Dr. Elizabeth Weir - MUSINGS OF A SCI-FI FANATIC

Home » Why Was Elizabeth Weir Recast » Dr. Elizabeth Weir - MUSINGS OF A SCI-FI FANATIC

Maybe your like

Saturday, February 9, 2008

Dr. Elizabeth Weir

The recent reshuffling news on Stargate Atlantis alerts fans to the latest casualty. After two solid announcements concerning the casting of 'regulars' Robert Picardo and Jewel Staite it was reported that the lovely Torri Higginson who played Dr. Elizabeth Weir will not return for Season 5 of the show. The news comes amidst a swirl of strained relations after Higginson was not properly picked up as a 'regular' for Season 4. Higginson had signed a 6 year deal when she was cast in 2004 and made her first appearance on Stargate SG-1. Here is Jessica Steen playing Dr. Elizabeth Weir in the character's first appearance on SG-1 for Lost City Part 1 at the end of Season 7. Jessica Steen (Earth 2) was lovely, but fortunately the creators had the good sense to recast the role and give the part to Higginson who infused the complex part with a touch more finesse. Higginson was perfect for the part. Would the real Dr. Elizabeth Weir please step forward? This was Higginson's first appearance at the start of Season 8 in New Order Part 1. I was a bit tentative initially about her part, but the actress expertly handled command. Stargate Atlantis showed a great deal of promise with Higginson at the helm. Higginson had these comments (taken from Gateworld): "The very last day of filming Season 3 as I finished filming the last scene on the last day, I was called up to the office and was told that my character was going to become recurring if I chose to be, so, I thought that was not a very dignified way to deal with it, and I was a bit surprised. So my reaction was -- I was a little bit surprised. I was a little bit upset by how it was dealt with" (extracted from DTRN's Sci Fi Guys Internet radio program). To quote Weir in the first clip above, "well there's gonna be a lot of changes and not everyone's gonna be happy about them." Steen discovered this after just two episodes. Unfortunately, Higginson, too, sees the character part come to a close. Coupled with the loss of Amanda Tapping from the show as a regular, Tapping will make appearances, the latest blow results in losing Higginson completely. There was indeed a sexy, commanding coolness about her and I will miss her presence on Stargate Atlantis. Her role was noticeably absent in Season 4, and from the sounds of it, the relationship between her and the creators ends on a sour note. It doesn't appear she'll be back.Still, does Jonas Quinn ring a bell? Michael Shanks came back from the wilderness following his own grievances. It's certainly unlikely for Higginson, but never say never in science fiction. Update: Higginson made an appearance on Joseph Mallozzi and Paul Mullie's Dark Matter (2015-present). Given Mallozzi and Mullie's connection to Stargate SG-1, Stargate Atlantis and Stargate Universe it would seem time does indeed heal all wounds. Posted by at 11:22 PM Labels: Stargate, Stargate Atlantis, Stargate SG-1

16 comments:

Falcon Horus said...

As a proud member of the Save Elizabeth Weir campaign, I support Torri's decision not to reprise her role as Dr. Elizabeth Weir on Stargate Atlantis' season 5 a full 100%.

February 10, 2008 at 10:45 AM SFF said...

I would agree. I really don't care for how she was demoted on the show. As much as I like Picardo, I would prefer to have my cake and eat it too. Clearly it has to do with the writers/ creators. I certainly would love to know more regarding why the character/ actress was handled this way. I can understand her decision completely despite selfishly preferring to see her recur than not at all. Her character will be missed.

February 10, 2008 at 10:56 AM Anonymous said...

Thanks for the article. I'm a supporter of Torri and loved her portrayal of Weir. She will be very missed. But I hope Torri does get to move on and we'll see her again soon.

February 10, 2008 at 12:21 PM SFF said...

Thanks for the input eri13. It's nice to see I'm not the only one who really grew to love her performance.

February 10, 2008 at 12:34 PM Anonymous said...

Words can't describe how disappointed I am to see Elizabeth go. I'm sure TPTB will just kill her off again, off camera, just out of spite.The way they've dealt with Torri Higginson is a disgrace. Anyone in a 'normal' industry would be able to sue their employers. Instead, Torri has to put up with one of the showrunners gloating on his own blog about how he was one of the people who decided to dump her, and how proud he is of that decision.Why should she comes back? I hope they're scared now. They've lost Torri for good, and even they must realise she's a drawcard, or they wouldn't have asked her back. They were using her for ratings spikes and to string her fans along. Not anymore. Torri's put an end to that, and I'm so proud of her.They're also scared about Amanda going. Every Carter fan who came over to SGA from SG1 just to see Carter will leave with Amanda. They don't like the show. It was of no interest to them before, and it'll be of no interest to them once Amanda's gone.These idiots have screwed up bigtime. I predict once Atlantis gets its magical 100th episode, it'll be history. And the showrunners will deserve to be out of work.

