRANKENSTEIN (2015) (1)
• • Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein (1948) (11)
• • After Frankenstein (2010) (1)
• • Assignment Terror (1970) (1)
• • Blue skies (1946) (2)
• • Bride of Frankenstein (1935) (81)
• • CGI Frankenstein (1998) (2)
• • Death Race 2000 (1975) (1)
• • Dracula vs. Frankenstein (1971) (1)
• • El Aullido del diablo (1988) (1)
• • El castillo de los monstruos (1958) (2)
• • Fanny Hill Meets Dr. Erotico (1967) (1)
• • Flesh for Frankenstein (1973) (1)
• • Frankenhood (2009) (1)
• • Frankenstein (1910) (15)
• • Frankenstein (1931) (90)
• • Frankenstein (2004) (1)
• • Frankenstein (ITV 2007) (1)
• • Frankenstein (Matinee Theater) 1957 (4)
• • Frankenstein (Mystery and Imagination (2)
• • Frankenstein (National Theatre 2011) (2)
• • Frankenstein (Tales of Tomorrow (2)
• • Frankenstein 1970 (1958) (6)
• • Frankenstein Conquers The World (1965) (4)
• • Frankenstein Created Woman (1967) (1)
• • Frankenstein Meets The Wolf Man (1943) (15)
• • Frankenstein Rising (2008) (1)
• • Frankenstein Unlimited (2009) (2)
• • Frankenstein all'italiano (1975) (1)
• • Frankenstein and the Monster from Hell (1974) (5)
• • Frankenstein's Army (2012) (2)
• • Frankenstein's Bloody Terror (1968) (1)
• • Frankenstein's Cat (1942) (1)
• • Frankenstein's Daughter (1958) (4)
• • Frankenstein's Wedding (2011) (3)
• • Frankenstein: The True Story (1973) (2)
• • G Man Jitters (1939) (1)
• • Gods and Monsters (1998) (1)
• • Gothic (1986) (1)
• • Gruesomestein's Monsters (2005) (1)
• • Haram alek (1953) (3)
• • Hellzapoppin' (1941) (1)
• • Homunculus (1916) (2)
• • House of Dracula (1945) (7)
• • House of Frankenstein (1944) (4)
• • House of the Wolf Man (2009) (2)
• • How To Make a Monster (1958) (2)
• • I Frankenstein (1)
• • I Was a Teenage Frankenstein (1957) (5)
• • Igor (2008) (2)
• • Il Mostro di Frankenstein (1920) (5)
• • La Figlia di Frankenstein (1971) (3)
• • Life Without Soul (1915) (5)
• • Los Monstruos del Terror (1969) (1)
• • Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (1994) (1)
• • Mickey's Gala Premiere (1933) (1)
• • Mistress Frankenstein (2000) (1)
• • Monster Brawl (2011) (2)
• • Porky's Movie Mystery (1939) (1)
• • Route 66: Lizard's Leg and Owlet's Wing (1962) (1)
• • Runaway Brain (1995) (3)
• • Santo vs la hija de Frankestein (1971) (1)
• • Sevimli Frankenstayn (1975) (1)
• • Son of Frankenstein (1939) (27)
• • Splice (2010) (1)
• • Tales of Frankenstein (1958) (3)
• • Tender Son - The Frankenstein Project (2010) (1)
• • Terror of Frankenstein (see Victor Frankenstein) (1)
• • The Bride (1985) (1)
• • The Curse of Frankenstein (1957) (21)
• • The Evil of Frankenstein (1964) (1)
• • The Frankenstein Theory (2013) (1)
• • The Ghost of Frankenstein (1942) (5)
• • The Halloween That Almost Wasn't (1979) (1)
• • The Horror of Frankenstein (1970) (3)
• • The Incredible Hulk (1)
• • The Man Who Saw Frankenstein Cry (2010) (1)
• • The Monster Squad (1987) (2)
• • The Revenge of Frankenstein (1958) (7)
• • The Vindicator (1986) (1)
• • The Walking Dead (1936) (2)
• • Third Dimensional Murder (1941) (2)
• • Thursday's Child (1943) (2)
• • Vampire Girl vs. Frankenstein Girl (2009) (4)
• • Van Helsing (2004) (1)
• • Victor Frankenstein (1977) (1)
• • Young Frankenstein (1974) (4)

