How To Get A Three-star Island Evaluation In New Horizons Explained

If you click on a link and make a purchase we may receive a small commission. Read our editorial policy.

Island evaluations will help you build your perfect isle in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. Each one includes a star rating, which is a hint towards how popular your island is with visitors.

When you first unlock island evaluations your goal will be to achieve a three-star rating for your island. This will allow you to unlock a variety of rewards, including terraforming.

So pull up those weeds and start crafting outdoor furniture - it's time to make your island beautiful!

On this page:

• Island evaluations and star rating in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained
• How to get an island evaluation in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained
• Benefits of raising your star rating in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained
• How to get your island to a three-star rating in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained

Island evaluations and star rating in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained

An island evaluation in New Horizons is a short report Isabelle will give you about how visitors feel about your island. Each island evaluation will include a star rating for your island, which ranges from one, being the lowest, to five, being the highest.

As part of your island evolution, Isabelle will offer you some advice on how to improve your star rating. This could be anything from having more villagers move to your island to putting down more fencing.

Following her advice to the letter will result in your island gaining a higher star ranking and, if you pay enough attention, then you will eventually gain a five-star rating.

Your star rating is determined by the amount of the following factors on your island:

• Bridges
• Fencing
• Flowers
• Furniture placed outside (and variety of)
• Inclines
• Trees (cedar, fruit and normal)
• Villagers living on island
• Weeds

Except for weeds, which you must pull up, you can improve your island ranking by placing more of these factors on your isle. It's also a good idea to keep your island nice and tidy, which you can achieve by not leaving items, like trash or turnips, on the ground.

Animal Crossing: New Horizons: 17 Advanced Tips and Tricks for Your Island Watch on YouTube

How to get an island evaluation in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained

If you want to have your island evaluated in New Horizons, then you must first upgrade Residential Services from a tent to the town hall.

Once you've done that, Isabelle will move to your island and will offer you a range of new services in the town hall.

One of these is island evaluation, which you can access by choosing the option, 'Let's talk island evals.' when talking to her. This will provide you with both your star ranking and advice on how to improve it.

Benefits of raising your star rating in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained

There are three main benefits of raising your star rating in New Horizons; you gain two of them when you reach a three-star level and the third when you achieve a five-star rating.

For three-stars, you'll unlock the Island Designer app, which allows you to terraform your island, and KK Slider, the dog-uitarist, will begin to visit your island once a week.

When you achieved a five-star rating, you'll earn the DIY recipe for the Golden Watering Can, which you can use to create Gold Roses, an exclusive flower.

Animal Crossing: New Horizons version 3.0 is on its way! It will bring Zelda items, LEGO items, Splatoon items and NES games. While you wait, make sure your Museum is full of fish and bugs. Cooking, meanwhile, will let you make some tasty gifts for your villagers. If your island needs decorating, why not add some Gyroids, flowers or fruit? Don't forget to make sure you've got every tool though and that your home is up to Happy Home Academy standards. There's also your Happy Home Paradise restort too!

How to get your island to a three-star rating in Animal Crossing: New Horizons explained

Once you've upgraded Residential Services and built the campsite, your next goal will probably be to unlock terraforming by achieving a three-star rating. The way you do this is by following Isabelle's advice when you ask her about island evaluations.

If you're having trouble raising to a three-star level, here's what my island had when I achieved a three-star ranking:

• Eight villagers
• 27 pieces of furniture outside with no duplicates
• 50 pieces of fencing
• Two bridges
• Two inclines
• A variety of fruit trees and flowers from different islands

My island was also free of weeds and didn't have any trash or items, like tools or turnips, on the ground.

This may differ for you depending on how you've been playing New Horizons, but, if you're stuck, then these figures are a good goal to aim for, especially with the number of villagers.

Good luck raising your star ranking!

Read this next

• Animal Crossing: New Horizons springs back to life next year with Switch 2 Edition, major free content update, and Lego collaboration
• Nintendo wants you to literally put your foot into Animal Crossing with upcoming Crocs collaboration
• Super Mario Wonder, Captain Toad and Wario sets join Nintendo Lego range

Latest On Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Feature | What we've been playing - "I would throw the dumbbells at a perfect vertical angle and close my eyes"

All villagers in Animal Crossing New Horizons

All flowers and hybrids in Animal Crossing New Horizons

Animal Crossing New Horizons New Year's Eve Event guide

Animal Crossing New Horizons Toy Day event guide

How to get Santa Outfit in Animal Crossing New Horizons

How to complete Jingle's Tasks in Animal Crossing New Horizons

How to get Jingle's Photo in Animal Crossing New Horizons

Latest News

• Here's Hideo Kojima interviewing himself, and interviewing Stranger Things' creators, the Duffer Brothers (but not at the same time)
• Final Fantasy 14 fans fear feline fancy Jonathan Bailey's fame is impacting his performance, as 7.4's "gruff" G'raha Tia sounds off
• Dave the Diver's In The Jungle DLC will make substantial changes, with Animal Crossing sim mechanics and a new restaurant
• We're never going to get those cut Dispatch sex scenes because "they never tangibly existed"
• Vin Diesel-starring Ark 2 now slated for 2028 release
• Sony and Honda's new vehicle will let passengers play PS5 games via Remote Play
• Marathon art lead departs Bungie of his own volition, ahead of game's new release date

Latest Guides

• How to find Tomo's lost cat in The Forge
• Endzone Strike codes
• Go Pass Winter Holiday 2025 in Pokémon Go
• Pokémon Go Winter Holiday Part 1 field research tasks and bonuses
• How to complete the Goblin King quest in The Forge
• Upcoming video games and January 2026 releases
• All Crimson Blaze Secret Missions in Pokémon TCG Pocket

Top Discussions

• What we've been playing - "I would throw the dumbbells at a perfect vertical angle and close my eyes" 189
• New report claims Xbox Wrapped 2025 isn't happening this year due to marketing budget constraints 81
• Indie Game Awards disqualifies Game of the Year winner Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 for using AI 69
• Epic boss Tim Sweeney confirms Fortnite will not release on iOS in Japan due to Apple's alleged "obstruction and lawbreaking" 29
• PBA Pro Bowling 2026 is an earnest, accurate sports sim that feels like it fell out of 2010. I love it 13
• Battlefield 6 tweaks "vehicle availability" across Breakthrough maps for attackers and defenders 2