February 10, 2008 at 12:38 PM SFF said...

Clearly there are strong feelings here and something doesn't smell right about her handling to be certain. Despite appearances that things were mishandled and I hope to learn why she was relegated to this status, I do want Stargate Atlantis to prosper just the same. I loved SG-1. I love this show's many threads and cast as well. I can't say that I hope it tanks despite being very disappointed with the treatment of Torri. She clearly made the right choice rather than being dangled out there with regard to her status. If she was a draw for the show why did they make this move back in Season 3? This is unfortunate.

February 10, 2008 at 12:49 PM Unknown said...

They lost me in S3, when they started disrespecting Elizabeth. In a way, I guess it mirrors their treatment of Torri. I'm certainly sad she's gone. Atlantis isn't the same without its leading lady and leader. The cast was a family, and now 2 of them are gone. This isn't the show I grew to love more than SG1. I wish Torri all the best. She deserves to bring her quiet strength to a show that will appreciate it.

February 10, 2008 at 2:51 PM Anonymous said...

Thanks for putting this up...I loved the character of Weir, and even though I was originally disappointed that Steen wasn't going to play her in Atlantis, it took me 'til about 10 mins into 'Rising' to join the ranks of Torri Higginson's fans! I'm gutted that Weir's no longer going to be part of SGA as I thought the decision to reduce her was a big mistake, but it was the writers' decision to make, and they must've known when they did that they were running the risk of not being able to get her back whenever they wanted. I completely support Torri's decision, and to be absolutely honest, I'm glad she seems to be cutting ties with the show once and for all - I don't think I could've taken another season of hanging on and hoping the writers would see fit to bring her back for more than a brief appearance. Although I wish the fans of the show the best, for me all the reshuffling and changes have put me off following it any further down the road. Such is the way things go, though!

February 10, 2008 at 3:00 PM Anonymous said...

Interesting entry and blog. I've bookmarked it to explore later. =)I'm also a member of the Save Elizabeth Weir campaign and I'm chiming in with support for Torri. I've watched SGA season 4 so far, and without Torri as Dr. Weir, the dynamic that I loved between the characters has been shattered. I've liked a few episodes, but most of them--in my opinion--are lackluster. And we're going to get yet another major cast change? I wish SGA well, but I fear my enjoyment of it is nearing an end. Which is a real shame, because it used to be my favorite show.And all the best wishes to Torri! She had a guest spot on NCIS this season and I hope she gets a recurring role, and/or other great offers soon.

February 10, 2008 at 3:02 PM SFF said...

I'm shocked based on this small sample they would let Higginson slip away. I had heard mixed feelings on Tapping's role as leader. Obviously Picardo will be a gamble, but I'm willing to give him a chance since he certainly has nothing to do with the creative decisions that were made back in S3. As much as I loved Staite on Firefly I would easily request to have Higginson back over Staite. I guess that seems to speak volumes for alot of our SA fanbase. We all seemed to already have missed her strong, unique leadership style and the latest announcement was the dagger in the heart. I submit that I will still roll with the changes. Thanks for the support Nik, Mariel and all for the conversation.

February 10, 2008 at 3:47 PM Anonymous said...

I missed Torri in season 4. I don't care much for the cast anymore especially McKay. Carter was a big miss for me this year....no sure I will tune in anymore after those executive idiots messed up the cast! Why could they not dump McKay?

March 4, 2008 at 8:33 AM SFF said...

I must admit it is interesting to see the fan backlash on some of the decisions made by executives regarding Atlantis. I don't hate McKay, but I agree I would very much like to see Weir return but that seems a distinct impossibility at this point.

March 4, 2008 at 4:44 PM Anonymous said...

Please bring Torri back. Tapping was dull and had none of the qualities that Torri brought to the show. The show runners now have Picardo as the S5 leader, me fears S5 will be the last.

March 18, 2008 at 9:52 AM SFF said...

I know what you mean. As much as I enjoy Amanda Tapping and she was one of the reasons I loved SG-1. This wasn't SG-1. This was Stargate Atlantis and I felt Torri really owned that role. It was a better fit for me as well. I do hope Season 5 surprises folks and we're looking at another Big 10.

March 19, 2008 at 11:23 AM AuralArch said...