Labels: General

• Advertising (15)
• Animation (21)
• Arsenic and Old Lace (1)
• Art and Illustration (260)
• Audio (3)
• Awards (23)
• BORIS KARLOFF BLOGATHON (12)
• Bela Lugosi (9)
• Blog-a-Thon (25)
• Books (60)
• Boris Karloff (51)
• Christopher Lee (9)
• Comics (63)
• Covers (103)
• Dick Briefer (9)
• Don Post (11)
• Dr. Moreau (2)
• Fantasia (9)
• Feg Murray (12)
• Fiction (5)
• Frankensteinian (14)
• Glenn Strange (9)
• Golem (4)
• Guest Blogger (13)
• Hammer Films (17)
• History (12)
• Illustration (9)
• Jack Pierce (12)
• James Whale (11)
• Lon Chaney Jr. (6)
• Mary Shelley (43)
• Memorabilia (10)
• Music (10)
• Musicals (8)
• On This Day (48)
• Peter Cushing (22)
• Peter Cushing Blogathon (8)
• Places (13)
• Pop Culture (108)
• Posters (81)
• Sculpture (12)
• Shock Theater (3)
• Shuler Hensley (6)
• Silent Films (8)
• Studies (9)
• The Munsters (5)
• Theater (34)
• Toys (12)
• Warren Magazines (21)
• Young Frankenstein: Musical (7)

Frankenstein Image Blog!

They Say...

"Outstanding, must-read. A mind blowing treasure trove of all things fantastically Frankenstein."— The Horrors of It All

“A wonderful blog, as fun as it is informative, and always well written and designed… always teaches me something or sharpens my focus on some detail or other.”— Tim Lucas, Video WatchBlog

“I continue to be amazed, amused, delighted, and awed by Pierre Fournier's blog, Frankensteinia…No one does it better."— Susan Tyler Hitchcock, author of Frankenstein, A Cultural History, Monster Sightings

“Beautiful and evocative writing style… as near perfect a Frankenstein experience as I could wish for. Bravo!"— Jeff Cohen, Vitaphone Varieties

“Inestimable… Mind-opening"—
Arbogast on Film

“Intelligent and well-presented… avid in seeking out a wide range of examples... A useful research aid for those seeking to survey the uses to which the Frankenstein monster is still being put in popular culture.”— Intute, Arts & Humanities

“Outstanding and intelligent… I am insane with giddiness that "It's ALIVE!!"

— Max, The Drunken Severed Head

Blogs

• And Everything Else Too
• arts•meme
• Bibi
• Big V Riot Squad
• Cinebeats
• Countdown to Halloween
• Dwrayger Dungeon
• El Desván del Abuelito
• Fantasy Ink
• Final Girl
• Greenbriar Picture Shows
• Here Lies Richard Sala
• io9
• Kindertrauma
• MONSTER CRAZY!
• Monsterminions
• Pappy's Golden Age Comics
• Scared Silly
• Shadowplay
• The Chiseler
• The Collinsport Historical Society
• The Horrors of It All
• The Pneumatic Rolling-Sphere Carrier Delusion
• This isn't happiness
• Tim Lucas Video WatchBlog
• Voyages Extraordinaires
• Wrong Side of the Art

Websites

• Creepy Classics & Monster Bash
• Fantasia Festival
• Frankenstein Films
• George Chastain
• Official Boris Karloff Home Page
• Rue Morgue
• The Official Hammer Films Site
• The Rondo Awards
• The Spooky Isles

Forums

• Classic Horror Film Board
• Universal Monster Army
• Latarnia Forums

All content on this site is copyrighted and/or trademarked, and all rights are reserved by the respective authors. Text posted here may not be reproduced or reblogged without permission. Visuals and references are presented here as quotes under Fair Use for the purpose of scholarship, information or review.