I know I'm over a decade late in this conversation, but…I actually preferred Steen and always thought it was a mistake to replace her with Higginson, constantly imagining how much better a number of crappy scenes would've been with the original actor.I wasn't much of a McKay fan either, even though I like Hewlett. The writers made his character so annoying far too often.And as a villain, aside from Todd, the wraith were really monodimensional, boring and pathetic! Seriously, I think they could have come up with better.There were some fantastic episodes of Atlantis, but IMO it was the weakest SG series by far.

September 14, 2018 at 6:30 PM Anonymous said...

Torri higginson was absolutely fantastic. She would have made a starship captain on trek that would have rivaled any of them. Horrible decision to make that change. Seriously one of my all time favorite characters and she was absolutely great

February 18, 2025 at 2:33 PM

Post a Comment

Newer Post Older Post Home Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

"I've seen things you people wouldn't believe... All those moments will be lost in time"

My photo SFF Somewhere Out There With The Truth, United States View my complete profile

Transmute Search Engine Into Fiery Phoenix Search Engine

Battle Of The Planets

Battle Of The Planets

All Those Posts Lost In Time Like Tears In Rain

  • Battle Of The Planets: The Characters "T he characters were ... dynamic.... They each had distinct personalities, which were not always so easily defined. Mark could be ras...
  • Battle Of The Planets E18: Mad New Ruler Of Spectra "W ho wants a horse-machine race?" -Tiny Harper-   "T hey're not mechanical horses. They're galloping dynamite...
  • Battle Of The Planets Vs. Gatchaman "A lways five acting as one. Dedicated! Inseparable! Invincible!" We sure could use a little more collective, inseparable think...
  • The Wish I f you had one wish that could affect one of your favorite science fiction series substantively or technically for the better what would it...
  • The Sci-Fi Fanatic BIG 10: Babylon 5 I give you the second official Sci-Fi Fanatic BIG 10 list! You know I love lists. As a result, I've come up with the official title, ...
  • The Killer F inally took time out to tackle Director John Woo's much lauded, highly acclaimed The Killer [1989]. It's been one of those films ...
  • SciFiNow: Babylon 5: Ten Of The Best I ran across a Babylon 5 Ten Of The Best article over at SciFiNow by James Rundle. You know my love for top ten lists knows no bounds. I...
  • Carter & O'Neill: Anatomy Of An SG-1 Love Story L ittle story about Jack and Miss Sam, two American kids growin' up in the heartland. Yes, you can imagine concocting lyrics to the cla...
  • B5 S4 Ep9: Atonement G'Kar is fitted with a SUPER BIONIC EYE and Minbari fit new Babylon 5 head of security Zack Allen with a new station uniform.... Zack...
  • Thompson Twins: Here's To Future Days T here are CDs and then THERE ARE CDs! Thompson Twins ' Here's To Future Days [1985] continues my ongoing series of looking back at...

Space:1999

Space:1999

The Incredible Hulk

The Incredible Hulk

Transmute! To Enjoy These Blogs

  • The Art of Manliness The Most Popular AoM Articles and Podcast Episodes of 2025 1 day ago
  • John Kenneth Muir's Reflections on Cult Movies and Classic TV Sears Wish Book: 1979 1 day ago
  • Robert's Anime Corner Blog March Anime Releases From Sentai and Crunchymation - Now Up for Pre-Order! 4 days ago
  • My Star Trek Scrapbook Rare Photos 6 4 weeks ago
  • Radiator Heaven Angel Heart 1 month ago
  • Star Trek - Sci Fi Blog. JERI TAYLOR - STAR TREK WRITER AND PRODUCER DIES AGED 86 1 year ago
  • The Film Connoisseur Zombieland Double Tap (2019) 6 years ago
  • Cinematic Wonders Short Peace (2013) 6 years ago

Blade Runner

Blade Runner

The Science Fiction Directory

  • 007 James Bond (4)
  • 100 The (3)
  • 12 Monkeys (1)
  • 70s & 80s Film Classics (1)
  • 80s Music Plus (24)
  • Alien Abduction Films (11)
  • Allen Irwin (7)
  • American Gods (1)
  • Anderson Paul W.S. (10)
  • Anime (165)
  • Another Life (1)
  • Area 88 (1)
  • Ascension (4)
  • Attack On Titan (1)
  • Babylon 5 (145)
  • Babylon 5 Books (6)
  • Babylon 5 Movies (5)
  • Babylon 5 Music Video (15)
  • Babylon 5 S1 (11)
  • Babylon 5 S2 (15)
  • Babylon 5 S3 (23)
  • Babylon 5 S4 (23)
  • Babylon 5 S5 (23)
  • Baker Tom (6)
  • Battle Of The Planets (46)
  • Battlestar Galactica (25)
  • Battlestar Galactica Classic (13)
  • Battlestar Galactica Classic S1 (4)
  • Battlestar Galactica S1 (7)
  • Battlestar Galactica: Blood And Chrome (1)
  • Before And After (2)
  • Big 10 (19)
  • Bixby Bill (20)
  • Blade Runner (3)
  • Blue Submarine No.6 (2)
  • Buck Rogers In The 25th Century (8)
  • Buck Rogers In The 25th Century S1 (4)
  • Caprica (4)
  • Carnivale (2)
  • Carpenter John (3)
  • Casshan (4)
  • Classic TV / Film Appearances (6)
  • Colony (3)
  • Continuum (2)
  • Courtship Of Eddie's Father The (6)
  • Cowboy Bebop (30)
  • Creature Double Feature (16)
  • Dark Matter (4)
  • Debris (1)
  • Defiance (9)
  • Defiance S1 (2)
  • Defying Gravity (3)
  • Doctor Who (43)
  • Doctor Who The Christopher Eccleston Year 2005 (5)
  • Doctor Who The David Tennant Years (1)
  • Doctor Who The Peter Capaldi Years 2013-2017 (1)
  • Doctor Who The Tom Baker Years 1974-1981 (8)
  • Dogs (9)
  • Ergo Proxy (8)
  • Expanse The (17)
  • Expanse The S1 (10)
  • FAB Friday (104)
  • Falling Skies (17)
  • Falling Skies S1 (15)
  • Fancave (14)
  • Farscape (21)
  • Farscape S1 (14)
  • Fear The Walking Dead (3)
  • Firefly (9)
  • Force Five (4)
  • Fringe (14)
  • Fringe S1 (10)
  • Gaiking (5)
  • Gamera (7)
  • Gamera Showa (5)
  • Gatchaman (15)
  • Ghost In The Shell (7)
  • Ghost In The Shell: SAC (1)
  • Gibson Mel (4)
  • Godzilla (23)
  • Godzilla Showa (10)
  • Grizzly Adams The Life And Times Of (2)
  • Gurren Lagann (9)
  • Harryhausen Ray (2)
  • Helix (1)
  • Henriksen Lance (8)
  • Herzog Werner (2)
  • Hill Walter (1)
  • Hitchcock Alfred (1)
  • Holiday (51)
  • Honda Ishiro (16)
  • Horror (3)
  • Hulk The Incredible (25)
  • Hulk The Incredible S1 (12)
  • I Remember That (11)
  • Into The Badlands (1)
  • Jericho (2)
  • Johnny Sokko And His Flying Robot (1)
  • Jovovich Milla (8)
  • Kaiju Eiga (31)
  • Kawajiri Yoshiaki (4)
  • King Stephen (3)
  • Kitakubo Hiroyuki (2)
  • Knights Of Sidonia (11)
  • Knights Of Sidonia S1 (10)
  • Koike Takeshi (2)
  • Land Of The Giants (8)
  • Land Of The Giants S1 (5)
  • Land Of The Lost (5)
  • Land Of The Lost S1 (4)
  • Little House On The Prairie (5)
  • Little Rascals (1)
  • Longmire (2)
  • LOST (28)
  • Lost In Space (51)
  • Lost In Space (Netflix) (11)
  • Lost In Space S1 (29)
  • LOST S1 (25)
  • Mad Max (2)
  • McShane Ian (10)
  • Millennium (17)
  • Miyazaki Hayao (5)
  • Moore Ronald (1)
  • Murase Shukou (1)
  • Neon Genesis Evangelion (7)
  • Nihei Tsutomu (1)
  • Ninja Scroll (1)
  • Oshii Mamoru (1)
  • Otomo Katsuhiro (6)
  • Outlander (1)
  • Pacific Rim (11)
  • Painting (6)
  • Patlabor (1)
  • Pigs In Space (8)
  • Protectors The (3)
  • Random Thoughts (107)
  • Redline (2)
  • Remembered The (79)
  • Resident Evil (7)
  • Rintaro (2)
  • Russell Kurt (3)
  • Sackhoff Katee (1)
  • Sci-Fi Books (24)
  • Sci-Fi Comics (25)
  • Sci-Fi Films (118)
  • Sci-Fi Goodies (2)
  • Sci-Fi Magazines (9)
  • Sci-Fi Non-Fiction (108)
  • Sci-Fi Quotes (5)
  • Sci-Fi Ships (2)
  • Sci-Fi Soundtracks (7)
  • Sci-Fi Themes (11)
  • She Blinded Me With Science-Fiction (2)
  • Shinkai Makoto (2)
  • Six Million Dollar Man The (11)
  • Six Million Dollar Man The S1 (5)
  • Snyder Zack (3)
  • Space Above And Beyond (1)
  • Space:1999 (48)
  • Space:1999 Year One (18)
  • Spaceships (11)
  • Star Blazers (5)
  • Star Trek (92)
  • Star Trek Books (4)
  • Star Trek Dolls (23)
  • Star Trek Films (6)
  • Star Trek: Discovery (1)
  • Star Trek: DS9 (2)
  • Star Trek: TNG (28)
  • Star Trek: TNG S1 (18)
  • Star Trek: TOS (17)
  • Star Trek: TOS S1 (12)
  • Star Trek: Voyager (1)
  • Star Wars (9)
  • Stargate (87)
  • Stargate Atlantis (14)
  • Stargate Atlantis S1 (2)
  • Stargate SG-1 (40)
  • Stargate SG-1 S1 (12)
  • Stargate Universe (38)
  • Stargate Universe S1 (17)
  • Stargate Universe S2 (1)
  • Starlog Magazine (1)
  • Studio Gainax (10)
  • Studio Ghibli (3)
  • Studio Gonzo (1)
  • Swamp Thing (1)
  • Tales From The Loop (1)
  • Tatsunoko (40)
  • Terminator (6)
  • Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles (7)
  • The Greatest American Hero (2)
  • The Office (4)
  • Thunderbirds (29)
  • Thunderbirds S1 (11)
  • Time Tunnel The (1)
  • Toho Studios (4)
  • Top _ Lists (56)
  • Travel (5)
  • Twilight Zone The (3)
  • UFO (27)
  • UFO S1 (10)
  • V (5)
  • Virtuality (1)
  • Voyage To The Bottom Of The Sea (2)
  • Voyage To The Bottom Of The Sea S1 (1)
  • Walken Christopher (2)
  • Walking Dead The (2)
  • Walking Dead The: World Beyond (1)
  • War Genre (1)
  • Watchmen (1)
  • Wonder Woman (2)
  • World According To Jack O'Neill The (8)
  • Worst In Science Fiction (7)
  • X-Files The (17)
  • X-Files The S1 (2)
  • X-Files The S2 (2)
  • Year End Retrospective (7)
  • Yun-Fat Chow (2)

Knights Of Sidonia

Knights Of Sidonia

The Dead Sea Scrolls

  • ▼  2008 (152)
    • ▼  February (10)
      • B5 S1 Ep 1-4: Midnight On The Firing Line, Soul Hu...
      • Insiders [SG-1's Clone Wars]
      • Rescue Dawn
      • Midway [a.k.a. The Wraith Spanking]
      • Forsaken [or how I learned to stop worrying and lo...
      • Jericho Season 1
      • Dr. Elizabeth Weir
      • Dr. Jennifer Keller
      • Richard Woolsey
      • Sanctuary: The Series

Gamera

Gamera "Your visual imagination is unsurpassed! I look at your blog posts and those illustrations...and my jaw drops. You have a way not just with words, my friend, but with pictures!""One of my favorite bloggers in the known universe [and in the Uncharted Territories]."-John Kenneth Muir on Musings Of A Sci-Fi Fanatic-_____________________________ "I always enjoy what you have to say and really dig your blog. With so many horror genre-centric blogs, it's great to see one exclusively devoted to science fiction."-Radiator Heaven on Musings Of A Sci-Fi Fanatic-_______________________________ "What a blast! Your blog....made my day." -Mateo Latosa [Powys Media] on Musings Of A Sci-Fi Fanatic- _______________________________ "... fun and perceptive analysis..." -Matthew Bradley of Bradley On Film on Musings Of A Sci-Fi Fanatic- _______________________________ "I've long enjoyed your site and the lovingly meticulous reviews therein!" -Sean Gill [Junta Juleil's Culture Shock] on Musings Of A Sci-Fi Fanatic- _______________________________ "splendid insights... discerning and thorough examination." -Lazy Thoughts From A Boomer on Musings Of A Sci-Fi Fanatic- _______________________________ "A truly kind gentleman who has a great website that inspired me to do half as well as his work." -Secure Immaturity on Musings Of A Sci-Fi Fanatic- _____________________________ "I just discovered your blog ... but I have to say it was well worth finding."-Roman J. Martel, Roman's Movie Reviews And Musings-________________________________

Back To Frank Black: A Return To Chris Carter's Millennium

Back To Frank Black: A Return To Chris Carter's Millennium On Sale Kindle, Hardcover or Paperback

Stargate Atlantis

Stargate Atlantis

Sci-Fi Fanatics

Tag » Why Was Elizabeth Weir Recast